Scuola Superiore St. Anna and Istituto di Chimica Biologica,
University of Pisa, Italy
 |
I. Introduction |
A. The ryanodine receptor
The ryanodine receptor (RyR)c corresponds
to the sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) Ca2+ channel (Inui et
al., 1987
; Imagawa et al., 1987
). Its structure and function have been
reviewed recently (Fleischer and Inui, 1989
; Lai and Meissner, 1989
;
McPherson and Campbell, 1993a
; Sorrentino and Volpe, 1993
; Coronado et
al., 1994
; Meissner, 1994
; Ogawa, 1994
; Sorrentino, 1995
; Wagenknecht
and Radermacher, 1995
; Marks, 1996
; Sutko and Airey, 1996
), and only a
few issues will be recalled here.
The RyR binds specifically the plant alkaloid ryanodine, which is the
reason for its name. In striated muscle, RyRs are located at the
triadic junctions between SR terminal cisternae and sarcolemmal T-tubules (Fleischer et al., 1985
) and correspond to the "feet" structures observed in electron microscope images within the triads. However, RyRs also have been identified in SR structures that do not
lie in contiguity with the sarcolemma, such as corbular and expanded
junctional SR, and in intracellular membranes of other cells and
tissues, such as brain, smooth muscle, endothelium, liver, and
fibroblasts (Franzini-Armstrong and Jorgensen, 1994
; Meissner, 1994
).
The RyR has been purified, cloned, and sequenced from a variety of
species, and several isoforms have been identified. Mammalian tissues
express three isoforms, known as RyR1, RyR2, and RyR3. They include
about 5000 (4872 to 5037) amino acid residues and are encoded by three
different genes. In humans, the three genes are located on chromosomes
19, 1, and 15, respectively. RyR1 and RyR2 are expressed predominatly
in skeletal muscle and in cardiac muscle, respectively (Marks et al.,
1989
; Takeshima et al., 1989
; Nakai et al., 1990
; Otsu et al., 1990
;
Zorzato et al., 1990
). RyR3 has a wide tissue distribution (Ledbetter
et al., 1994
; Giannini et al., 1995
), although it has been originally
identified in brain (Hakamata et al., 1992
) and is sometimes called
"brain isoform." All three isoforms are actually expressed in
brain, and the major brain isoform does not appear to be RyR3, but
rather RyR2 (Witcher et al., 1992
; McPherson and Campbell, 1993b
;
Murayama and Ogawa, 1996b
). Alternative splicing variants of RyR1 and
RyR2 have been identified, but their functional relevance remains to be
established (Sutko and Airey, 1996
). Two RyR isoforms, known as
-RyR
and
-RyR, have been identified in fish, amphibian, and avian
skeletal muscle (Airey et al., 1990
, 1993b
; Olivares et al., 1991
;
Sutko et al., 1991
; Lai et al., 1992
; Murayama and Ogawa, 1992
), and they are the homologues of mammalian RyR1 and RyR3, respectively (Oyamada et al., 1994
; Ottini et al., 1996
). The overall identity of
the RyR isoforms is of the order of 66 to 67%.
The RyR monomer has a sedimentation coefficient of about 30S and a
molecular weight of about 560 kDa. The functional receptor is thought
to be a homotetramer, which has a quarterfoil shape and a size of 22 to
27 nm on each side (Inui et al., 1987
; Lai et al., 1988
; Wagenknecht et
al., 1989
). The center of the quarterfoil includes a pore, with a
diameter of 1 to 2 nm, that most likely represents the Ca2+
channel. There is structural and functional evidence that the central
channel is connected to four radial channels included in the peripheral
portion of each monomer (Wagenknecht et al., 1989
; Ding and Kasai,
1996
). Near its cytoplasmic end, the channel appears to be blocked by a
mass, sometimes referred to as the "plug," that might be involved
in the modulation of channel conductance. The pore region corresponds
to the carboxy-terminal portion of each RyR monomer and includes,
according to different suggested models, four (Takeshima et al., 1989
;
Nakai et al., 1990
; Hakamata et al., 1992
) or 10 to 12 (Zorzato et al.,
1990
; Otsu et al., 1990
) transmembrane segments. Results obtained with
site-specific antibodies (Grunwald and Meissner, 1995
) support the
four-transmembrane segment model, whereas cryoelectron microscopy data
(Serysheva et al., 1995
; Wagenknecht and Radermacher, 1995
) favor the
10-transmembrane segment model. The rest of the molecule forms a large
extramembrane region that corresponds to the foot structure, has a
hollow appearance, and includes at least two domains in each monomer
(Serysheva et al., 1995
). Recent observations suggest that the channel
opening is associated with a 4° rotation of the transmembrane with
respect to the cytosolic region (Orlova et al., 1996
).
The channel included in the RyR is a cation-selective channel with low
cationic selectivity and large unitary conductance. With
Ca2+ as current carrier, the maximum conductance was equal
to 80 pS for the cardiac channel, and to 172 pS for the skeletal muscle channel, with a dissociation constant
3 to 4 mM
(Smith et al., 1988
; Lindsay and Williams, 1991
). The maximum
conductance was higher with monocations as current carriers, e.g.,
about 0.6/1 nS with Na+ and K+, respectively
(Smith et al., 1988
; Liu et al., 1989
). Although in single salt
solutions, channel conductance was higher for monocations than for
Ca2+, in mixed salts, channel permeability was higher for
Ca2+ than for monovalent cations. This finding has been
interpreted on the basis of a model in which multiple ion-binding sites
are arranged sequentially, assuming that Ca2+ binding is
favored over monocation binding. In particular, a four-barrier,
three-binding-site model might account for the experimental results
(Tinker et al., 1992b
; Tinker and Williams, 1992
, 1993c
).
The RyR mediates the efflux of Ca2+ from the SR or other
intracellular stores. In striated muscle, it has a central role in excitation-contraction coupling, i.e., in the coupling between sarcolemmal depolarization and SR Ca2+ release.
There are at least two mechanisms that have been proposed to mediate
excitation-contraction coupling. According to the direct-coupling model, SR Ca2+ release is produced by a direct interaction
between the dihydropyridine and the RyRs. In particular, sarcolemmal
depolarization is thought to produce a conformational change in the
dihydropyridine receptor that is transmitted to the RyR and induces the
release of Ca2+ from the SR (Rios and Pizarro, 1991
; Rios
et al., 1993
; Schneider et al., 1994
). In this model, the
dihydropyridine receptor acts primarily as a voltage sensor rather than
as a channel, because sarcolemmal calcium influx is not required for
excitation-contraction coupling. Close contiguity between the ryanodine
and dihydropyridine receptors has been shown by morphological studies
(Block et al., 1988
) and confirmed by biochemical investigations (Marty
et al., 1994
), although it is still uncertain whether other proteins
that are closely associated with the dihydropyridine and RyRs (see below, II.A.7.) may play a role in the coupling process.
Alternatively, excitation-contraction coupling might be mediated by a
process known as Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release
(Fabiato, 1983
). Because the SR channel is activated by an increase in
cytosolic [Ca2+] (see below, II.A.1.a.), the sarcolemmal
Ca2+ current, although insufficient to activate the
contractile process directly, could induce further release of
Ca2+ from the SR. This process may be favored by the
existence of Ca2+ gradients in the cytosol, because
Ca2+ ions entering the cell through the dihydropyridine
receptor seem to have preferential access to the RyR, establishing a
sort of "functional coupling" (Cannell et al., 1995
; Sham et al.,
1995
).
The relative importance of these two mechanisms is still controversial.
There is evidence that in skeletal muscle, the former (i.e., direct
coupling) is sufficient to induce tension development, whereas in
cardiac muscle, Ca2+ influx is necessary for contraction,
and Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release is thought to be
the dominant mechanism (Näbauer et al., 1989
; Callewaert, 1992
;
Stern, 1992
; Meissner, 1994
). Consistently, morphological data suggest
closer association of dihydropyridine and RyRs in skeletal muscle than
in cardiac muscle (Sun et al., 1995
). However, a large fraction of
skeletal muscle RyRs are not associated with dihydropyridine receptors
(Franzini-Armstrong and Jorgensen, 1994
), and it has been suggested
that Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release might also
contribute to skeletal muscle activation (Anderson and Meissner, 1995
;
Yano et al., 1995b
; Klein et al., 1996
).
It is still uncertain whether the different modes of
excitation-contraction coupling are related to differences in the RyR, in the dihydropyridine receptor, or in other components. Experiments performed in dysgenic myotubes with chimeric dihydropyridine receptors suggested that specific regions of the skeletal muscle dihydropyridine receptor (included between transmembrane repeats II and III) determine the appearance of skeletal-type excitation-contraction coupling (Tanabe
et al., 1990
). This conclusion has not been supported by the results of
another study (Lu et al., 1994
), in which peptides including the
putative cytoplasmic loops between transmembrane repeats II and III of
skeletal and cardiac dihydropyridine receptors were expressed in
Escherichia coli, because both types of peptides activated
the skeletal but not the cardiac RyR, suggesting that the type of
excitation-contraction coupling was determined by the RyR.
B. Study of Ryanodine Receptor Modulation
In recent years, the RyR has emerged as the target of
pharmacological interventions, and RyR alterations have been implicated in the pathogenesis of several diseases. These issues will be the
object of the present review.
A brief description of the techniques used in the study of RyR
modulation may be useful. Special emphasis will be given to the assay
of Ca2+ release, to single channel studies, and to
[3H]ryanodine binding experiments. Results obtained with
indirect techniques will also be mentioned whenever they add valuable
information.
1. Ca2+ release studies.
In Ca2+
release experiments, SR vesicles are loaded with labeled or unlabeled
Ca2+ by passive diffusion or by active uptake.
Ca2+ release is then induced by exposing the SR to a
release solution, and its kinetics are determined. If free
Ca2+ concentration is assayed by metallochromic indicators,
the increase in extravesicular Ca2+ concentration can be
monitored after rapid mixing of the preparation with release buffer
(stopped flow technique) (Yamamoto and Kasai, 1982
; Kim et al., 1983
;
Nagasaki and Kasai, 1983
; Ikemoto et al., 1989
). If 45Ca is
used, residual vesicle radioactivity must be measured at different time
points. This can be accomplished with rapid quenching (Meissner, 1984
,
1988
; Ikemoto et al., 1985
; Meissner et al., 1986
; Meissner and
Henderson, 1987
) or rapid filtration techniques (Dupont, 1984
; Submilla
and Inesi, 1987
; Chiesi et al., 1988
; Moutin and Dupont, 1988
;
Calviello and Chiesi, 1989
).
The kinetics of Ca2+ release are interpolated by an
exponential curve, so that the release rate is described by a rate
constant that is independent from the extent of Ca2+
loading and from intravesicular Ca2+ concentration. Under
physiological conditions, the rate constant of SR Ca2+
release is of the order of 20 to 60 sec
1,
corresponding to a half-life of 10 to 35 msec. An accurate evaluation of SR Ca2+ release requires, therefore, a temporal
resolution in the millisecond range, which is usually achieved through
automatized or semi-automatized devices.
2. Single-channel studies.
SR vesicles or purified RyRs are
incorporated into artificial lipid bilayers, which separate two ionic
solutions. Incorporation of a channel in the bilayer is shown by the
appearance of a current flowing between the two chambers (Coronado et
al., 1992
). The chamber to which channels are added is called
cis chamber; the other one is called trans
chamber. Channel incorporation is usually polar, so that the cytosolic
face corresponds to the cis chamber. Current recordings show
spontaneous openings and closures and are used to calculate the
conductance of the channel and its open probability, that is, the
fractional time during which the channel is open, henceforward designed
as Po. Channel gating is described on the basis of mathematical models
that assume the existence of one or more open state(s) and one or more
closed state(s). Statistical techniques provide a detailed evaluation
of channel gating. The usual approach (lifetime analysis) consists in
determining the time constant of each state, which is linearly related
to its mean lifetime (Ashley and Williams, 1990
; Jackson, 1992
). Increased current may be due to increased conductance of the open channel or to increased Po. The latter can be due either to increased lifetime of the open channel or to decreased lifetime of the closed channel, also referred to as increased frequency of channel opening.
Under physiological conditions, the behavior of the RyR has been
described by models including two or three closed states and two open
states (Smith et al., 1986b
; Ashley and Williams, 1990
). With higher
temporal resolution, up to three open and five closed states have been
described recently for the cardiac channel (Sitsapesan and Williams,
1994b
). Further complexity has been introduced by the observation that
steady-state recordings show sequences of bursts of either low or high
Po, suggesting the existence of different gating modes, as already
described for other ion channels (Armisen et al., 1996
). Channel gating
and conductance are temperature-dependent: at low temperature the
conductance decreased, while the Po increased owing to increased
lifetime of the open channel, and the net result was an increased
Ca2+ current (Sitsapesan et al., 1991
).
A limitation of this technique is the relatively short duration of the
recordings (about 30 min), so that it may be difficult to study
equilibrium effects.
3. [3H]ryanodine binding.
The production of
radiolabeled ryanodine (Pessah et al., 1985
; Sutko et al., 1986
)
introduced a new approach in the study of RyR structure and function.
High affinity binding of [3H]ryanodine to the RyR has
been extensively characterized. In a variety of tissues, the
dissociation constant (KD) for
[3H]ryanodine was in the low nanomolar range. The Hill
coefficient was
1, and the kinetic KD,
i.e., the ratio of the dissociation and association constants, was
close to the equilibrium KD (Pessah et al.,
1985
, 1986
; Michalak et al., 1988
; Lai et al., 1989
; McGrew et al.,
1989
; Holmberg and Williams, 1990a
; Carroll et al., 1991
; Pessah and
Zimanyi, 1991
). High affinity [3H]ryanodine binding was
correlated to the functional state of the Ca2+ channel.
Conditions that are associated with increased channel Po usually
favored [3H]ryanodine binding, suggesting that ryanodine
binds to the open channel. However, exceptions to this rule have been
described, and this issue will be further discussed in section II.C.
The RyR also shows low affinity binding sites. Pessah and Zimanyi
(1991)
identified four different binding sites, with
KD in the range of 1 to 4 nm, 30 to
50 nM, 500 to 800 nM and 2 to 4 µM, respectively. The Hill coefficient for the low
affinity sites was < 1, suggesting that low affinity binding
reflect a negative cooperative interaction between four identical
sites. Consistent with this hypothesis, the association rate decreased at high [3H]ryanodine concentration (Buck et al., 1992
;
Zucchi et al., 1995a
). Complex findings were obtained with regard to
ryanodine dissociation. Some investigators observed a higher
dissociation rate at high [3H]ryanodine concentration
(Pessah and Zimanyi, 1991
; Zucchi et al., 1995a
), in accordance with
negative cooperativity. However, the dissociation rate of nanomolar
[3H]ryanodine decreased in the presence of micromolar
unlabeled ryanodine (McGrew et al., 1989
; Lai et al., 1989
; Chu et al., 1990a
; Pessah and Zimanyi, 1991
; Zimanyi et al., 1992
). The latter finding, originally regarded as evidence of positive cooperativity (McGrew et al., 1989
), has been interpreted by assuming that occupancy of low affinity sites lead to a slow, possibly irreversible change of
the receptor (Pessah and Zimanyi, 1991
; Zimanyi et al., 1992
).
In some studies, the ratio of low-affinity to high-affinity binding
sites was close to 3, in accordance with the tetrameric model of the
RyR (Lai et al., 1989
). However, in other reports, the ratio was
substantially higher, in the range of 10 to 100 (Inui et al., 1987
,
1988
; McGrew et al., 1989
; Pessah and Zimanyi, 1991
; Buck et al., 1992
;
Zucchi et al., 1995a
). Wang et al. (1993)
obtained a ratio close to 1 using either heavy SR or purified RyR, whereas the ratio was close to 6 in a T-tubule preparation. These authors suggested that high-affinity
and low-affinity binding involve different sites, and that the
low-affinity site may not be exclusive to the RyR and also may exist on
associated proteins.
It should be stressed that the investigations involving low affinity
[3H]ryanodine binding should be interpreted with great
care, because an accurate determination of the binding site density
(Bmax) is technically difficult, and confidence intervals
are always large.
4. Indirect studies.
RyR function often has been evaluated
indirectly. For instance, tension development by skinned cells or
intact preparations after exposure to caffeine or after rapid cooling
has been regarded as an index of SR Ca2+ release. Although
such techniques may produce useful results, their limitations should be
kept in mind. The contractile response can be affected by actions at
the contractile protein level, and both caffeine and rapid cooling have
multiple targets besides the RyR (Akera, 1990
; Feher and Rebeyka,
1994
). Similar considerations apply to the analysis of changes in
intracellular Ca2+ concentration (Ca2+
transients), which are affected by other sarcolemmal or intracellular Ca2+ transport systems, and by Ca2+ binding to
intracellular proteins.
Another indirect approach is the measurement of oxalate-supported
Ca2+ uptake in the presence and in the absence of SR
channel blockers. The rationale of this approach is that, because
oxalate is accumulated into the SR, oxalate-supported Ca2+
provides a measurement of net SR Ca2+ uptake, even in crude
preparations, and represents the difference between active
Ca2+ transport by the Ca2+-adenosine
triphosphatase (ATPase) and passive Ca2+ efflux through the
RyR (Feher and Lipford, 1985
). Therefore, the stimulation of
oxalate-supported Ca2+ uptake after RyR blockade can be
considered as an index of SR Ca2+ efflux (Feher et al.,
1989
; Limbruno et al., 1989
). A limitation of this approach is that the
distribution of RyRs between the vesicles produced after SR
fragmentation is not homogeneous (Jones and Cala, 1981
; Feher and
Lipford, 1985
). Changes in such a distribution, possibly produced by
different homogenization and fractionation procedures, or by altered
physical-chemical properties of the SR membrane, might bias the results
obtained with this technique. Besides, the assumption of negligibility
of Ca2+ release by passive diffusion or by reversal of the
ATPase reaction might not be justified, especially under pathological
conditions.
 |
II. Modulation of the Ryanodine Receptor |
Many substances can modulate RyR function. In this section
(section II.), endogenous (physiological) and exogenous
(pharmacological) modulators are distinguished, and their mechanisms of
action are discussed. For the sake of clarity, the former subsection
also includes ions that are not physiological cell components, but whose action is related closely to that of endogenous ions. A comprehensive summary of the effects of the chief endogenous and pharmacological modulators on Ca2+ release, single-channel
gating, and [3H]ryanodine binding is provided in tables
1 and 2, respectively.
A. Endogenous Modulators
1. Ions.
a. CA2+.
Ca2+ has major
importance in the regulation of the RyR, and it is thought to be the
"physiological" channel activator, because other ligands cannot
activate the channel in the absence of Ca2+, or they
require Ca2+ for maximum effect. Ca2+ efflux
studies have shown a bell-shaped relationship between Ca2+
release and extravesicular Ca2+ concentration.
Ca2+ release was negligible at pCa < 9, reached a
maximum around pCa = 5, and decreased at millimolar
Ca2+ concentration (Kim et al., 1983
; Kirino et al., 1983
;
Nagasaki and Kasai, 1983
; Chamberlain et al., 1984a
; Meissner, 1984
;
Meissner et al., 1986
; Rousseau et al., 1986
; Meissner and Henderson,
1987
; Submilla and Inesi, 1987
; Moutin and Dupont, 1988
; Calviello and Chiesi, 1989
; Donoso and Hidalgo, 1993
). In order to explain the biphasic response to Ca2+, it has been suggested that the
RyR contains a high-affinity Ca2+ binding site, which
stimulates Ca2+ release, and a low-affinity
Ca2+ binding site, which inhibits Ca2+ release.
At physiological concentrations of Mg2+ and adenine
nucleotides, the activating action of Ca2+ was cooperative,
with Hill coefficient close to 2 and EC50
2 µM. In the absence of Mg2+ and nucleotides,
the EC50 was lower (0.5 µM), and the Hill
coefficient was close to 1 (Meissner et al., 1986
). The
IC50 for Ca2+ inhibition of Ca2+
release has been estimated to be of the order of 120 to 150 µM, with a Hill coefficient > 1 (Nagasaki and
Kasai, 1983
; Meissner et al., 1986
). Recent results have shown that the
sensitivity to Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release was
about 10 times lower for RyR3 than for the other isoforms (Takeshima et
al., 1995
).
Indirect studies suggested that Ca2+ release may be
modulated also by intraluminal Ca2+ (Ikemoto et al., 1989
;
Nelson and Nelson, 1990
). Consistently, in rabbit SR, the rate of
Ca2+ release increased with luminal Ca2+
concentration according to a hyperbolic relationship (EC50 = 260 µM), and similar results were obtained in frog SR,
except that the relationship was sigmoidal (Donoso et al., 1995
). Single-channel recordings have confirmed the results of the release
experiments. Channel Po was regulated by the concentration of
Ca2+ in the cis chamber. The EC50
was in the micromolar range, so that channel Po was close to zero at
nanomolar Ca2+ concentration, and maximum activation was
observed at concentrations in excess of 100 µM. In the
presence of Ca2+ alone, higher Po values were obtained in
cardiac than in skeletal muscle, but full channel activation could not
be produced in either tissue. Detailed analysis of single-channel data
suggested the existence of at least two open states and two or three
(in skeletal and cardiac muscle, respectively) closed states of the
channel. The major effect of Ca2+ was a decrease in the
lifetime of the closed states and/or a shift from short-lived closures
to long-lived closures, although increased lifetime of the open channel
was occasionally observed (Rousseau et al., 1986
; Smith et al., 1986b
;
Ma et al., 1988
; Rousseau and Meissner, 1989
; Ashley and Williams,
1990
; Fill et al., 1990
, 1991b
; Lee et al., 1991
; Bull and Marengo,
1993
; Chu et al., 1993
; Shomer et al., 1993
; Ma and Zaho, 1994
). The effect of high cis Ca2+ on channel Po is
still controversial. In some experiments, Po did not saturate at high
Ca2+ concentration (Smith et al., 1986b
; Ashley and
Williams, 1990
), whereas other investigators reported inhibition of Po
by millimolar cis Ca2+, with IC50
300 to 500 µM and Hill coefficient = 1.3 (Ma et al., 1988
; Fill et al., 1990
, 1991b
; Bull and Marengo, 1993
; Shomer et
al., 1993
; Ma and Zaho, 1994
). Chu et al. (1993)
suggested that channel
inhibition at high Ca2+ is a property of skeletal, but not
of cardiac, muscle. However, Laver et al. (1995)
have reported recently
that Ca2+ can inhibit both the skeletal and the cardiac
channel, although with different affinity (IC50 = 0.7 mM and 15 mM, respectively). Ca2+
inhibition was the most labile characteristic of cardiac RyR, because
it was lost in the presence of 500 mM cis
Cs+ and after
3-[(3-cholamidopropyl)dimethylammonio]-1-propane-sulfonate solubilization. The latter observations might account for the discrepancies mentioned above. In rat brain, three different gating patterns have been identified, suggesting that they may correspond to
different RyR isoforms (Marengo et al., 1996
): channels with high Po,
not inhibited by Ca2+ (up to 500 µM);
channels with high Po, inhibited by Ca2+ with
IC50 = 152 µM; and channels with low Po and
low IC50 (
26 µM). In frog skeletal
muscle, two populations of channels have been distinguished on the
basis of inhibition or lack of inhibition by millimolar
Ca2+ (Murayama and Ogawa, 1992
; Bull and Marengo, 1993
). In
chicken skeletal muscle,
-RyR was more sensitive to inhibition by
millimolar Ca2+ than was
-RyR (Percival et al., 1994
). Several studies have evaluated the effect of trans
Ca2+ on channel gating. High (> 100 to 200 µM) trans Ca2+ was reported to
decrease channel Po (Ma et al., 1988
; Fill et al., 1990
), but other
investigators (Sitsapesan and Williams, 1994a
, 1995a
) observed that an
increase in luminal Ca2+ favored channel activation by
adenine nucleotides and sulmazole, and that millimolar trans
Ca2+ was needed for a maximum effect. Tripathy and Meissner
(1996)
have observed recently that the effect of trans
Ca2+ was voltage-dependent: at negative (cis
minus trans) holding potentials, submillimolar (
250 µM) trans Ca2+ increased channel
Po, and the effect decreased at higher concentrations. At positive
holding potentials, 5 to 10 mM trans
Ca2+ was needed to activate the channel. On the basis of
the response to other cations and to Ca2+ buffers, the
authors concluded that luminal Ca2+ modulate the Po by
diffusing through the channel and interacting with Ca2+-
activation and Ca2+-inactivation sites located on the
cytosolic side. Binding experiments have shown that high affinity
[3H]ryanodine binding is strictly
Ca2+-dependent. In skeletal muscle (Pessah et al., 1985
,
1987
; Michalak et al., 1988
; Bull et al., 1989
; Chu et al., 1990a
;
Holmberg and Williams, 1990a
; Ogawa and Harafuji, 1990a
,b
; Zimanyi
and Pessah, 1991a
; Chu et al., 1993
; Shomer et al., 1993
; Fruen et al.,
1994a
), the Ca2+ dependence of [3H]ryanodine
binding was bell-shaped, with the peak in the 10 µM to
100 µM range. Micromolar Ca2+ favored
[3H]ryanodine binding by increasing both the affinity and
the Bmax. The KDCa= dissociation
constant for Ca2+ (KDCa) was in the
low micromolar range (in the absence of Mg2+ and adenine
nucleotides), and the Hill coefficient for Ca2+-stimulation
was close to 2, suggesting a cooperative effect of Ca2+ on
[3H]ryanodine binding. Kinetic analysis revealed that
Ca2+ increased the rate of [3H]ryanodine
association, whereas the dissociation rate was not affected (Chu et
al., 1990a
).Similar results have been obtained in cardiac tissue (Pessah et al.,
1985
; Seifert and Casida, 1986
; Alderson and Feher, 1987
; Anderson et
al., 1989
; Holmberg and Williams, 1990a
; Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991a
),
although cardiac [3H]ryanodine binding was less sensitive
to inhibition by high Ca2+ concentrations (Michalak et al.,
1988
; Chu et al., 1993
; Fruen et al., 1994a
). In brain microsomes, the
Ca2+ sensitivity of ryanodine binding was higher than in
striated muscle, (Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991b
; Padua et al., 1994
), and
similar results were obtained with bullfrog
-RyR, which is thought
to be homologue to mammalian RyR3 (Murayama and Ogawa, 1996b
). In fish
skeletal muscle, the chief functional difference between the
and
isoforms of the RyR was that the latter did not show any decrease
of [3H]ryanodine binding at high Ca2+
concentration (O'Brien et al., 1995
). Ca2+ might also affect the equilibrium between
high-affinity and low-affinity binding sites. In purified RyR1, the
decrease in [3H]ryanodine binding observed at nanomolar
Ca2+ concentration was associated with a compensatory
increase in low affinity binding (Lai et al., 1989
), but in cardiac
microsomes, Ca2+ had no effect on low-affinity
[3H]ryanodine binding (Zucchi et al., 1995a
). Several investigators have attempted to identify the molecular sites
involved in Ca2+ binding. On the basis of RyR1 primary
structure, Takeshima et al. (1989)
identified three putative
Ca2+ binding sites at residues 4253 to 4264, 4407 to 4416, and 4489 to 4499, whereas Zorzato et al. (1990)
predicted that residues 1873 to 1923 included a low-affinity Ca2+ binding site.
Immunological studies helped to identify the epitopes involved in the
Ca2+-dependent modulation of RyR1. Fill et al. (1991a)
showed that channel Po was decreased by antibodies reacting with
epitopes in the regions 4445 to 4586 and 4760 to 4877. Treves et al.
(1993)
confirmed that antibodies interacting with epitopes in the
region 4380 to 4625 blocked the Ca2+-activating domain. By
using fusion proteins and sequence-specific antibodies, Chen et al.
(1994)
suggested that the binding site involved in channel activation
was located between residues 4489 and 4499. In RyR2, high-affinity
Ca2+ binding has been tentatively attributed to regions
1336 to 1347 and 2010 to 2021, whereas in RyR3, Ca2+
binding might involve residues 3934 to 3945 (Nakai et al., 1990
; Hakamata et al., 1992
).The stimulation of Ca2+ release by micromolar
Ca2+ is the basis of the mechanism known as
Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release (Fabiato, 1983
),
whereas the physiological relevance of Ca2+-dependent
inactivation is a controversial issue. Because Ca2+-induced
Ca2+ release is a positive-feedback process, the existence
of mechanisms able to terminate Ca2+ release is necessary.
Fabiato (1985)
originally suggested that Ca2+ release might
be limited by Ca2+ binding to an inactivation site
characterized by higher affinity and lower association rate than the
Ca2+-activation site. Subsequent investigations have shown
that the time course of Ca2+ transients might be explained
by such a model only assuming an IC50 in the range of 0.2 to 0.8 µM (Kwok and Best, 1991
; Simon et al., 1991
;
Delbono, 1995
; Garcia and Schneider, 1995
), which is much lower than
the IC50 observed in single-channel studies and release
studies.In other ionic channels, inactivation is a voltage-dependent
phenomenon. The existence of voltage-dependent inactivation of the RyR
is controversial. Sitsapesan et al. (1995b)
and Percival et al. (1994)
observed inactivation at positive holding potential, whereas a similar
phenomenon occurred at negative holding potential in the experiments
performed by Ma (1995)
. In any case, voltage-dependent inactivation is
unlikely to have any physiological relevance, because the SR potential
is close to zero during Ca2+ release, owing to the large SR
conductance to K+.A peculiar response to Ca2+, called adaptation, has been
described in studies involving transient changes in Ca2+
concentration. The sudden increase in Ca2+ concentration
produced by the photolysis of caged Ca2+ caused, in a few
milliseconds, channel activation, which was greater than observed under
steady-state conditions, but was followed by a spontaneous decrease in
channel Po, even if Ca2+ concentration remained elevated.
Contrary to classical inactivation, the ability to respond to a
second Ca2+ stimulus was preserved (Györke and Fill,
1993
; Györke et al., 1994
; Yasui et al., 1994
). A similar
response has been described with different channel activators (Dettbarn
et al., 1994b
), and kinetic models of adaptation have been developed
(Tang and Othmer, 1994
; Cheng et al., 1995
; Sachs et al., 1995
). The
rate constant of Po decay was in the range of seconds, so that the
process was too slow to account for the physiological modulation of
Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release, but it has been
suggested that adaptation may be faster in vivo, due to the presence of
Mg2+ (Valdivia et al., 1995b
). However, the results
obtained with the photolysis of caged Ca2+ have not been
reproduced in bilayer experiments after quick solution exchange.
Sitsapesan et al. (1995b)
could not show any adaptation process,
whereas Laver and Curtis (1996)
observed a time-dependent decrease in
Po (rate constant: 0.5 to 15 sec), but they were unable to reactivate
the channel by a new Ca2+ stimulus.As an alternative to inactivation and adaptation,
Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release might be limited
simply by the diffusion of Ca2+ away from the
Ca2+-activation sites (Stern, 1992
). Recent observations
have shown that the rate constant of such a process, tentatively named
deactivation, was in the millisecond range (Schiefer et al., 1995
),
and, therefore, it was quick enough to account for the physiological
modulation of Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release.
b. MG2+.
The effect of Mg2+ is
quite the opposite of the effect of Ca2+. In release
experiments, Mg2+ inhibited Ca2+ -induced
Ca2+ release (Kim et al., 1983
; Kirino et al., 1983
;
Nagasaki and Kasai, 1983
; Chamberlain et al., 1984a
; Meissner, 1984
;
Meissner et al., 1986
; Meissner and Henderson, 1987
; Rousseau et al.,
1986
; Submilla and Inesi, 1987
; Moutin and Dupont, 1988
; Calviello and Chiesi, 1989
). In skeletal muscle, the IC50 was of the
order of 20 µM at 1 µM Ca, and of 70 to 200 µM at 10 µM Ca2+, and the Hill
coefficient was > 1, suggesting a cooperative effect (Meissner,
1984
; Meissner et al., 1986
; Moutin and Dupont, 1988
). Cardiac RyR was
less sensitive to Mg2+ inhibition, because IC50
values in excess of 300 µM were observed at 10 µM free Ca2+, with Hill coefficient
1.5 (Meissner and Henderson, 1987
). Adenine nucleotides made the
channel less sensitive to Mg2+ inhibition. In skeletal
muscle, Mg2+-inhibition of Ca2+ release
appeared to be modulated by depolarization, which decreased (by more
than 10-fold) the Mg2+ affinity of the RyR, or at least of
the RyRs functionally coupled to dihydropyridine receptors (Lamb and
Stephenson, 1994
; Ritucci and Corbett, 1995
).In single-channel experiments, millimolar Mg2+ reduced
channel Po by increasing the lifetime of the closed channel (Rousseau et al., 1986
; Smith et al., 1986a
,b
, 1988
; Hymel et al., 1988
; Lai et
al., 1988
, 1992
; Ma et al., 1988
; Anderson et al., 1989
; Holmberg and
Williams, 1989
, 1990a
; Liu et al., 1989
; Ashley and Williams, 1990
;
Ogawa and Harafuji, 1990a
; Lindsay and Williams, 1991
). In addition, in
cardiac muscle, Mg2+ accelerated the kinetic of RyR
adaptation (Valdivia et al., 1995b
). Mg2+ inhibited ryanodine binding by reducing the
Bmax and increasing the KD
(Pessah et al., 1985
, 1986
, 1987
; Michalak et al., 1988
; Chu et al.,
1990a
; Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991a
). The latter effect was due to a
reduced association rate, while the dissociation rate was unchanged.
Mg2+ also affected the Ca2+ dependence of
Ca2+ release by shifting the activation curve to the right.
Ryanodine binding studies confirmed that the sensitivity to
Mg2+ was higher in skeletal than in cardiac muscle (Pessah
et al., 1985
; Seifert and Casida, 1986
; Michalak et al., 1988
; Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991a
). For instance, with 1 nM
[3H]ryanodine and optimal Ca2+ concentration,
the IC50 was 0.45 mM versus 2 mM
(Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991a
). In brain tissue, the sensitivity to
Mg2+ was even lower than in the heart (IC50 = 10.4 mM) (Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991b
).On a molecular level, it has been suggested that Mg2+
competitively displaces Ca2+ from its putative stimulatory
site(s). There is also evidence that Mg2+ may interact with
the low-affinity Ca2+ inhibitory site (Coronado et al.,
1994
).
c. H+.
Ca2+-induced
Ca2+ release and [3H]ryanodine binding are
pH-sensitive (Meissner, 1984
; Sumbilla and Inesi, 1987
; Ma et al.,
1988
; Michalak et al., 1988
; Rousseau and Pinkos, 1990
; Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991b
; Donoso and Hidalgo, 1993
). The optimal pH was usually around 7.2 to 8.0, but higher values were occasionally reported both in
release (Meissner and Henderson, 1987
) and in binding studies (Valdivia
et al., 1990b
). In single-channel experiments, the relationship between
cis pH and Po was more complex, with two peaks at
pH = 7.2 to 7.6, and at pH = 8.5. The effect of
H+ was highly cooperative, and it was due to a shift in the
relative occurrence of short-lived versus long-lived openings (Ma et
al., 1988
; Ma and Zaho, 1994
). On the other hand, acidification of the
trans chamber led to reduction in channel conductance
(Rousseau and Pinkos, 1990
).
d. OTHER CATIONS.
Fe2+ has been reported to
inhibit Ca2+-induced and doxorubicin-induced
Ca2+ release (IC50 = 14 to 29 µM), whereas Fe 3+ was ineffective (Kim et
al., 1995
). [3H]ryanodine binding was also inhibited, due
to decreased sensitivity to activation by Ca2+. It was
suggested that Fe2+ may compete with Ca2+ at
the activator site of the channel complex, whereas lipid peroxidation did not appear to be involvedAs to other cations, Ba2+, Cd2+, and
La2+ inhibited [3H]ryanodine binding (Kirino
et al., 1983
; Pessah et al., 1985
; Seifert and Casida, 1986
). A
biphasic response was observed with Ln3+ and
Tb3+, which was attributed to interaction with the
Ca2+-activating and Ca2+-inactivating sites
(Hadad et al., 1994
).
e. ANIONS.
Inorganic phosphate can activate the
skeletal muscle RyR (Fruen et al., 1994a
,b
). In skeletal muscle SR,
millimolar phosphate favored [3H]ryanodine binding, by
decreasing the KD, while the
Bmax was unchanged (EC50 = 4 mM).
Phosphate affected the Ca2+-dependence of ryanodine binding
by increasing the IC50 for Ca2+. Release
experiments and bilayer recordings confirmed that millimolar phosphate
increased the rate constant of Ca2+ release and channel Po.
As to other anions, sulfate and arsenate were ineffective, whereas
thiocyanate, iodide, nitrate, and vanadate had a similar effect,
suggesting that these anions interact with a common and specific anion
binding site. Although Fruen et al. (1994a)
reported that phosphate and
related anions were ineffective in cardiac tissue, other investigators
described a stimulation of Ca2+ release by inorganic
phosphate in saponin-treated rat cardiac trabeculae (Smith and Steele,
1992
) Perchlorate is a modulator of excitation-contraction coupling. At 10 to
100 mM concentration, perchlorate-induced SR
Ca2+ release from skeletal muscle SR, increased channel Po
in bilayer experiments, and increased the affinity of ryanodine binding
in a Ca2+-dependent way (Gallant et al., 1993
; Ma et al.,
1993
; Fruen et al., 1994b
; Yano et al., 1995a
). The response to
perchlorate was not affected by the thiol-reducing agent
dithiothreitol, suggesting that sulfhydryl oxidation was not involved.
It has been speculated that the effect of perchlorate may be due to its
chaotropic action, i.e., to dissociation of protein complexes into
subunits (Ma et al., 1993
). Alternatively, because the action of
perchlorate was similar to that of phosphate and other anions,
perchlorate might act on the putative RyR anion binding site (Fruen et
al., 1994b
). Whereas high concentrations of perchlorate affected the
RyR directly, lower (< 10 mM) concentrations activated
Ca2+ release in a voltage-dependent way and required the
presence of complete triads. Therefore, the latter effect has been
attributed to interference with T tubule/junctional SR signal
transmission, and its molecular mechanism is uncertain (Yano et al.,
1995a
). Lactate affected skeletal muscle RyR independently of any pH change
(Favero et al., 1995b
). In particular, 10 to 20 mM lactate decreased single-channel Po and ryanodine binding. Unlike other anions,
lactate decreased the Bmax and did not affect the
KD. Cl
can modulate SR Ca2+ release. According to
Sukhareva et al. (1994)
, the rate of Ca2+ release was
maximum when Cl
was included both in the luminal and in
the release solution, although either luminal Cl
alone or
extravesicular Cl
alone were stimulatory. On the other
hand, Allard and Rougier (1994)
, who included Cl
in the
intravesicular buffer, reported inhibition of Ca2+ release
by extravesicular Cl
. In single-channel experiments,
Cl
did not affect Ca2+ fluxes, and its
effects on Ca2+ release were attributed to activation of a
nonselective Cl
channel localized in junctional SR. This
channel was blocked by ruthenium red and clofibric acid (Sukhareva et
al., 1994
), and its physiological role has not been established.
f. IONIC STRENGTH AND OSMOLARITY.
Buffers with high
ionic strength stimulate [3H]ryanodine binding by
increasing the Bmax. In skeletal muscle, the
Bmax increased by more than 10-fold to 12-fold in the
presence of 1 M versus 100 mM NaCl or KCl
(Michalak et al., 1988
; Chu et al., 1990a
; Ogawa and Harafuji, 1990b
;
Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991a
,b
; Padua et al., 1994
). Because sucrose was
as effective as KCl or NaCl, the effect should be attributed to
osmolarity rather than to ionic strength (Ogawa and Harafuji, 1990b
).
The stimulation of ryanodine binding produced by Ca2+,
caffeine, or adenine nucleotides and the inhibition produced by
millimolar Ca2+ and Mg2+ was much greater at
low ionic strength than at high ionic strength. The sensitivity to
ionic strength may be different in different RyR isoforms: in binding
experiments, bullfrog skeletal muscle
-RyR showed a higher
Ca2+ sensitivity than
-RyR at high (1 M
NaCl) but not at low (0.17 M NaCl) ionic strength (Murayama
and Ogawa, 1996a
). Release experiments confirmed that a medium with
high ionic strength modified the permeability of the channel, and
neutral molecules such as glucose could not permeate through the SR
Ca2+ channel, even in the open state, unless submolar
concentrations of KCl were present (Kasai et al., 1992
; Kasai and
Kawasaki, 1993
).
2. Nucleotides.
Adenine nucleotides activate the RyR.
Ca2+ release studies performed in skeletal muscle
(Morii and Tonomura, 1983
; Nagasaki and Kasai, 1983
; Meissner, 1984
;
Meissner et al., 1986
; Sumbilla and Inesi, 1987
; Moutin and Dupont,
1988
; Calviello and Chiesi, 1989
; Wyskovsky et al., 1990
; Donoso and
Hidalgo, 1993
) have shown that in the presence of adenine nucleotides,
Ca2+ release occurred, even at nanomolar Ca2+
concentration and/or in the presence of Mg2+. The
Ca2+-activation curve was shifted to the left, and the
maximum rate of Ca2+ release was increased. In fact, full
activation of Ca2+ release required the presence of both
Ca2+ and nucleotides. The EC50 for adenine
nucleotides was in the millimolar range at all Ca2+
concentrations, and the Hill coefficient was close to 2 (Meissner et
al., 1986
). In cardiac muscle, the effect of adenine nucleotides was
qualitatively similar, although less remarkable (Rousseau et al., 1986
;
Meissner and Henderson, 1987
). The order of potency was adenosine
5'-(
,
-methylene)triphosphate (AMP-PCP) > cyclic AMP (cAMP) > adenosine diphosphate (ADP) > adenosine monophosphate (AMP), while
nonadenine nucleotides, such as cytosine triphosphate (CTP), guanosine
triphosphate (GTP), inosine triphosphate (ITP), and uridine
triphosphate (UTP) were ineffective (Morii and Tonomura, 1983
;
Meissner, 1984
). In cardiac muscle, adenosine and adenine were also
effective (Meissner, 1984
), whereas in skeletal muscle, Ca2+ release was produced by adenine but not by adenosine
(Rousseau et al., 1988
).
In single-channel experiments, millimolar concentrations of adenine
nucleotides increased channel Po. In particular, adenine nucleotides
increased the lifetime of the open channel and decreased the lifetime
of the closed channel, without affecting the conductance of the open
channel. Micromolar Ca2+ and millimolar adenine nucleotide
together elicited persistent channel opening, with Po close to 1 (Smith
et al., 1985
, 1986b
, 1988
; Hymel et al., 1988
; Lai et al., 1988
, 1992
;
Rousseau et al., 1986
; Anderson et al., 1989
; Holmberg and Williams,
1989
, 1990a
; Liu et al., 1989
; Rardon et al., 1989
; Ashley and
Williams, 1990
; Lindsay and Williams, 1991
). Activation of the sheep
cardiac channel was produced also by millimolar adenosine (McGarry and Williams, 1994b
).
Consistently, millimolar concentrations of adenine nucleotides,
diadenosine polyphosphates, and adenine favored ryanodine binding by
increasing the Bmax and decreasing the
KD, the latter effect being accounted for by an
increased association rate (Pessah et al., 1987
; Michalak et al., 1988
;
Chu et al., 1990a
; Ogawa and Harafuji, 1990a
,b
; Zimanyi and Pessah,
1991a
; Zarka and Shoshan-Barmatz, 1993
; Holden et al., 1996
). The
Ca2+-sensitivity of ryanodine binding was either unchanged
or slightly increased. Binding experiments confirmed that the
sensitivity to adenine nucleotides was higher in skeletal than in
cardiac muscle (Michalak et al., 1988
; Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991a
).
Peculiar results were obtained in brain, where ryanodine binding was
enhanced by 1 mM ATP and inhibited by higher ATP
concentrations (Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991b
).
Adenine nucleotides appear to interact with a molecular site that is
different from, although interacting with, the Ca2+-binding
and Mg2+-binding site. Sequence analysis identified two
putative nucleotide binding sites in RyR1 and two to four similar sites
in RyR2 and RyR3. All these sites contain the nucleotide binding motif
GXGXXG. Using a photoaffinity analog of ATP, Zarka and Shoshan-Barmatz (1993)
labeled the putative adenine nucleotide binding site of RyR1,
observing a molar ratio of 1:1 with the tetrameric RyR, but the
presence of lower-affinity sites could not be definitely excluded.
3. Cyclic adenosine diphosphate-ribose.
Cyclic ADP-ribose
(cADPR) is an endogenous metabolite of nicotinamide-adenine
dinucleotide (NAD), which is thought to act as a second-messenger in
several tissues (Clapper et al., 1987
; Lee et al., 1989
). In sea urchin
eggs, nanomolar cADPR induced Ca2+ release from
intracellular stores. Its action was independent from inositol
1,4,5-trisphosphate, was inhibited by ruthenium red and endogenous
polyamines, and was potentiated by Ca2+, ryanodine, and
caffeine (Galione et al., 1991
, 1993a
,b
; Galione and White, 1994
; Lee
et al., 1993
; Chini et al., 1995
). On the basis of these observations,
it has been suggested that cADPR activates the RyR. However, other
findings have questioned this conclusion. In sea urchin eggs,
Ca2+ release showed peculiar properties, because it was
dependent on the presence of calmodulin (Lee et al., 1994
, 1995
; Tanaka and Tashjian, 1995
), and it was not activated by ATP (Graeff et al.,
1995
). In addition, the cADPR derivative 8-amino-cADPR antagonized cADPR-induced, but not ryanodine-induced, Ca2+ release
(Walseth and Lee, 1993
). Finally, photoaffinity labeling studies showed
that cADPR binds to two proteins of 100 kDa and 140 kDa (Walseth et
al., 1993
), and it is not known whether such proteins interact with the
RyR or rather represent a novel type of Ca2+ channel. It
should be stressed that RyR expression has not been extensively studied
in sea urchin eggs. Antibodies raised against RyR1 identified a 380-kDa
protein that has not been further characterized (McPherson et al.,
1992
). More recently, Ca2+-sensitive and caffeine-sensitive
[3H]ryanodine binding has been described in a preliminary
report, but no modulation by cADPR and ATP has been detected (Lokuta et al., 1996
).
cADPR induced intracellular Ca2+ release in many other
tissues and cell types, including neurons, pituitary cells, pancreatic
cells, pancreatic and lacrimal acinar cells, vascular smooth muscle, heart and skeletal muscle preparations, lymphoma cells, and
plant vacuoles (Koshiyama et al., 1991
; Currie et al., 1992
; Meszaros et al., 1993
; Morrissette et al., 1993
; Takasawa et al., 1993
;
White et al., 1993
; Hua et al., 1994
; Thorn et al., 1994
; Allen et al.,
1995
; Bourguignon et al., 1995
; Gromada et al., 1995
; Kannan et al.,
1996
). Evidence of RyR modulation has been reported by some
investigators. In lymphoma cells, 1 µM cADPR increased
the affinity for [3H]ryanodine by five-fold (Bourguignon
et al., 1995
). In cardiac SR, 1 to 2 µM cADPR increased
[3H]ryanodine binding and single-channel Po, but only at
submicromolar (10 to 100 nM) Ca2+
concentrations. A similar action was observed in brain, but not in
skeletal muscle microsomes (Meszaros et al., 1993
). However, the latter
results have not been confirmed by other investigators. Fruen et al.
(1994c)
did not observe any effect of cADPR on
[3H]ryanodine binding nor any change in single-channel
Po, either in heart or in skeletal muscle. Sitsapesan and coworkers
(1994
, 1995b
) reported activation of cardiac (1994)
and skeletal muscle (Sitsapesan and Williams, 1995b
) ryanodine-sensitive channels by
1 µM cADPR, but this action occurred only at high
(micromolar) Ca2+ concentration, was shared by ADPR and
-NAD+, and was not detected in the presence of
physiological concentrations of ATP and Mg2+. These authors
concluded that cADPR interacts with the adenine nucleotide binding
site. They also stressed that the physiological tissue concentration of
cADPR, that is, 20 to 600 nM, according to Walseth et al.
(1991)
, is too low to exert any effect, even in the absence of
Mg2+ and ATP. Morrissette et al. (1993)
also reported that
1 to 17 µM cADPR induced Ca2+ release from
skeletal muscle SR, but no change in single-channel Po was detected.
The latter finding might be explained by the low intraluminal
(trans) Ca2+ concentration used in that study,
because it has been shown that RyR activation by adenine nucleotides
requires > 40 µM trans Ca2+
(Sitsapesan and Williams, 1995a
).
Therefore, although it is clear that cADPR can mobilize intracellular
Ca2+ in many cell types, its mechanism and site of action
are still poorly understood (Sitsapesan et al., 1995a
). Direct action
on RyR1 or RyR2 seems unlikely, at least under physiological
conditions. This conclusion is supported by the recent observation that
flash photolysis of caged cADPR (up to 100 µM) did not
induce nor modulate SR Ca2+ release in cardiomyocytes,
whereas it triggered Ca2+ release in sea urchin eggs (Guo
et al., 1996a
).
4. Lipid derivatives.
In skeletal muscle, but not in cardiac
muscle, palmitoyl carnitine and other long-chain (>C14) acyl
carnitines induced SR Ca2+ release (El-Hayek et al., 1993
;
Dumonteil et al., 1994
). The stimulation of Ca2+ release
was slower than that produced by Ca2+ or ATP and had a lag
of about 100 to 150 msec. Consistently, palmitoyl carnitine increased
ryanodine binding at all Ca2+ concentrations (1 µM to 1 mM). In mammalian muscle, palmitoyl carnitine increased the Bmax without affecting the
KD (El-Hayek et al., 1993
), whereas in avian
muscle, Dumonteil et al. (1994)
reported increased affinity with
unchanged Bmax. In bilayer experiments, channel Po
increased, due to an increased ratio of long-lived versus short-lived
openings. These actions occurred at concentrations ranging from 5 to
100 µM (EC50 = 10 to 15 µM),
and their physiological or pathophysiological implications are
uncertain, because the plasma palmitoyl carnitine concentration is of
the order of 2 to 4 µM, but the cytosolic concentration
might be higher (Dumonteil et al., 1994
).
In skeletal muscle SR, Ca2+ release was induced also by
medium-chain (C12-C16) acyl-CoAs. Although El-Hayek et al. (1993)
reported that palmitoyl-CoA was ineffective, this finding was not
confirmed by other investigators (Dumonteil et al., 1994
; Fulceri et
al., 1994
). In particular, Fulceri et al. (1994)
observed that
palmitoyl-CoA induced Ca2+ release with EC50 = 6 µM and increased the affinity for
[3H]ryanodine without affecting the Bmax.
Free fatty acids, namely palmitic, stearic, arachidic, oleic, and
linoleic acid, have been reported to induce Ca2+ release
(Cheah, 1981
; Messineo et al., 1984
). However, in other studies, these
results could not be reproduced (El-Hayek et al., 1993
) or were
attributed to reversal of the Ca2+-ATPase reaction (Cardoso
and De Meis, 1993
). Peculiar results have been obtained with
arachidonic acid. Arachidonic acid (50 µM) induced SR
Ca2+ release in skeletal and cardiac muscle (Damron and
Bond, 1993
; Dettbarn and Palade, 1993
; El-Hayek et al., 1993
), but its
action was not inhibited by ruthenium red (Dettbarn and Palade, 1993
). In a recent cardiac muscle study (Uehara et al., 1996b
) arachidonic acid inhibited ryanodine binding by increasing the
KD and reducing the Bmax
(IC50
12 µM), but single-channel Po was
unaffected.
Sphingosine, a long-chain amino-alcohol that is a component of
sphingolipids, inhibited Ca2+-induced, caffeine-induced,
and doxorubicin-induced Ca2+ release from skeletal and
cardiac SR (Sabbadini et al., 1992
; Dettbarn et al., 1994a
; McDonough
et al., 1994
). In addition, sphingosine inhibited ryanodine binding, by
reducing the Bmax and increasing the
KD. The IC50 was of the order of 0.5 to 1 µM in skeletal muscle, and of 2 to 4 µM in cardiac muscle. The action of sphingosine did not
involve protein kinase modulation, and sphingomyelin or
sphingosylphosphoryl-choline were ineffective. However, at high
concentrations, both sphingosine (30 to 50 µM) and
sphingosylphosphoryl-choline (10 to 75 µM) induced
Ca2+ release in skeletal muscle and in brain microsomes
(Sabbadini et al., 1992
; Dettbarn et al., 1995
). Such stimulatory
action was only partly inhibited by ruthenium red, suggesting that it might largely represent a nonspecific effect on the lipid bilayer. Because the T-tubule membrane contains sphingomielinase, an enzyme involved in sphingosine production (Sabbadini et al., 1992
), and because the average cellular concentration of free sphingosine is of
the order of 0.4 µM (Dettbarn et al., 1994a
), RyR
modulation by sphingosine might have physiological importance.
5. Endogenous polyamines.
Palade (1987c)
first reported that
caffeine-induced and thymol-induced Ca2+ release were
inhibited by endogenous polyamines such as spermine, spermidine, and
putrescine. The IC50 for spermine was in the 10 to 100 µM range, whereas spermidine and putrescine, which
contain fewer amino groups, were less effective.
In single-channel experiments (Uehara et al., 1996a
), spermine and
other polyamines did not affect channel Po, but decreased channel
conductance in a voltage-dependent way, because the block was relieved
at large positive (cis minus trans) potentials.
These results suggest that polyamines enter the channel and compete with current-carrying ions in the permeation pathway. Under
physiological conditions (close to 0 mV), spermine
EC50 was < 100 µM. Because endogenous
spermine concentrations are in the range of 0.15 to 0.8 µmol/g wet
weight (Koenig et al., 1987
; Busselen, 1991
; Zarka and Shoshan-Barmatz,
1992
), modulation of RyR activity might have physiological relevance.
In binding studies (Zarka and Shoshan-Barmatz, 1992
), endogenous
polyamines increased the affinity for ryanodine, by affecting both the
association and the dissociation rate, without any change in the
Bmax. However, this action occurred only at low ionic
strength and at very high (unphysiological) concentrations, because the EC50 was 3.5 mM for spermine and 40 mM for spermidine and putrescine.
6. Phosphorylation.
The RyR is the substrate of several
protein kinases, namely cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA),
cGMP-dependent protein kinase (PKG), protein kinase C (PKC), and
calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CaMK). There is evidence that
junctional SR contains membrane-bound CaMK (Chu et al., 1990b
).
In cardiac SR, Takasago et al. (1989
, 1991
) observed that PKA, PKG, and
PKC incorporated about 1 mole of phosphate per mole of high-affinity
ryanodine binding site, suggesting the existence of a single
phosphorylation site per tetramer, which was presumably the same for
the three kinases. Phosphate incorporation by CaMK involved different
sites and was about four times higher, suggesting the existence of four
phosphorylation sites per tetramer, although only one of such sites
appeared to be available to endogenous CaMK (Witcher et al., 1991
).
Hohenegger and Suko (1993)
and Strand et al. (1993)
observed a
different stoichiometry, namely about 2 moles of phosphate per tetramer
with CaMK, 1 mole per tetramer with PKA, and 0.3 moles per tetramer
with PKG. When comparing these results, it should be considered that
differences in the phosphorylation state of the RyR in the native
tissue could account, at least in part, for the reported discrepancies.
From the functional point of view, phosphorylation of cardiac RyR by
PKA, PKG, or PKC favored Ca2+ release and produced a 15 to
25% increase in ryanodine binding (Takasago et al., 1991
). In
single-channel experiments, RyR2 phosphorylation by PKA increased the
responsiveness of the channel to Ca2+ and accelerated the
kinetics of adaptation (Valdivia et al., 1995b
). RyR2 phosphorylation
was enhanced by
-stimulation (Yoshida et al., 1992
), which was
associated with increased Ca2+ release (Patel et al.,
1995
). CaMK produced different effects, namely decreased affinity for
ryanodine (Takasago et al., 1991
; Lokuta et al., 1995
) and decreased
channel Po, due to reduced lifetime of the open channel and increased
lifetime of the closed channel. These effects were reversed by acidic
phosphatase, which was able to increase Po and ryanodine binding also
in native cardiac channels, suggesting that channel phosphorylation
occurred in vivo. At variance with these findings, Witcher et al.
(1991)
observed increased Po after treatment of cardiac RyR with CaMK.
Hain et al. (1995)
provided evidence that CaMK may have multiple
actions. In fact, phosphorylation by PKA or by exogenous CaMK made the channel insensitive to inhibition by Mg2+, whereas
phosphorylation by endogenous CaMK, presumably at a different site,
produced channel inhibition. The latter was reversible upon exposure to
potato acid phosphatase or to protein phosphatase 1.
On the whole, phosphorylation is likely to play an important role in
the physiological modulation of RyR2. The consequences of
phosphorylation should be considered when interpreting the results of
many in vitro studies, because the phosphorylation state of the native
channel is usually unknown, but it can significantly affect channel
properties as assessed in vitro.
The sites of action of the different kinases are not well
characterized. On the basis of sequence analysis, up to four serine residues and two threonine residues have been identified as possible phosphorylation sites. In particular, phosphorylation of serine 2809 has been involved in channel activation (Witcher et al., 1991
).
The effects of RyR1 phosphorylation are controversial. It was reported
that PKA, PKG, and CaMK phosphorylated serine residue 2843 (homologous
to serine 2809 of RyR2), with stoichiometry ranging from 0.3 to 0.9 moles per receptor monomer (Suko et al., 1993
), and that CaMK also
phosphorylated other residues, including a 60-kDa protein later
identified as an isoform of phosphoglucomutase (Kim and Ikemoto, 1986
;
Kim et al., 1988
; Leddy et al., 1993
). Other investigators observed
only minimal phosphorylation of RyR1 by PKA or CaMK and questioned its
physiological relevance (Strand et al., 1993
). Functional studies have
also provided controversial results, because either channel activation
(Gechtman et al., 1991
; Herrmann-Frank and Varsanyi, 1993
), or channel
inactivation (Wang and Best, 1992
) or no effect (Chu et al., 1990b
)
have been reported. According to Hain et al. (1994)
, phosphorylation by
PKA or exogenous CaMK removed Mg2+-inhibition, whereas
phosphorylation by endogenous CaMK blocked the channel, as observed in
cardiac muscle.
7. Ryanodine receptor-protein interactions.
a. DIHYDROPYRIDINE RECEPTOR.
Interaction between the
dihydropyridine and RyRs has major importance in excitation-contraction
coupling. This issue has been dealt with above (section I.A.), and has
been extensively reviewed elsewhere (Rios and Pizarro, 1991
;
Franzini-Armstrong and Jorgensen, 1994
; Schneider, 1994
).
b. CALMODULIN.
Calmodulin is a ubiquitous
Ca2+ binding protein. Seiler et al. (1984)
first observed
that calmodulin was associated with high molecular weight proteins in
the SR, later identified as the RyR. Calmodulin inhibited
Ca2+-induced, caffeine-induced, and AMP-induced
Ca2+ release from cardiac and skeletal muscle SR, with
IC50
0.1 to 0.2 µM. Inhibition of
Ca2+ release occurred only at free Ca2+
concentrations > 0.1 µM, suggesting that
Ca2+-calmodulin was the inhibitory species, but the action
was observed in the absence of ATP, showing that calmodulin-dependent
kinases were not involved. The inhibition was not complete, and it was reversible (Meissner, 1986a
; Meissner and Henderson, 1987
; Plank et
al., 1988
; Fuentes et al., 1994
). In single-channel experiments performed with skeletal or cardiac
channels, 2 µM calmodulin reversibly decreased channel
Po. The action was Ca2+-dependent and ATP-independent.
Whereas Smith et al. (1989)
reported decreased mean open time, Fuentes
et al. (1994)
reported that calmodulin decreased the frequency of open
events. Tripathy et al. (1995)
described two effects, i.e.,
stabilization of the closed channel in the absence of
Mg2+-ATP and reduced lifetime of the open channel in the
presence of Mg2+-ATP.Consistently, in brain microsomes and in skeletal muscle,
[3H]ryanodine binding was inhibited by calmodulin, with
IC50 = 0.1 µM (McPherson and Campbell, 1993b
;
Fuentes et al., 1994
). More recently, a biphasic action has been described (Tripathy et al.,
1995
). While calmodulin inhibited the skeletal muscle channel at
micromolar or millimolar Ca2+ concentration, at
submicromolar Ca2+ (< 0.1 µM) concentration
ryanodine binding increased (EC50 = 28 nM, with
Hill coefficient close to 1), Ca2+ release was stimulated,
and single-channel recordings showed an increased Po.Multiple calmodulin binding sites have been described, on the basis of
sequence analysis, electron microscopy imaging, and labeling studies.
Two to six sites per monomer have been tentatively identified,
partially overlapping with Ca2+-binding sites and ruthenium
red binding sites (Takeshima et al., 1989
; Zorzato et al., 1990
; Chen
and MacLennan, 1994
; Menegazzi et al., 1994
; Wagenknecht et al., 1994
;
Yang et al., 1994
; Tripathy et al., 1995
). Calmodulin binding depended
on the Ca2+ concentration: according to Tripathy et al.
(1995)
, four calmodulin molecules per RyR monomer were bound at
Ca2+ < 0.1 µM, versus 1 molecule per monomer
at micromolar Ca2+. Calmodulin binding was affected by the
pH (maximum at 6.5 to 7.2) and ionic strength (maximum at 0.1 to 0.25 M), whereas Mg2+ decreased the number of
high-affinity calmodulin binding sites (Yang et al., 1994
). One of the
calmodulin binding sites includes a sequence that can be phosphorylated
by PKA, and calmodulin binding appears to inhibit this phosphorylation
(Guerrini et al., 1995
). Because the intracellular concentration of calmodulin is close to 2 µM, its actions on the RyR are likely to have
physiological importance.
c. FK BINDING PROTEINS.
A 12-kDa FK-506 binding protein
known as FKBP12 is the cytosolic receptor for the immunosuppressant
drug FK-506. The complex FKBP12/FK-506 is a potent inhibitor of
calcineurin, a calmodulin-dependent Ca2+-activated protein
phosphatase involved in the activation of T-lymphocytes. In skeletal
muscle, FKBP12 is closely associated with RyR1, with a molar ratio of
4:1, suggesting that one FKBP12 molecule is associated with each RyR
monomer (Collins, 1991
; Jayaraman et al., 1992
). In cardiac muscle,
RyR2 is associated with the same molar ratio to another recently
identified FK binding protein that is closely related to FKBP12 and has
been named FKBP12.6 (Timerman et al., 1994
; Sewell et al., 1994
; Lam et
al., 1995
). Observations performed after FKBP12/RyR dissociation (Timerman et al.,
1993
; Mayrleitner et al., 1994
) and after coexpression of FKBP12 and
RyR in insect cells (Brillantes et al., 1994
) have shown that FKBP12
stabilizes the RyR. In particular, FKBP12 prevented the appearance of
subconductance states occasionally observed with purified RyRs (Smith
et al., 1988
; Ma, 1993
; Ma et al., 1988
; Liu et al., 1989
), increased
the threshold to caffeine activation, and produced longer opening
events after caffeine activation. Furthermore, FKBP12 blocked the flow
of "reverse" (cis to trans) current,
without affecting the physiological (trans to
cis) current flow (Chen et al., 1994
; Ma et al., 1995
).
The stabilizing action of FKBP12 was independent from its peptidyl
prolyl isomerase activity (Timerman et al., 1995
).Cryoelectron microscopy has identified FKBPs binding sites, which are
located about 10 nm from the transmembrane baseplate assembly that
contains the ion channel (Wagenknecht et al., 1996
).
d. CALSEQUESTRIN.
Calsequestrin is the primary
Ca2+-binding protein of the SR. It has been suggested that
calsequestrin interacts with the RyR, and, in particular, that RyR
activation induces the release of Ca2+ from calsequestrin
(Ikemoto et al., 1989
, 1991
; McPherson and Campbell, 1993a
). Consistent
with this hypothesis, calsequestrin increased the Po of single skeletal
muscle channels if added to the trans (luminal)
chamber (Kawasaki and Kasai, 1994
).
e. TRIADIN.
Triadin is a 95-kDa SR membrane protein
that exists as a disulfide-linked homopolymer and binds the RyR
with
1:1 molar ratio. There is evidence that RyR/triadin
interaction is also mediated by disulfide bonds (Caswell et al., 1991
;
Knudson et al., 1993a
,b
). Triadin was initially thought to be specific
for skeletal muscle, but its presence has been demonstrated
subsequently also in myocardium (Brandt et al., 1993
; Peng et al.,
1994
). Anti-triadin antibodies inhibited the slow phase of
Ca2+ release (Brandt et al., 1992
), and it has been
speculated that triadin mediates the interaction between the
dihydropyridine and RyRs (Brandt et al., 1990
; Kim et al., 1990
).
Immunolabeling studies have confirmed that triadin is closely
associated with dihydropyridine and RyRs since its earliest appearance
during skeletal muscle development (Carl et al., 1995
). It has also
been proposed that triadin may provide a functional connection between
RyR and calsequestin (McPherson and Campbell, 1993a
; Guo and Campbell,
1995
; Guo et al., 1996b
).
f. OTHER PROTEINS.
Other proteins are associated with
the RyR. Annexin VI (Diaz-Munoz et al., 1990
), a minor SR
Ca2+-binding protein, and S-100 (Fano et al., 1989
), a
cytoplasmic Ca2+-binding protein, have been reported to
facilitate Ca2+ release. Ankyrin, a cytoskeletal protein,
binds to all RyR isoforms. In lymphoma cells, ankyrin inhibited
[3H]ryanodine binding and blocked the inhibitory effect
of ryanodine on Ca2+ release (Bourguignon et al., 1995
).
Sorcin, a 22-kDa binding protein initially identified in
multidrug-resistant cells, has been identified in many tissues,
including the heart, where immunoelectron microscopy and
immunoprecipitation techniques have shown a close association with the
RyR (Meyers et al., 1995
). Phosphorylation of the 150-kDa protein
sarcalumenin and of the 160-kDa histidine-rich Ca2+-binding
protein by casein kinase II has been associated with inhibition of
ryanodine binding in skeletal muscle SR (Orr and Shoshan-Barmatz, 1996
;
Shoshan-Barmatz et al., 1996
). Protamine inhibited thymol-induced
Ca2+ release (IC50 = 1.5 nM),
whereas several histones had a biphasic action, because they inhibited
Ca2+ release at low concentrations and stimulated
Ca2+ release at higher concentrations (Palade, 1987c
).
Several glycolytic enzymes (glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase,
aldolase, and phosphoglucomutase) have been identified in heavy SR
membranes, but it is still unknown whether they have any specific
function at this level (Meissner, 1984
). Proteolytic enzymes affect SR function, although their physiological
role, if any, is unknown. Trypsin incubation had a biphasic effect in
lipid bilayer experiments: channel Po initially increased, but channel
activity was subsequently lost. High-affinity ryanodine binding
decreased, while low-affinity binding increased after prolonged
incubation with trypsin (Chu et al., 1988
; Shoshan-Barmatz and Zarka,
1988
; Trimm et al., 1988
; Anderson et al., 1989
; Meissner et al.,
1989
). Calpains also affect RyR function. Calpain I is associated with
skeletal muscle RyR, and its activation produced two fragments with
apparent molecular mass of 375 kDa and 150 kDa (Shoshan-Barmatz et al.,
1994
). The proteolytic fragments remained associated, but RyR cleavage
stimulated Ca2+ efflux, although ryanodine binding was not
modified. Cleavage by calpain I was prevented by 1 to 5 mM
ATP and by high NaCl concentration. Similar findings have been obtained
with calpain II. In particular, Rardon et al. (1990)
have observed that
incubation with calpain II had no effect on ryanodine binding but
increased channel Po.
8. Other endogenous modulators.
The second-messenger inositol
1,4,5 trisphosphate (IP3) can release Ca2+ from
intracellular stores in smooth muscle, neurons, and nonexcitable cells
(Berridge, 1993
). After the observation that IP3 mobilized Ca2+ also from skeletal and cardiac SR (reviewed by
Meissner, 1994
), it was speculated that IP3 might be
involved in excitation-contraction coupling, possibly by modulating the
RyR (Volpe et al., 1985
; Nosek et al., 1986
; Suarez-Isla et al., 1988
,
1991
; Kentish et al., 1990
; Valdivia et al., 1990a
, 1992a
; Borgatta et
al., 1991
; Chu and Stefani, 1991
). IP3 interacts with a
specific receptor, a homotetramer that includes a Ca2+
channel and shows significant homology with the RyR (Berridge, 1993
;
Mikoshiba, 1993
). Because IP3 receptors have been
identified in striated muscle (Marks et al., 1990
; Nakagawa et al.,
1991
; Kijima and Fleischer, 1992
; Gorza et al., 1993
; Kijima et al., 1993
; Moschella and Marks, 1993
; Go et al., 1995
; Moschella et al.,
1995
), it seems likely that Ca2+ mobilization by
IP3 is mediated by the IP3 receptor, rather
than by the RyR.
It has been reported that nitric oxide can mobilize Ca2+
from ryanodine-sensitive stores in pancreatic
-cells (Willmott et al., 1995
). However, in skeletal muscle preparations, nitric oxide donors inhibited SR Ca2+ release and decreased
single-channel Po, due to a reduced number of channel openings. These
effects were prevented by mercaptoethanol, suggesting that sulfhydryl
oxidation was involved in the response to nitric oxide (Meszaros et
al., 1996
).
L-Thyroxine (250 µM) increased
Ca2+ release, ryanodine binding, and single-channel Po in
skeletal muscle (Connelly et al., 1994
). In addition, thyroid hormones
favored the expression of RyR genes (Arai et al., 1991
).
The physiological modulation of RyR gene expression has not been
extensively studied. Apart from the effect of thyroid hormones, it has
been observed that fibroblast growth factors inhibited the expression
of RyR1 in a myogenic cell line (Marks et al., 1991
), whereas in
another cell line, RyR3 expression depended on transforming growth
factor
(Giannini et al., 1992
). Forskolin, an adenylate cyclase
activator, decreased RyR1 mRNA levels in cultured myotubes, whereas PKC
produced the opposite effect. Both forskolin and PKC appeared to act by
modulating the stability of RyR gene transcripts rather than the
transcription process itself (Ray et al., 1995
). Recently, it has been
reported that two novel transcription factors, designated as RYREF-1
and RYREF-2, are involved in the regulation of RyR1 gene transcription
(Schmoelzl et al., 1996
).
B. Pharmacological Modulators
Many exogenous substances have been reported to modulate RyR
function. (for earlier reviews, see Herbette et al., 1982
and Palade et
al., 1989
). Their actions are often complex and/or not completely
clarified. Even the basic distinction between agonists and antagonists
is not easy, because several modulators may either stimulate or inhibit
Ca2+ release, depending on concentration or incubation
time. Therefore, we have decided to classify the pharmacological
modulators on the basis of their chemical structure. Only compounds
with reasonably well-defined structural or functional similiarity have
been grouped together. A separate chapter includes agents that produce
covalent modifications. In section II.C., we outline general mechanisms of RyR modulation and attempt to set a basis for functional
classification. Unless otherwise specified, reference to therapeutic
drug concentrations is based on Gilman et al. (1990)
.
1. Ryanoids.
Ryanodine is an ester of pyrrole-
-carboxylic
acid with ryandolol. Modulation of cardiac and skeletal muscle function
by ryanodine has been known for many years (Jenden and Fairhurst,
1969
). Evidence of an action on the SR Ca2+ release channel
was first provided by the observation that ryanodine increased SR
Ca2+ uptake without affecting active Ca2+
transport (Jones et al., 1979
; Sutko et al., 1979
). Subsequent investigations have shown that ryanodine has complex, antithetical effects on the RyR.
In release experiments (Meissner, 1986b
; Hasselbach and Migala, 1987
;
Lattanzio et al., 1987
; Carroll et al., 1991
; Pessah and Zimanyi, 1991
;
Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991a
; Kasai and Kawasaki, 1993
), ryanodine favored
Ca2+ release and allowed it to proceed even in the presence
of a nonrelease medium. Cardiac muscle was more sensitive than skeletal
muscle to ryanodine activation, and the EC50 was inversely
related to free Ca2+ concentration, ranging from 40 nM to 50 µM. While the immediate effect of
ryanodine was always channel activation, prolonged incubation with
micromolar ryanodine eventually inhibited Ca2+ release. The
incubation time required for inhibition to develop was inversely
related to temperature and to ryanodine concentration, e.g., 1 h
with 1 µM ryanodine or 5 to 10 min with 500 µM ryanodine. Channel blockade by micromolar ryanodine
was not reversible, at least on the time scale of release experiments.
Single-channel recordings have provided a more direct insight into the
action of ryanodine (Rousseau et al., 1987
; Hymel et al., 1988
;
Anderson et al., 1989
; Bull et al., 1989
; Holmberg and Williams, 1989
,
1990a
; Lai et al., 1989
; Chu et al., 1990a
; Lindsay and Williams, 1991
;
Buck et al., 1992
; Lindsay et al., 1994
). At micromolar concentration,
ryanodine locked the channel open, but in a state of subnormal
conductance, corresponding to about 40 to 60% of the conductance of
the open channel. The modified state was characterized by a remarkable
(more than 20-fold) increase in open lifetime, associated with
decreased closed lifetime. Contrary to the normal channel, the Po of
the modified channel was voltage-dependent, and the relationship
between Po and membrane potential was bell-shaped (Ma, 1993
). This
modified state was insensitive to activation by Ca2+ and
ATP and was less sensitive than the normal channel to Mg2+
inhibition, H+ inhibition, and ruthenium red inhibition. At
higher ryanodine concentrations (in the millimolar range), such an
action was followed by persistent channel blockade. Occasionally,
further subnormal conductance states were transiently observed before
complete blockade. Bull et al. (1989)
and Buck et al. (1992)
described
multiple effects of increasing concentrations of ryanodine: 5 to 40 nM ryanodine increased channel Po and induced the
occasional appearance of a subnormal state with
1/2 of
the basal conductance; > 50 nM ryanodine stabilized the
channel in the one-half-conductance state that was not readily
reversible; > 70 µM ryanodine induced a transition to a
lower conductance (
1/4 of the basal value), and > 200 µM ryanodine caused complete blockade, which was not
reversible on the time scale of the recordings.
The characteristics of ryanodine binding have been described above
(section I.B.3.). The current interpretation of these results (Meissner, 1986b
; Chu et al., 1990a
; Carroll et al., 1991
; Pessah and
Zimanyi, 1991
; Buck et al., 1992
) is that the interaction of ryanodine
with its high-affinity site stabilizes the open state of the channel,
but the conductance of the open channel is subnormal, possibly due to
partial occlusion of the channel lumen by the ryanodine molecule. At
higher concentrations, ryanodine binds to low-affinity sites, which
causes further reduction in channel conductance, up to complete
blockade. Although this issue has not been definitely established,
low-affinity binding is probably due to negative cooperativity between
identical binding sites of different monomers. After occupation of the
low-affinity sites, the channel undergoes a slow transition to a state
characterized by persistent channel inactivation, which is associated
with decreased ryanodine binding. The latter effect is either
irreversible or very slowly reversible, because prolonged incubation
with > 100 nM ryanodine produced the complete loss of
low-affinity binding and a concentration-dependent decrease in
high-affinity binding that persisted for at least 48 h (Mack et
al., 1992
; Zimanyi et al., 1992
). The decrease in ryanodine binding
observed after prolonged exposure to micromolar ryanodine might be due
to sulfhydryl oxidation, because it was prevented by the thiol reducing
agent dithiothreitol. Covalent labeling of the RyR with a
photo-activatable derivative of ryanodine suggested that channel
inactivation was associated with the development of stable, virtually
irreversible interactions between receptor monomers (Bidasee et al.,
1995
).
The comparison of single-channel and [3H]ryanodine
binding experiments reveals that the concentrations required to produce corresponding effects (e.g., stabilization of a
50%
subconductance state and high-affinity binding) were significantly
higher in the former. The usual explanation of this discrepancy is that single-channel experiments are performed under nonequilibrium conditions, owing to the relatively short duration of the recordings, which leads to the use of high ryanodine concentrations to produce an
immediate response. However, it cannot be excluded that RyR incorporation into lipid bilayers may cause the loss of proteins that
modulate the response to ryanodine.
Indirect evidence suggested that ryanodine may also inhibit the
transition between low-affinity and high-affinity states of an
intracellular Ca2+ compartment, possibly calsequestrin
(Gilchrist et al., 1992
). However, in other indirect studies, no
evidence of an intra-SR action of ryanodine was observed (Nelson and
Nelson, 1990
).
Ryanodine produced opposite functional effects in heart versus skeletal
muscle (Jenden and Fairhurst, 1969
; Sutko et al., 1985
; Meissner,
1986b
; Lewartowski et al., 1990
; Northover, 1991
). In the former,
nanomolar ryanodine had a pronounced negative inotropic action,
sometimes preceded by a transient positive inotropic response, whereas
in the latter, contracture was produced. Such a difference has been
attributed to differences in the regulation of intracellular Ca2+ homeostasis. The effect of nanomolar ryanodine is to
lock the SR channel open, so that Ca2+ is released into the
cytosol. In cardiomyocytes, Ca2+ is quickly extruded by the
sarcolemmal Na+/Ca2+ exchanger and
Ca2+-ATPase, so that the increase in cytosolic
[Ca2+] is short-lived; the final effect is depletion of
the intracellular Ca2+ pool, which accounts for negative
inotropism. In skeletal muscle, sarcolemmal Ca2+ extrusion
is much slower, so that ryanodine determines a persistent increase in
cytosolic [Ca2+], which is responsible for the
contracture.
Other natural ryanoids contain several substituents at C-8, C-9, and
C-10 of the cyclohexane ring. The most important one in amount and
biological activity is 9,21-didehydroryanodine, which differs from
ryanodine by the absence of two H atoms. Didehydroryanodine had the
same functional effects as ryanodine, and competitively inhibited
[3H]ryanodine binding (Pessah et al., 1985
, 1986
; Carroll
et al., 1991
). It should be stressed that several commercial ryanodine preparations contain up to 50% didehydroryanodine, so that many reports actually describe the effects of a mixture of ryanodine and
didehydroryanodine.
Many other biologically active ryanoids have been synthesized by
derivatization of the cyclohexane ring or of the hydroxyls at C-2, C-4,
C-6, C-10, C-12 and by inversion, relocation, or substitution of the
pyrrole nucleus (Waterhouse et al., 1987
; Gerzon et al., 1993
;
Humerickhouse et al., 1993
, 1994
; Jefferies et al., 1993
, 1996a
, 1996b
;
Ruest and Deslongchamps, 1993
; Welch et al., 1994
, 1996
). Although most
derivatives were less active than ryanodine, some
C10-Oeq esters containing positively charged side groups (e.g., guanidinopropionyl- and
-alanil-ryanodine) were
more potent than ryanodine in binding experiments. In single-channel experiments, biologically active derivatives induced the
appearance of long-lived subconductance states, whose amplitude
ranged from about 5% (C10-Oeq
guanidinopropionyl-ryanodine) to about 70% (ryanodol) of the control
state (Tinker et al., 1996
).
The evaluation of synthetic ryanoids has shown that different molecular
features are responsible for the multiple pharmacological actions of
ryanodine. In particular, the synthesis of
C10-Oeq esters yielded compounds with pure
agonist activity (e.g.,
-alanil-ryanodine) since channel blockade
was not observed at concentrations as high as 300 µM
(Humerickhouse et al., 1994
; Bidasee et al., 1995
).
The molecular location of ryanoid binding sites is still unknown.
Results obtained with proteolytic fragments suggest that ryanodine
binding involves the foot region of the protein. More precisely, in
RyR1 both low-affinity and high affinity binding sites are located
between Arg 4475 and the carboxyl terminus (Callaway et al., 1994
).
Photoaffinity labeling with an azido derivative of ryanodine confirmed
the carboxy-terminal location of the binding site(s) (Witcher et al.,
1994
). On the basis of the response to different ryanoids, Welch et al.
(1994
, 1996
) concluded that ryanodine binds to the receptor with the
pyrrole and isopropyl groups buried deep inside a cleft of the protein,
while the 9-portion and 10-portion remain at the mouth of the binding
site and extend into the solvent.
2. Purine derivatives and related compounds.
This group
includes substances that have a similar sterical structure, based on a
purine, carboline, carbazole, or imidazopyridine ring and are likely to
act on the same molecular site.
a. METHYLXANTHINES.
It has been known for many years
that caffeine favors SR Ca2+ release (Endo, 1977
; Herbette
et al., 1982
; Fabiato, 1983
; Kim et al., 1983
; Nagasaki and Kasai,
1983
; Meissner, 1984
; Meissner et al., 1986
; Meissner and Henderson,
1987
; Palade, 1987a
; Pessah et al., 1987
; Moutin and Dupont, 1988
;
Rousseau et al., 1988
; Akera et al., 1990
; Wyskovsky et al., 1990
; Lee
et al., 1991
). Caffeine increased the Ca2+-sensitivity of
the process, so that significant Ca2+ release was produced
even at nanomolar [Ca2+]. A remarkable stimulation was
obtained at suboptimal (low micromolar) [Ca2+], whereas
at optimal [Ca2+], the stimulation was minimal. The
sensitivity to caffeine was higher in cardiac than in skeletal SR, and
the EC50 was of the order of 0.2 to 0.5 mM. The
stimulatory actions of caffeine and adenine nucleotides were additive,
and the response to caffeine was inhibited by Mg2+ and
ruthenium red.These results have been confirmed in single-channel experiments
(Rousseau et al., 1988
; Rousseau and Meissner, 1989
; Sitsapesan and
Williams, 1990
; Hernandez-Cruz et al., 1995
). In skeletal and cardiac
muscle, caffeine increased channel Po without any conductance change.
At low concentrations (0.5 to 2 mM), caffeine had a
Ca2+-sensitizing action: channel activation required the
presence of submicromolar Ca2+, and the increase in Po was
due to a reduced lifetime of the closed states. Higher concentrations
(> 5 to 10 mM) activated the channel also at picomolar
Ca2+, and increased the lifetime of the open channel, which
was associated with the appearance of an additional long-lived open
state. Channels activated by caffeine were still characteristically
modified by ryanodine, ATP, Mg2+, and ruthenium red.In binding experiments (Pessah et al., 1987
; Chu et al., 1990a
;
Holmberg and Williams, 1990a
; Ogawa and Harafuji, 1990a
,b
; Zimanyi and
Pessah, 1991b
; Hernandez-Cruz et al., 1995
), caffeine (1 to 30 mM) favored ryanodine binding by increasing the affinity and Ca2+ sensitivity of the binding reaction. The maximum
binding at optimal Ca2+ concentration was only slightly
increased. Kinetic experiments showed that caffeine increased the
association rate. In general, the effect of caffeine was similar to the effect of adenine
nucleotides. However, several lines of evidence suggest that caffeine
and adenine nucleotides act on different, although possibly
interacting, sites: (a) caffeine and adenine nucleotides had synergic effects on channel gating and on ryanodine binding (Ogawa
and Harafuji, 1990b
); (b) adenine and adenosine
inhibited the response to ATP analogues, yet they stimulated the
response to caffeine (Rousseau et al., 1988
; McGarry and Williams,
1994b
); (c) the stimulation of ryanodine binding
produced at optimal Ca2+ concentration was greater with
adenine nucleotide than with caffeine (Pessah et al., 1987
);
(d) contrary to adenine nucleotides, caffeine did not
affect the lifetime of the open channel, except possibly at very high
concentrations (Sitsapesan and Williams, 1990
); (e) the
sensitivity to caffeine was higher in cardiac muscle, whereas the
sensitivity to adenine nucleotide was higher in skeletal muscle (Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991a
).Theophylline (Seifert and Casida, 1986
) and other methylxanthines
shared the action of caffeine. Rousseau et al. (1988)
reported the
following order of effectiveness in release experiments:
1,7-dimethylxanthine > 3,7-dimethylxanthine (theobromine)
1,3-dimethylxanthine (theophylline) > 1,3,7-trimethylxanthine
(caffeine)
3,9-dimethylxanthine, whereas 1,9-dimethylxanthine
and 1,3,9-trimethylxanthine were minimally effective. The integrity of
the imidazole ring was necessary for activity, because
1,3-dimethyluracil was ineffective. Although most useful in the experimental setting, it is unlikely that
RyR modulation will be important in the therapeutic response to
methylxanthines, because their plasma concentration (e.g., about 55 µM for theophylline) is lower than the effective concentration range, as determined in vitro.
b. CARBOLINE DERIVATIVES AND CARBAZOLE DERIVATIVES.
Derivatives of eudistomin D, a natural product with a
-carboline
skeleton isolated from the Caribbean tunicate Eudistoma olivaceum, induced SR Ca2+ release. One of the most
active derivatives was 9-methyl-7-bromoeudistomin D (MBED), which
produced the same effects as caffeine on SR Ca2+ release
and ryanodine binding and was about 1000 times more potent (Seino et
al., 1991
). Many other
-carboline and
-carboline derivatives showed similar effects, and their potency was increased by C-5 or C-7
halogenation or by N-9 methylation (Takahashi et al., 1995a
). Because
the spacial structure of MBED is similar to that of caffeine, it has
been postulated that MBED interacts with the caffeine binding site in
the RyR (Seino et al., 1991
). This hypothesis was supported by binding
experiments performed with [3H]MBED, because a specific
binding site was identified and [3H]MBED binding was
competitively inhibited by caffeine. Ca2+,
Mg2+, and ryanodine did not affect [3H]MBED
binding, whereas AMP-PCP had a stimulatory effect (Fang et al., 1993
).
These results support the concept that caffeine and adenine nucleotide
binding sites are separated and partially interacting.
[3H]MBED binding was inhibited by several channel
blockers, such as procaine, tetracaine, spermine and dantrolene,
whereas it was slightly stimulated by ruthenium red. In skeletal
muscle, the density of [3H]MBED binding sites was almost
equal to that of [3H]ryanodine binding sites, but in
brain, the former was more than 100-fold higher (Yoshikawa et al.,
1995
). It is unclear whether these observations reflect the presence of
MBED-binding proteins different from the RyR, or rather of isolated RyR
monomers, that are unable to bind [3H]ryanodine.Several carbazole derivatives shared the Ca2+-releasing
action of carboline derivatives such as MBED. However, derivatives with a carbazole skeleton and bromine at C-6 had an inhibitory action (Takahashi et al., 1995a
). In particular 4,6-dibromo-3-hydroxycarbazole was a potent inhibitor of SR Ca2+ release (IC50 = 58 µM). This substance maintained its inhibitory action
also at high (> 30 µM) Ca2+ concentration,
and it did not affect ryanodine binding (Takahashi et al., 1995b
).
c. SULMAZOLE.
Sulmazole is an imidazopyridine compound,
namely
2-(2-methoxy-4-(methylsulfinyl)-phenyl)-1H-imidazo(4,5-
)pyridine. In
single-channel experiments performed with sheep cardiac RyR, sulmazole
increased the frequency and duration of open events with an
EC50 of about 400 µM (Williams and Holmberg,
1990
; Sitsapesan et al., 1991
; McGarry and Williams, 1994a
). Sulmazole
acted by both Ca2+-dependent and
Ca2+-independent mechanisms, because it induced channel
opening even in the absence of Ca2+ (60 pM free
Ca2+); in addition, it increased the
Ca2+-sensitivity of channel activation. Channels activated
by sulmazole were still inhibited by Mg2+ and ruthenium
red. The Hill coefficient for Ca2+-independent channel
activation was close to 1, whereas a Hill coefficient close to 2 was
obtained in the presence of Ca2+, suggesting that one
sulmazole molecule can bind to the closed conformation of the channel,
whereas Ca2+ is required for the binding of a second
molecule. In binding experiments (Holmberg and Williams, 1990a
; McGarry and
Williams, 1994a
), sulmazole increased ryanodine binding, by increasing
the KD, with EC50 and Hill
coefficient comparable to those observed in single-channel experiments. The action of sulmazole was not stereospecific and was shared by the
enantiomer isomazole. Analogs lacking the methylsulfinyl oxygen were
also effective and were about 10-fold more potent than sulmazole and
isomazole (McGarry and Williams, 1994a
). The pharmacological actions of sulmazole resemble those of caffeine.
Because the tridimensional structures of the imidazopyridine ring of
sulmazole and of the purine ring of caffeine are quite similar, it is
likely that they act on the same molecular site. In fact, sulmazole
shares other actions with caffeine, such as sensitization of
contractile proteins to Ca2+, inhibition of type III
phosphodiesterase, inhibition of sarcolemmal Na+/K+ ATPase, and A1-adenosine antagonism (see
McGarry and Williams, 1994a
for reference).
3. Anthraquinones.
Zorzato et al. (1985)
first reported that
the anthraquinone compound doxorubicin, an antineoplastic drug also
known as adriamycin, induced Ca2+ release from skeletal
muscle SR, with EC50
5 µM. The same
action was produced by other anthraquinones such as mitoxantrone,
daunorubicin, rubidazone, and doxorubicinol and occurred also in
cardiac muscle (Palade, 1987b
; Abramson et al., 1988a
; Kim et al.,
1989
; Pessah et al., 1990
; Tian et al., 1991
). In some experiments, the
response to doxorubicin was bell-shaped, because the stimulation of
Ca2+ efflux decreased at concentrations > 30 µM (Pessah et al., 1992b
). Naphtoquinones such as
menadione and plumbagin were minimally effective, and benzoquinones
were ineffective (Abramson et al., 1988a
). In the presence of
physiological Mg2+ concentration, the action of
anthraquinones was sharply dependent on [Ca2+], showing
that these substances increased the Ca2+-sensitivity of
Ca2+ release.
In single-channel experiments, doxorubicin increased cardiac channel Po
(Nagasaki and Fleischer, 1989
; Holmberg and Williams, 1990b
; Ondrias et
al., 1990
). At low concentrations (1 to 10 µM), doxorubicin decreased the lifetime of the closed channel; at higher concentrations (25 µM), it also increased the lifetime of
the open channel. Ondrias et al. (1990)
reported a biphasic,
time-dependent effect, because doxorubicin (2.5 to 10 µM)
initially increased channel Po and subsequently inactivated the
channel. The degree of channel activation was concentration-dependent,
whereas the time needed to inactivate the channel was
concentration-independent and averaged 8 min.
In binding experiments, doxorubicin decreased the
KD for ryanodine by increasing the association
constant, and it did not modify the Bmax (EC50
20 to 30 µM at 1 µM Ca2+)
(Abramson et al., 1988a
; Kim et al., 1989
; Pessah et al., 1990
, 1992b
;
Holmberg and Williams, 1990b
; Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991b
). These effects
are similar to those of caffeine, and it was speculated that caffeine
and doxorubicin compete for the same binding site on the RyR (Pessah et
al., 1990
). However, kinetic analysis suggested that anthraquinone and
caffeine bind to different, although interacting, sites (Abramson et
al., 1988a
).
Although the acute effect of doxorubicin was quickly reversible,
long-term (1 to 7 days) treatment increased the sensitivity of rat
cardiac preparations to anthraquinones, because the increase in
Ca2+ release and ryanodine binding observed after the acute
administration of doxorubicin was much higher than in the control
animals (Pessah et al., 1990
). However, if chronic treatment was
further prolonged, RyR inactivation eventually ensued: after 4 weeks
(total dose 9 mg/kg), the Bmax for ryanodine was reduced,
with unchanged KD, and Ca2+ release
was impaired (Pessah et al., 1992b
). Similar findings were obtained in
a rabbit model of chronic doxorubicin toxicity (Dodd et al., 1993
).
After 6 to 9 weeks (total dose: 12 to 18 mg/kg), a significant
reduction in the Bmax for ryanodine was observed in heart,
but not in skeletal muscle. The KD was
unchanged, and the KDCa was slightly
increased. Decreased RyR density was confirmed by Western blot analysis
of cardiac homogenates, using specific antibodies.
Significant differences between anthraquinones have been observed. In
cardiac tissue, mitoxantrone and doxorubicin had different actions on
ryanodine binding (Kim et al., 1994b
). Both compounds decreased the
KD for ryanodine, but, whereas doxorubicin
increased the association rate and did not affect the dissociation
rate, mitoxantrone decreased the dissociation rate. Contrary to
doxorubicin, mitoxantrone did not increase the Ca2+
sensitivity of ryanodine binding, and, under optimal conditions (30 µM Ca2+ and no Mg2+), ryanodine
binding was actually inhibited. In single-channel experiments, high
concentrations of mitoxantrone induced the formation of a
low-conductance state (Holmberg and Williams, 1990b
).
It is likely that interference with RyR function by anthraquinones may
produce a transient cytosolic Ca2+ overload, followed by an
impairment of the SR Ca2+ release capability. These
phenomena are thought to be of major importance in determining the
toxic effects of these substances, both in experimental preparations
and in the clinical setting. The acute effects of anthracyclins include
a transient positive inotropic response followed by a sustained
negative inotropic action, prolonged time to peak-twitch-tension, and
decreased relaxation rate, whereas chronic doxorubicin toxicity is
characterized by the progressive development of a cardiomyopathy
leading to congestive heart failure (Hagane et al., 1988
; Doroshow,
1991
; Boucek et al., 1993
; Wang and Korth, 1995
). On the other hand,
the arrhythmias that are often the only clinical evidence of acute
toxicity have been related to interference with delayed rectifier
K+ current (Wang and Korth, 1995
).
4. Digitalis glycosides.
At therapeutic concentration (1 nM), digoxin increased the rate of Ca2+-induced
Ca2+ release from cardiac SR (McGarry and Williams, 1993
).
Digoxin could not induce Ca2+ release at subactivating
(picomolar) Ca2+ concentrations, and its action was
inhibited by Mg2+. In single-channel experiments, digoxin
increased channel Po, owing to decreased lifetime of the closed
channel. High concentrations (10 to 20 nM) produced an
additional effect, i.e., increased lifetime of the open channel.
Digoxin appeared to sensitize the SR channel to Ca2+,
because channel-gating was not modified at picomolar Ca2+
concentration. Equimolar digitoxin had the same effect as digoxin, whereas ouabain was effective only at higher concentrations (10 nM). Spironolactone and chlormadinone, which inhibit
digoxin binding to Na+/K+ ATPase, were
uneffective.
This activation of RyR2 occurred at a therapeutic concentration, was
clearly distinct from Na+/K+ ATPase inhibition,
and might contribute to the inotropic action of digoxin and digitoxin.
Such action was similar to that of caffeine and sulmazole, but
digitalis glycosides had no effect on RyR1.
The antiarrhythmic agent R56865
(N-[1-[4-(fluorophenoxy)-butyl]4-piperidinyl]-N-methyl-2-benzothiazolamine)
inhibited [3H]digoxin binding to SR membranes (but not to
the Na+/K+-ATPase) and the response of single
SR channels to digoxin. However, in the absence of digoxin, it had no
direct effect on SR Ca2+ release nor on ryanodine binding
(McGarry et al., 1995
). This property might contribute to the
antiarrhythmic action of R56865, even if this substance acts also on
other targets, i.e., Na+ current, Na+-activated
K+ current, and, possibly, T-type sarcolemmal
Ca2+ current (Ichikawa et al., 1994
; McGarry et al., 1995
).
5. Milrinone and other bipyridine derivatives.
Both indirect
(Malecot et al., 1986
) and direct (Holmberg and Williams, 1991
)
evidence showed that milrinone
(1,6,dihydro-2-methyl-6-oxo-(3,4-bipyridine)-5-carbonitrile), a
bipyridine derivative used as an inotropic agent, can activate cardiac
RyR. At 10 µM Ca2+ concentration, 100 µM to 2 mM milrinone increased channel Po, by
reducing closed channel lifetime. At higher (100 µM)
Ca2+ concentration, the duration of channel opening
increased, which was reflected in lifetime analysis as the appearance
of a third, long-lived, open state. In binding experiments, 100 µM to 2 mM milrinone increased
[3H]ryanodine binding at a concentration of 5 nM in the presence of 5 µM Ca2+,
whereas no stimulation was produced at optimal (100 µM)
Ca2+ concentration, suggesting that milrinone increased the
Ca2+ sensitivity of the binding reaction.
Because peak plasma milrinone concentration is nearly one order of
magnitude lower than the concentrations used in this study (Prielipp et
al., 1996
), it is uncertain whether RyR modulation may contribute to
its inotropic action, which usually is attributed to phosphodiesterase
inhibition. It is worth noting that other phosphodiesterase inhibitors
such as caffeine and sulmazole are also RyR modulators. By contrast,
enoximone, another phosphodiesterase inhibitor used as an inotropic
agent, did not affect RyR function (Holmberg and Williams, 1991
).
Other dipyridine derivatives influence SR Ca2+ release. For
instance, in skeletal muscle, 1,1'-diheptyl-4,4'-bipyridinium bromide inhibited SR Ca2+ release induced by polylysine,
Ag+, or caffeine, and decreased [3H]ryanodine
binding, with IC50 of the order of 2.5 to 5 µg/ml (Kang
et al., 1994
). By contrast, diethyl bipyridinium, dibenzyl bipyridinium, and dimethyl bipyridinium had no effect on skeletal muscle SR (Kang et al., 1994
).
6. Suramin.
Suramin
(sym-bis(m-aminobenzoyl-m-amino-p-methylbenzoyl-1-naphthyl-amino-4,6,8,-trisulfonate)carbamide)
is a polysulphonated naphtylurea originally developed for the treatment
of trypanosomiasis and used as an anticancer agent. Suramin is also an
antagonist of ATP at P2 purinergic receptors. In skeletal
muscle, suramin inhibited Ca2+-ATPase activity, induced SR
Ca2+ release, and increased ryanodine binding (Emmick et
al., 1994
). RyR actions occurred at 10 µM to 1 mM concentration. The effect on ryanodine binding was
similar to that of adenine nucleotides, and the response to suramin and
AMP-PCP was not additive, suggesting that suramin interacted with the
adenine nucleotide binding site. In single-channel experiments,
micromolar suramin increased the Po of the sheep cardiac channel by
stabilizing the open states (Sitsapesan and Williams, 1996
).
7. Halogenated hydrocarbons and phenols.
Several
halogenated compounds affect SR Ca2+ release. The most
extensively studied are volatile anesthetics such as halothane (2-bromo-2-chloro-1,1,1-trifluoroethane), enflurane
(2-chloro-1-(difluoromethoxy)-1,1,2-trifluoroethane), and its isomer
isoflurane (2-chloro-2-(difluoromethoxy)-1,1,1-trifluoroethane). More
recently, hexachlorocyclohexane and chlorinated phenol derivatives have
been reported to affect RyR function. These substances have been
grouped for their structural similarity, although no common mechanism
of action has been identified.
a. VOLATILE ANESTHETICS.
In skeletal muscle and cardiac
SR preparations, halothane increased SR Ca2+ release at gas
concentrations ranging from about 0.002% to 3.8% (v/v) (Kim et al.,
1984
; Beeler and Gable, 1985
; Ohnishi, 1987
; Nelson and Sweo, 1988
;
Herland et al., 1990
; Carrier et al., 1991
; Frazer and Lynch, 1992
;
Louis et al., 1992
; Beltran et al., 1996
). The response to halothane
was Ca2+-dependent and pH- dependent. At a pH of 7.4, halothane increased the rate of Ca2+ release at all
Ca2+ concentrations, so that the normal Ca2+
dependence of Ca2+ release was retained. At a pH of 7.1, halothane shifted the Ca2+-dependence of Ca2+
release to the left, but no stimulation was observed at pCa < 5. At a pH of 6.8, no significant Ca2+ release occurred in the
absence of halothane, at any Ca2+ concentration, and the
stimulation produced by halothane was Ca2+-independent
(Beltran et al., 1996
). The response to halothane was not affected by
adenine nucleotides, and it was inhibited by ruthenium red (Beeler and
Gable, 1985
; Herland et al., 1990
; Frazer and Lynch, 1992
). Similar
effects have been observed with isoflurane and enflurane (2.5 to 4%). In single-channel experiments performed with RyRs obtained from cardiac
muscle (Connelly and Coronado, 1994
) or frog skeletal muscle (Bull and
Marengo, 1994
), halothane increased channel Po without affecting
channel conductance. Lifetime analysis showed increased duration of
open events and decreased lifetime of the closed channel. Channel
activation was reversible and Ca2+-dependent: the maximum
effect occurred at 1 to 10 µM Ca2+, whereas
Ca2+ efflux was only slightly increased at 100 µM Ca2+, and no activation was observed at
0.1 µM Ca2+. The EC50 was
inversely related to Ca2+ concentration and ranged from 13 µM to 184 µM (aqueous phase concentration),
approximately corresponding to 0.03 to 0.45% gas concentration.
Reduction of pH from 7.4 to 7.1 caused maximum channel activation to
occur at lower cis Ca2+ concentration
(Beltran et al., 1996
). Enflurane (1.6%) was also effective, but no
effect was observed with 1.4% isoflurane. Similar results have been
obtained in whole-cell patch-clamp experiments performed in ventricular
myocytes (Pancrazio and Lynch, 1994
). In contrast with these findings,
Nelson (1992)
reported that in normal human skeletal muscle, channel Po
was not affected by halothane, although increased Po was observed in
about half of the channels obtained from patients predisposed to
malignant hyperthermia (see III.C.). It should be noted that the drug
concentrations used in this study were quite low (2.2 to 17.6 µM), which might explain the failure to activate the
normal channel. Volatile anesthetics increased ryanodine binding by shifting its
Ca2+ dependence to the left. This action was
tissue-specific, because halothane and enflurane (1.5 to 2%) increased
ryanodine binding in cardiac but not in skeletal muscle, whereas the
opposite was observed with isoflurane (Connelly et al., 1992
). More
precisely, in cardiac preparations 0.75 to 1.5%, halothane increased
the density of high-affinity binding sites, whereas the
KD was unchanged, and low-affinity binding
was reduced (Lynch and Frazer, 1994
). Enflurane (3.5%) and isoflurane
(2.5%) had different effects, because high-affinity binding was
unchanged or decreased, and low-affinity binding was stimulated. The interaction of volatile anesthetics with the RyR occurred at doses
that are lower than their minimum effective alveolar concentration
(that is, about 0.75% for halothane, 1.68% for enflurane, and 1.15%
for isoflurane) and should therefore have clinical importance, contributing to the negative inotropic effect and to the transient vasoconstrictor action produced by these drugs. However, volatile anesthetics can modulate other systems involved in Ca2+
homeostasis, i.e., SR Ca2+-ATPase,
Na+/Ca+ exchange, sarcolemmal Ca2+
channel, and contractile proteins, which might also contribute to their
clinical effects (Su and Zhang, 1989
; Su et al., 1994
; Herland et al.,
1990
; Komai and Rusy, 1990
; Marijic et al., 1990
; Puttick and Terrar,
1993
; Stadnika et al., 1993
; Kakuyama et al., 1994
; Tsuchida et al.,
1994
; Wheeler et al., 1994
; Akata and Boyle, 1995
; Boyle and Maher,
1995
; Vogel et al., 1995
). Indirect studies showed that other chloromethane, chloroethane, and
chloroethylene derivatives can induce SR Ca2+ release.
Because sarcolemmal Ca2+ fluxes were also affected, it has
been speculated that the response to halogenated hydrocarbons may
reflect a nonspecific membrane action (Hoffmann et al., 1994
). Nonvolatile general anesthetics such as ketamine (Kongsayareepong et
al., 1993
; Connelly et al., 1995
) and propofol (Puttick and Terrar,
1993
; Cook and Housmans, 1994
; Fruen et al., 1995
) did not affect SR
Ca2+ release, although they inhibited ryanodine binding at
concentrations much higher than their therapeutic range (Connelly et
al., 1995
; Fruen et al., 1995
). Thiopental inhibited postrest
contraction in rabbit papillary muscle, which was interpreted as
indirect evidence of decreased SR Ca2+ release (Komai and
Rusy, 1994
).
b. PHENOL DERIVATIVES.
Chlorocresol
(chloro-methylphenol) induced Ca2+ release from skeletal
muscle terminal cisternae (Zorzato et al., 1993
), and its action was
inhibited by ruthenium red. The most effective isomer was
4-chloro-m-cresol (EC50 = 300 µM), and 4-chloro-o-cresol was much less
potent. The presence of the methyl group was important, because
p-chlorophenol was effective only at millimolar
concentrations, and the presence of chloride was critical, because
o-cresol was ineffective. In skeletal muscle terminal
cisternae and in several nonexcitable cell lines, Ca2+
release was induced also by 100 to 500 µM
4-chloro-m-ethylphenol (Larini et al., 1995
).In binding experiments, 4-chloro-m-cresol stimulated
ryanodine binding by decreasing the KD with
unchanged Bmax (EC50 = 112 µM).
In bilayer experiments, it increased channel Po by prolonging the
lifetime of the open channel (Herrmann-Frank et al., 1996
). With regard
to the latter action, the sensitivity to
4-chloro-m-cresol was higher when it was included in the
trans (luminal) chamber (EC50 = 50 µM versus 150 µM).Several polychlorinated biphenyls increased ryanodine binding and
Ca2+ release both in skeletal muscle and in cardiac SR
(Wong and Pessah, 1996
). Compounds with chloride substitutions in the
ortho-position were most active (EC50
1 µM). Polychlorinated biphenyl-activated Ca2+
release was inhibited by ryanodine and ruthenium red, but it was quite
resistant to Mg2+ inhibition.Nonhalogenated phenol derivatives also showed some activity. In
particular, several 4-alkylphenols (ethylphenol to nonylphenol) have
been reported to cause SR Ca2+ release, and the
effectiveness was proportional to the length of the alkyl chain (Beeler
and Gable, 1993a
). Thymol (5-methyl-2-isopropyl-1-phenol) and menthol
(hexahydro-thymol) have also been used to induce SR Ca2+
release (Herbette et al., 1982
; Palade, 1987b
).
c. HEXACHLOROCYCLOHEXANE.
Hexachlorocyclohexane,
particularly the
isomer, produced Ca2+ release from
cardiac SR, with EC50 = 22 µM (Pessah et al.,
1992a
).
-hexachlorocyclohexane had peculiar properties, because its
action was not inhibited by ruthenium red and was associated with
decreased ryanodine binding. In equilibrium experiments,
-hexachlorocyclohexane decreased the Bmax for ryanodine,
either in heart, skeletal muscle, or brain (IC50 = 37, 123, and 100 µM, respectively: Hill coefficient
2).
The KD showed biphasic changes, because it
decreased at low (20 to 30 µM) concentrations, and was
unchanged at higher concentrations. Pretreatment with
-hexachlorocyclohexane produced complex results: ryanodine binding
increased in membranes pretreated with 25 µM
-hexachlorocyclohexane, but decreased in membranes pretreated with
50 µM
-hexachlorocyclohexane. These results have been
interpreted on the basis of the hypothesis that
-hexachlorocyclohexane may produce sequential changes in the RyR,
whose final result is an irreversible alteration of the channel
structure, leading to increased Ca2+ efflux and preventing
the binding of ryanodine and ruthenium red.
8. Macrocyclic compounds.
a. IMMUNOSUPPRESSANT MACROLIDES.
As mentioned above
(II.A.7.c.), the macrolide immunosuppressant FK-506, also known as
tacrolimus, can induce the dissociation of FKBPs from the RyR and can
modify RyR gating. In skeletal muscle SR, 3 to 20 µM
FK-506 induced Ca2+ release by increasing channel Po and
determining the appearance of a long-lived subconductance state (Ahern
et al., 1994
; Brillantes et al., 1994
; Mayerleitner et al., 1994
). The
subconductance state corresponded to
30% of the maximum
conductance, and it was different from the ryanodine-induced
subconductance state. In the presence of FK-506, channel inactivation
by millimolar Ca2+ was alleviated. These effects appear to
be associated with inhibition of ryanodine binding, because, in liver
microsomes, FK-506 decreased ryanodine binding, due to reduced
Bmax with unchanged KD
(Kraus-Friedmann and Feng, 1994
). Interference with RyR function might
be involved in some toxic effects of FK-506, particularly in the
development of myocardial hypertrophy and failure, which has been
observed in pediatric transplant patients (Atkison et al., 1995
).
Rapamycin is another macrolide immunosuppressant that can dissociate
FKBPs from the RyR. In cardiac muscle, 0.2 to 12 µM
rapamycin increased single-channel Po and decreased channel conductance (Kaftan et al., 1996
). These effects were sequential: within 2 to 10 min from the addition of rapamycin, Po increased, owing to increased
lifetime of the open channel; with prolonged exposure (> 10 min),
channel conductance decreased. It has been speculated that the former
effect is the consequence of drug binding to FKBPs, whereas changes in
channel conductance occur after FKPB/RyR dissociation. The involvement
of FKBPs in the response to rapamycin was confirmed by the observation
that no effect was produced on channels expressed in insect cells and
lacking FKBPs (Brillantes et al., 1994
). As observed with FK-506, 20 µM of rapamycin inhibited ryanodine binding to cardiac
microsomes by decreasing the Bmax (Kaftan et al., 1996
).
b. BASTADINS.
Bastadins are macrocyclic bromotyrosine
derivatives isolated from the sponge Ianthella basta.
Bastadins are selective modulators of RyR1 (Mack et al., 1994
), and
behave either as pure agonists (e.g., bastadin 5 and bastadin 7) or as
partial agonists (e.g., bastadin 19). In the presence of > 100 µM Ca2+, bastadin 5 increased SR
Ca2+ release, and its action was inhibited by ruthenium
red. In single-channel experiments, bastadin 5 showed peculiar
properties, since it remarkably (by 50- to 180-fold) increased the
lifetime of either the open or the closed states. The final effect was
a slight increase in channel Po and a remarkable reduction in the
frequency of opening and closure events. Bastadin 5 (1 to 5 µM) decreased the KD and increased the Bmax of the high-affinity ryanodine
binding site, which was associated with a reduction in low affinity
binding. The Ca2+-dependence of ryanodine binding was
preserved, but detailed analysis showed that the affinity of the
Ca2+-inhibitory site decreased five-fold. In addition, the
IC50 for Mg2+ increased.The action of bastadins was additive with that of caffeine and adenine
nucleotides, suggesting a different site of action. Because the
response to bastadins was inhibited by FK-506, it was concluded that
bastadins interact with FKBP12 and stabilize the RyR homotetramer.
c. QUINOLIDOMICIN A1.
Quinolidomicin A1 is a
60-membered macrolide isolated from the actinomycete
Micromonospora species, which shows cytotoxic effects in
a murine leukemia cell line. In skeletal muscle SR (Ohkura et al.,
1996
), it induced Ca2+ release with EC50
20 µM. The Ca2+ dependence of Ca2+
release was not modified; the stimulation was additive with that produced by caffeine, and it was only partly inhibited by
Mg2+, procaine, and ruthenium red. In binding experiments,
quinolidomicin A1 increased the affinity for ryanodine, whereas the
Bmax was unchanged. Although these observations suggest
that quinolidomicin A1 may modulate the RyR, its precise site and
mechanism of action have not been clarified and need further
investigation.
9. Heparin.
An early study showed that 0.5 to 10 µg/ml
heparin induced Ca2+ release from skeletal muscle SR by a
ruthenium red-sensitive pathway (Ritov et al., 1985
). Single-channel
studies showed that heparin increased channel Po, with EC50 = 0.23 µg/ml and Hill coefficient
4 (Bezprozvanny et al.,
1993
). The action was Ca2+-dependent, because channel
activation was observed at 80 nM [Ca2+] but
not at [Ca2+] < 20 nM, and it was shared by
other polyanions, such as pentosan polysulfate and polyvinyl sulfate.
These results have been interpreted on the basis of the hypothesis that
heparin and related polyanions can increase the local Ca2+
concentration near the regulatory sites of the RyR.
Ryanodine binding has not been determined in the above-mentioned
studies. In brain microsomes, comparable concentrations of heparin did
not affect ryanodine binding (Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991b
). In skeletal
muscle, heparin caused a slight stimulation of ryanodine binding only
at substantially higher concentrations (0.1 to 1 mg/ml) (Ogawa and
Harafuji, 1990a
).
10. Polyamines.
Several RyR modulators have one feature in
common: the presence of several amino groups in their structures. These
substances include: inorganic polyamines such as ruthenium red,
aminoglycoside antibiotics, synthetic polyamines, endogenous
polyamines, and cationic proteins. The effects of endogenous polyamines
and of cationic proteins have been reviewed above (see II.A.5. and
II.A.7.f.).
a. RUTHENIUM RED.
Ruthenium red is a polycationic dye
with a structure that includes 14 amino groups. Ruthenium red has been
shown to inhibit SR Ca2+ release, both in cardiac muscle
and in skeletal muscle. In release experiments, effective
concentrations ranged from 1 nM to 20 µM (Kim
et al., 1983
; Chamberlain et al., 1984b
; Antoniu et al., 1985
; Chu et
al., 1986
; Meissner et al., 1986
; Meissner and Henderson, 1987
; Palade,
1987a
,c
; Chiesi et al., 1988
; Moutin and Dupont, 1988
; Baylor et al.,
1989
; Calviello and Chiesi, 1989
; Holmberg and Williams, 1989
;
Wyskovsky et al., 1990
; Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991a
,b
). In skeletal
muscle, the IC50 was of the order of 19 to 90 nM, whereas in cardiac muscle, it was slightly higher; the inhibition was incomplete, because complete blockade required the
addition of either Mg2+ or FLA365.In bilayer experiments, micromolar ruthenium red dramatically decreased
channel Po, producing a long-term closure that was substantially
irreversible on the time scale of the recordings (Smith et al., 1985
,
1986b
, 1988
; Rousseau et al., 1986
; Hymel et al., 1988
; Ma et al.,
1988
; Anderson et al., 1989
; Liu et al., 1989
; Ashley and Williams,
1990
; Lindsay and Williams, 1991
; Buck et al., 1992
). Further
information was obtained by studying the effect of ruthenium red on
ryanodine-modified channels (Ma, 1993
). The action of ruthenium red was
asymmetrical and voltage-dependent. When added to the
cis (cytosolic) chamber, ruthenium red decreased channel
Po without affecting its conductance. At low concentration (0.5 µM), the chief effect was a decreased lifetime of the
open channel, whereas at higher concentration (1.2 µM),
the lifetime of the closed channel increased (more precisely, the
percentage of long-lived versus short-lived closures increased). This
action was voltage-dependent (i.e., it was more evident at higher
holding potentials) and cooperative, with a Hill coefficient close to 2. When added to the trans (luminal) chamber, ruthenium
red decreased channel current in the trans to
cis direction (but not in the reverse direction) without
any change in Po. In binding experiments, ruthenium red inhibited ryanodine binding, with
a Hill coefficient close to 1. Decreased Bmax and increased
KD were observed, and the latter effect was
due to a slower association rate (Pessah et al., 1985
,1986
; Michalak et al., 1988
; Chu et al., 1990a
; Holmberg and Williams, 1990a
; Ogawa and
Harafuji, 1990a
; Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991a
; Mack et al., 1992
). The
IC50 was in the range of 10 to 40 nM, both in
cardiac and in skeletal muscle, whereas it was higher (600 nM) in brain (Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991b
). In addition, high
(>1 µM) concentrations of ruthenium red slowed ryanodine
dissociation, suggesting the occurrence of a persistent receptor
alteration, similar to that produced by micromolar ryanodine. In fact,
prolonged incubation with ruthenium red gave a 50% decrease in the
number of ryanodine binding sites (Mack et al., 1992
).Binding studies performed on cloned segments of RyR1 have shown
extensive overlapping among Ca2+ binding sites, calmodulin
binding sites, and ruthenium red binding sites. In particular,
ruthenium red binding sites have been localized at residues 1861 to
2094 and 3657 to 3776 (Chen and MacLennan, 1994
). On the basis of
multiple inhibition studies, Mack et al. (1992)
have suggested that
ruthenium red interacts with a subregion of the ryanodine binding site,
which also binds other polycations and is distinct from the FLA365
binding site (see II.B.11.). On the basis of single-channel results, it
has been concluded that the binding site is located within the membrane
field, probably close to the pore of the channel, and that ruthenium
red cannot permeate through the open channel (Ma, 1993
). Other inorganic polyamines structurally related to ruthenium red
inhibited SR Ca2+ release. Tetramine palladium and
tetramine platinum had similar effects in single-channel and in binding
experiments (Ma, 1993
). In addition, phthalocyanine-induced
Ca2+ release was blocked by 50 µM
hexamminecobalt chloride or hexammineruthenium chloride (Abramson et
al., 1988b
).
b. AMINOGLYCOSIDES.
Aminoglycoside antibiotics
inhibited Ca2+ release induced by Ca2+,
caffeine, thymol, or tetraphenylboron, with the following order of
potency: neomycin > gentamicin > streptomycin
clindamycin
kanamycin
tobramycin. In skeletal muscle,
the IC50 for neomycin and gentamicin was of the order of 50 to 200 nM, whereas the IC50 for the other
aminoglycosides was in the micromolar range (Meissner and Henderson,
1987
; Palade, 1987c
; Chiesi et al., 1988
; Calviello and Chiesi, 1989
;
Wyskovsky et al., 1990
; Mack et al., 1992
; Zimanyi et al., 1992
).In bilayer experiments, neomycin (5 µM) decreased channel
Po. The addition of ryanodine after neomycin produced no effect, whereas the addition of 10 µM neomycin to a
ryanodine-modified channel decreased the mean open time (Wang et al.,
1996
). Neomycin inhibited high-affinity ryanodine binding by increasing the
KD as a consequence of a slower association
rate. The IC50 was lower in skeletal than in cardiac muscle
(0.32 to 0.38 versus 5 to 37 µM), and the Hill
coefficient was < 1. The Ca2+ dependence of ryanodine
binding was unaffected (Zimanyi and Pessah, 1991a
; Mack et al., 1992
;
Wang et al., 1996
). At high concentrations (
0.6 µM),
neomycin had additional actions, because it decreased the
Bmax and slowed ryanodine dissociation. Furthermore,
prolonged incubation with 0.3 µM neomycin produced a 20%
decrease in ryanodine binding (Mack et al., 1992
). It was concluded
that high concentrations of neomycin irreversibly inactivate the RyR,
as observed with high concentrations of ryanodine or ruthenium red.
Ruthenium red and neomycin are likely to react with the same molecular
site. Assays performed after trypsin treatment confirmed that ryanodine and neomycin binding sites were located in a 76-kDa fragment, corresponding to the carboxyl terminal part of the protein (up to Arg
4475) (Wang et al., 1996
). In skeletal muscle, neomycin inhibited depolarization-induced
Ca2+ release. This action was voltage-dependent and
occurred at concentrations (1 to 100 nM) much lower than
those necessary to inhibit caffeine-induced or polylysine-induced
Ca2+ release (Yano et al., 1994
). The existence of a
high-affinity neomycin binding site able to modulate T-tubule/SR
interaction has been suggested, and [3H]neomycin binding
experiments have shown that this putative site is not localized in the
T-tubule membrane, but rather in the RyR or in some other closely
associated protein. Because therapeutic aminoglycoside concentrations are in the micromolar
range, it is possible that RyR modulation might be involved in the
toxic effects. However, this issue has not been specifically
investigated.
c. OTHER ORGANIC POLYAMINES.
Palade (1987c)
reported
that synthetic polyamines such as polylysine and polyarginine inhibited
thymol-induced Ca2+ release with an estimated
IC50 of 1 to 6 µg/ml (corresponding to about 0.5 to 1.5 µM). In a later study, Cifuentes et al. (1989)
observed a
biphasic effect: polylysine induced Ca2+ release at low
concentration (IC50 = 0.3 µM), but inhibited
Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release at higher
concentration (3 µM). El-Hayek et al. (1995c)
have
described a bell-shaped dose-response curve for the stimulation of
Ca2+ release by polylysine, with the peak at 100 nM. Polylysine-induced Ca2+ release showed the
same Ca2+ dependence as did caffeine-induced
Ca2+ release and was inhibited by 10 µM
ruthenium red. Stimulation of ryanodine binding by 1 µM
polylysine has been observed (Lu et al., 1994
).A radiolabeled polylysine derivative bound to the RyR, and the binding
was not inhibited by ruthenium red. Fluorescent labeling studies showed
that polylysine-induced Ca2+ release was preceded by a
conformational change in the junctional foot protein (El-Hayek et al.,
1995c
) and revealed that neomycin did not affect polylysine binding,
suggesting that the polylysine binding site was distinguished from the
neomycin/ruthenium red binding site (Kang et al., 1992
).
11. FLA365.
[2,6-dichloro-4-(dimethylamino)phenyl]-isopropylamine, commonly known
as FLA365, is a synthetic compound that proved to be effective in
modulating SR Ca2+ release. FLA365 inhibited
Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release from skeletal muscle
SR (Calviello and Chiesi, 1989
). At an activating free Ca2+
concentration of 2 µM, the IC50 was 3.4 µM, and full inhibition was achieved with 50 µM FLA365. However, when free Ca2+
concentration was increased to 30 µM, full inhibition of
Ca2+ release could not be produced by FLA365 alone, but
required the association of neomycin or ruthenium red. Similar results
were obtained in indirect cardiac muscle studies (Chiesi et al., 1988
), because Ca2+ uptake was minimally affected by FLA365 alone,
and the association of neomycin or ruthenium red was required to
produce a full stimulation.
Binding experiments (Mack et al., 1992
) showed that FLA365
competitively inhibited ryanodine binding at its high-affinity site and
that the IC50 was similar in skeletal and in cardiac muscle
(1.4 and 4.4 µM at 0.6 nM
[3H]ryanodine). FLA365 decreased the affinity for
ryanodine, without any change in the Bmax. Contrary to what
happened with ruthenium red and neomycin, prolonged incubation with
FLA365 produced no persistent change in ryanodine binding. The effect
of FLA365 was not modified by either ruthenium red or neomycin, and
FLA365 had no effect on ruthenium red inhibition of ryanodine binding.
It was concluded that FLA365 interacts with the RyR on a site that is
separate from the ruthenium red/neomycin site. The additive effect of
FLA365 and ruthenium red/neomycin suggested that these two sites may
correspond to subregions of a larger ryanodine binding site (Mack et
al., 1992
).
12. Dantrolene.
Dantrolene is the hydantoin derivative
1-((5-(p-nitrophenyl) furfurylidine)amino)hydantoin sodium.
It acts as a postsynaptic muscle relaxant and is the chief drug used in
the prevention and in the treatment of malignant hyperthermia (see
III.C.). In skeletal muscle SR preparations, 10 to 90 µM
dantrolene inhibited Ca2+ release (Van Winkle, 1976
;
Herbette et al., 1982
; Otha et al., 1990
). Because therapeutic
dantrolene concentration is in the range of 10 µM
(Flewellen et al., 1983
), inhibition of Ca2+ release is
likely to be responsible for its clinical effects. Dantrolene reduced
the maximum rate of Ca2+ release without affecting the
Ca2+-sensitivity of the process, and its action was much
more evident in the presence of caffeine and adenine nucleotides than
in their absence. Doxorubicin-induced Ca2+ release was
inhibited by azumolene (100 to 400 µM), a water-soluble analog of dantrolene (Tian et al., 1991
). The response to dantrolene was temperature-dependent, because Ca2+ release was
inhibited at 38°C but not at 20°C (Otha et al., 1990
). Inhibition
of SR Ca2+ release was also observed in cardiac muscle, but
the sensitivity to dantrolene was lower than in skeletal muscle.
Suarez-Isla et al. (1986)
reported that 50 µM dantrolene
decreased the Po of a skeletal muscle SR channel. Although the channel was activated by caffeine, it was not inhibited by ruthenium red, and
its conductance was much smaller than usually observed for RyRs
(maximum Ca2+ conductance = 7.9 pS). Therefore, the
nature and the physiological role of such channel are not clear.
Studies involving typical SR channels have produced conflicting
results. Bull and Marengo (1994)
reported that halothane-induced
activation of frog skeletal muscle RyR was not affected by
100 µM dantrolene. Single-channel studies using porcine and
human RyR1 (Nelson et al., 1996
) showed a biphasic response to
dantrolene: nanomolar (0.5 to 2 nM) dantrolene increased
channel Po, owing to increased lifetime of the open channel, whereas 1 to 5 µM dantrolene produced channel inactivation, which
was preceded by a transient period of increased activity and was
accounted for by an increased lifetime of the closed channel. Similar
results were obtained with purified porcine RyR1. The reasons for these
discrepancies are not clear and might be related to differences in
species, in temperature (about 20°C versus 25°C), or in the
stimulus used to activate the channel (Ca2+ and halothane
versus Ca2+ alone).
Ryanodine binding was inhibited by micromolar dantrolene and azumolene,
due to reduced affinity with unchanged Bmax (Pessah et al.,
1986
; Ogawa and Harafuji, 1990a
; Tian et al., 1991
).
Doxorubicin-stimulated binding was much more inhibited than
Ca2+-stimulated or caffeine-stimulated binding (Tian et
al., 1991
; El-Hayek et al., 1992
).
Experiments performed with [3H]dantrolene (Parness and
Palnitkar, 1995
) have shown that dantrolene binding sites and ryanodine binding sites have a parallel distribution in skeletal muscle membrane
fractions. Although high concentrations of dantrolene and azumolene
inhibited dihydropyridine binding (El-Hayek et al., 1992
), dantrolene
binding was not detectable in sarcolemmal or T-tubule membranes.
Dantrolene binding did not require Ca2+, and it was
inhibited by high ionic strength buffers and by millimolar Mg2+. Recently, selective solubilization techniques have
allowed the separation of [3H]ryanodine and
[3H]dantrolene binding sites, suggesting that dantrolene
does not interact directly with the RyR (Palnitkar and Parness, 1996
).
13. Local anesthetics.
Procaine and tetracaine inhibited SR
Ca2+ release induced by Ca2+, caffeine, or
quercetin, with IC50 of the order of 1 to 2 mM and 0.1 mM, respectively (Endo, 1977
; Morii and Tonomura,
1983
; Volpe et al., 1983
; Xu et al., 1993
; Chamberlain et al., 1984b
; Meissner, 1984
; Antoniu et al., 1985
; Palade, 1987a
; Lee et al., 1991
;
Klein et al., 1992
; Garcia and Schneider, 1995
). A similar action has
been observed with other local anesthetics, such as the tertiary amines
etidocaine, bupivacaine, prilocaine, lidocaine, and mepivacaine, the
quaternary amines QX 572 and QX 314, and the neutral anesthetic
benzocaine (Volpe et al., 1983
).
In contrast with these findings, early studies had suggested that local
anesthetics induced muscle contraction, inhibited the SR
Ca2+ pump, and stimulated SR Ca2+ release (see
Herbette et al., 1982
; Volpe et al., 1983
for review). In particular,
dibucaine was reported to stimulate Ca2+-induced
Ca2+ release (Yagi and Endo, 1980
) or to have a biphasic
action, i.e., inhibition of Ca2+ efflux at low
concentration and stimulation of Ca2+ efflux at higher
concentration (Nash-Adler et al., 1980
). In another study, millimolar
tetracaine induced Ca2+ release from skeletal muscle SR
vesicles. However, the involvement of the RyR was unlikely, because the
effect was much more evident in mixed SR vesicles than in RyR-enriched
heavy SR vesicles (Shoshan-Barmatz, 1988
). Reports of Ca2+
release induced by high concentrations of local anesthetics have been
tentatively attributed to a nonspecific increase in membrane permeability (Herbette et al., 1982
).
Single-channel studies have shown two different actions of local
anesthetics. Tetracaine and procaine decreased channel Po by
stabilizing a long-lived closed state of the channel, without affecting
its unitary conductance (Xu et al., 1993
; Zahradnikova and Palade,
1993
). The Hill coefficient for Po modulation was
2, indicating
a cooperative action, and the IC50 was comparable to that
derived from Ca2+ release experiments, i.e., 0.1 to 0.6 mM for tetracaine and 4 mM for procaine in
skeletal muscle, whereas in cardiac muscle, the IC50 for
procaine was 0.3 mM. On the other hand, QX 314 elicited a
voltage-dependent blockade of the skeletal muscle channel,
characterized by reduced conductance with unchanged Po.
Voltage-dependent blockade also was observed when millimolar
concentrations of procaine or tetracaine were used in the presence of 2 µM ryanodine, which induced the formation of a
low-conductance open state (Xu et al., 1993
). In cardiac preparations,
voltage-dependent blockade was produced by QX 222 (another quaternary
amine) and by 3 mM procaine, whereas QX 314 induced the
formation of a subconductance open state (Tinker and Williams, 1993a
).
The latter action resembled the effect of large tetra-alkylammonium
cations and has been attributed to a sterical or electrostatic
obstruction in the conduction pathway (Tinker et al., 1992a
; Tinker and
Williams, 1993b
).
Voltage-dependent blockade characterized by reduced channel conductance
without apparent changes in Po has been observed also with cocaine,
which has local anesthetic properties (Tsushima et al., 1996
). Because
the apparent KD was 38 mM at 0 mV,
this action is unlikely to have clinical importance in overdose
victims, in whom cocaine levels are in the micromolar range.
Ryanodine binding studies showed multiple actions of local anesthetics.
Both in skeletal muscle (Shoshan-Barmatz and Zchut, 1993
) and in brain
microsomes (Martin et al., 1993
), tetracaine inhibited ryanodine
binding by decreasing the Bmax, without changing the
KD (IC50 in the submillimolar
range). The inhibition decreased at high ionic strength and was
counteracted by ATP (Shoshan-Barmatz and Zchut, 1993
), wheras it
was not affected by caffeine (Martin et al., 1993
). Interaction with
the ATP binding site was suggested by the observation that tetracaine
inhibited the binding of the photoreactive ATP analogue
-32P-benzoyl-ATP. Procaine (10 mM) also
decreased ryanodine binding (Ogawa and Harafuji, 1990a
). Dibucaine had
a biphasic action, because ryanodine binding was stimulated at low (< 0.3 mM) concentrations and inhibited at higher
concentrations. Lidocaine and its analogue QX 314 stimulated ryanodine
binding by decreasing the KD, without any change
in the Bmax. In kinetic experiments, the increased affinity
for ryanodine was accounted for by an increased association rate, while
the dissociation rate was unaffected.
In summary, local anesthetics show at least two different actions.
(a) Channel inhibition, due to decreased Po and associated with reduced ryanodine binding. Such action, produced by tetracaine and
procaine, is likely to be mediated by a high-affinity binding site,
corresponding to or interacting with the Ca2+-binding and
adenine nucleotide binding sites. (b) Voltage-dependent channel blockade, characterized by reduced channel conductance. This
action occurred with lidocaine, with quaternary amines, and, possibly,
with high concentrations of procaine and tetracaine; it was associated
with increased affinity for ryanodine, and it is supposed to be
mediated by a lower-affinity site, located close to the conductive
pathway. Additional effects cannot be excluded. In particular, as
mentioned above, high concentrations of local anesthetics might affect
SR Ca2+ release by a nonspecific action on membrane
permeability.
14. Phenylalkylamines.
Phenylalkylamine Ca2+
antagonists, i.e., verapamil, gallopamil, and amipamil, are well known
blockers of the sarcolemmal L-type Ca2+ channel
(Spedding and Paoletti, 1992
; McDonald et al., 1994
). Several
investigations have provided evidence that phenylalkylamines may affect
excitation-contraction coupling directly, i.e., independently of the
modulation of the sarcolemmal Ca2+ current (Zucchi, 1996
).
Fernandez-Belda and Gomez-Fernandez (1987)
studied the release of
Ca2+ induced by tetraphenylboron in a skeletal muscle model
and concluded that verapamil and diltiazem (a benzothiazepine
Ca2+ antagonist) blocked the pathway responsible for
Ca2+ release. The action occurred in the micromolar
concentration range, and the KD for verapamil
was 8 µM. In similar experimental models,
dihydropyridines were ineffective (Fernandez-Belda and Gomez-Fernandez,
1987
; Ohkusa et al., 1991
). Indirect studies also provided interesting
results. Ca2+ antagonists have no major effect in skeletal
muscle under physiological conditions. However, at low temperature (5 to 7°C), gallopamil was able to paralyze the frog skeletal muscle:
after a conditioning K+-induced contracture, further
contraction was inhibited (Eisenberg et al., 1983
), although a normal
response was restored after membrane hyperpolarization (Berwe et al.,
1987
; Feldmeyer et al., 1990
). Contrary to L-channel
blockade, this action occurred at low temperature, but not at room
temperature (Eisenberg et al., 1983
). It was not reproduced by
Cd2+, an inorganic calcium channel blocker (Berwe et al.,
1987
), and it showed a bell-shaped dose-response relationship.
Indirect evidence of a SR action of gallopamil has been obtained also
in cardiac muscle. Zucchi et al. (1992b)
observed that low (0.01 to 0.3 µM) concentrations of gallopamil stimulated
Ca2+ uptake. The stimulation was not additive with that
produced by ryanodine, suggesting that gallopamil blocked
Ca2+ release, rather than enhancing active Ca2+
transport. Consistent with this result, Ca2+-ATPase
activity was not affected. The response to gallopamil was biphasic,
because concentrations > 1 µM were ineffective, in
accordance with the results of earlier studies, in which submicromolar concentrations had not been tested (Entman et al., 1972
; Nayler and
Szeto, 1972
; Watanabe and Besch, 1974
; Colvin et al., 1982
; Wang et
al., 1984
; Movsesian et al., 1985
). Similar results were obtained with
verapamil and diltiazem, whereas nifedipine was ineffective (Zucchi et
al., 1992a
).
In a single-channel study, Valdivia et al. (1990b)
observed that RyR1
Po decreased significantly in the presence of 50 µM verapamil, due to reduced lifetime of the open channel and reduced burst time.
Binding studies showed that gallopamil or verapamil did not affect
high-affinity ryanodine binding either in skeletal muscle or in cardiac
muscle (Pessah et al., 1985
), except possibly in pathological states or
under peculiar experimental conditions, because high verapamil
concentrations (>100 µM) increased the affinity of
ryanodine binding in the cardiomyopathic Syrian hamster (Finkel et al.,
1993
), and verapamil produced a moderate inhibition of ryanodine
binding (< 20%) in skeletal muscle if the assay was performed at
alkaline pH and at low ionic strength (Valdivia et al., 1990b
). On the
other hand, in cardiac microsomes, gallopamil inhibited low affinity
ryanodine binding, with IC50 in the micromolar range
(Zucchi et al., 1995a
). Kinetic analysis showed that gallopamil slowed
the dissociation rate of ryanodine from the low-affinity site(s) and
potentiated the effect of micromolar ryanodine on the dissociation of 4 nM [3H]ryanodine from the high-affinity site.
It was concluded that gallopamil modulates the cooperativity of
ryanodine binding and/or the transition to a receptor state
characterized by slow ryanodine dissociation.
The molecular site of action of phenylalkylamines has not been
determined. Because the dihydropyridine and RyRs remain associated, even in subcellular preparations (Marty et al., 1994
), the action might
be mediated by the former. However, the gating of solubilized SR
calcium channels by verapamil (Valdivia et al., 1990b
), and the
observation that the ratio of phenylalkylamine to nitrendipine binding
sites was higher in microsomal than in sarcolemmal preparations (Garcia
et al., 1984
), are difficult to reconcile with this hypothesis and
instead suggest that phenylalkylamines interfere directly with the RyR.
Oeken et al. (1986)
observed that [3H]verapamil
binding was enriched in cardiac SR membranes and proposed the existence
of an SR binding site for phenylalkylamines. However, this putative
site appeared to be associated with free SR rather than junctional SR,
and its relationship to the RyR is unknown.
In summary, the bulk of evidence suggests that, at equilibrium,
gallopamil and verapamil are effective at micromolar or even submicromolar concentrations and that the dose-response relationship is
bell-shaped. The latter finding has been interpreted in the context of
a modulated receptor hypothesis, with speculation that low drug
concentrations stabilize the inactive state of the SR channel, whereas
higher concentrations stabilize also the active state (Fill and Best,
1989
; Rios and Pizarro, 1991
). The issue of the effective concentration
range is critical with regard to the clinical relevance of RyR
modulation. The plasma concentrations of verapamil and gallopamil
in human patients, assuming conventional therapeutic dosages, are in
the range of 0.1 to 0.5 µM and 0.02 to 0.1 µM, respectively (Brogden and Benfield, 1994
), but
phenylalkylamines enter myocardial cells (Hescheler et al., 1982
), and
their intracellular concentration might be higher than the plasma one
(Pang and Sperelakis, 1983
).
15. Peptides.
A fraction enriched in peptides of estimated
molecular weight of 5 to 8 kDa obtained from the venom of the scorpion
Buthotus hottentota stimulated ryanodine binding in SR
preparations obtained from skeletal muscle, heart or brain (Valdivia et
al., 1991a
). The chief effect was an increase of the Bmax,
with a slight reduction of the KD, and the
estimated dissociation constant of the peptide/RyR complex was 20 to 30 nM. Peptide-stimulated binding retained a normal
Ca2+-dependence, and the stimulation was synergic with that
produced by caffeine. Single-channel experiments showed an increased
open lifetime and the appearance of a subconductance state. Contrary to
the action of ryanodine, these effects were quickly reversible.
Other RyR-modulating peptides have been purified from the venom of the
scorpion Pandinus imperator. An 8.7-kDa peptide,
imperatoxin-a, stimulated ryanodine binding by increasing the
Bmax (EC50
6 nM), whereas the
KD was unchanged, and its action was selective for the skeletal muscle isoform (Valdivia et al., 1992b
; El-Hayek et
al., 1995a
). Similar results were obtained after RyR purification. As
observed with caffeine, the stimulation of ryanodine binding was
greater at low than at high Ca2+ concentration. In
single-channel experiments, the response to imperatoxin-a was rapid and
reversible, and consisted in increased channel Po due to decreased mean
closed time.
Another Pandinus imperator venom 10.5 kDa peptide,
designated imperatoxin-i, decreased ryanodine binding (IC50
10 nM) and single-channel Po both in skeletal muscle
and in cardiac preparations (Valdivia et al., 1992b
). Although its
action was rather specific for the RyR, in skeletal muscle preparations
the binding of the dihydropyridine PN 200-110 was also partially
inhibited.
A 42-residue peptide purified from the venom of Crotalus viridis
viridis, named myotoxin-a, increased SR Ca2+ release
in skeletal muscle, at 0.1 to 10 µM concentration
(Furukawa et al., 1994
). The Ca2+-dependence of its action
resembled that of adenine nucleotides, and synergism with caffeine was
observed. Myotoxin-induced Ca2+ release was stimulated by
low concentrations of spermine, and it was inhibited by high
concentrations of spermine and by Mg2+ and ruthenium red,
whereas it was only slightly inhibited by procaine. Binding experiments
showed that myotoxin-a did not affect ryanodine binding and that
labeled myotoxin-a did not interact with the purified RyR, suggesting
that its target was a regulatory protein different from the RyR (Okhura
et al., 1995
). Myotoxin-a binding was inhibited by spermine,
K+ and Na+, but it was not affected by
Ca2+, Mg2+, ruthenium red, procaine, and
9-methyl-7-bromoeudistomin D.
Helothermine is a 25-kDa cysteine-rich protein derived from the
salivary secretion of the lizard Heloderma horridum horridum (Morrissette et al., 1995
). In single-channel experiments, micromolar helothermine decreased the Po of skeletal muscle and cardiac channels, by increasing the lifetime of the closed channel and decreasing the
lifetime of the open channel. Binding experiments showed that helothermine reversibly displaced ryanodine.
Ryanotoxin is a 11.4-kDa peptide that has been recently isolated from
the venom of the scorpion Buthotus judaicus (Morrissette et
al., 1996
). Its action was similar to that of ryanodine, because micromolar ryanotoxin stimulated Ca2+ release from skeletal
muscle SR, induced a state of reduced conductance in single-channel
recordings, and increased the affinity for [3H]ryanodine
(EC50 = 0.16 µM), without affecting the
Bmax.
Indirect evidence for RyR modulation has been reported for other
peptides. Mellitin (100 nM), the major component of bee
venom, decreased the threshold of Ca2+ release in skeletal
muscle SR preparations which were subjected to successive
Ca2+ additions until Ca2+ release was induced
(Fletcher et al., 1992
). However, mellitin did not affect
[3H]ryanodine binding. Stimulation of SR Ca2+
release was produced also by Naja naja kaouthia cardiotoxin
(Fletcher et al., 1991a
).
16. Agents producing covalent modifications.
a. SULFHYDRYL REAGENTS.
Heavy metals and mercurials
induce Ca2+ release from heavy SR preparations (Abramson et
al., 1983
, 1995
; Bindoli and Fleischer, 1983
; Salama and Abramson,
1984
; Trimm et al., 1986
; Palade, 1987b
; Brunder et al., 1988
; Nagura
et al., 1988
; Tatsumi et al., 1988
; Abramson and Salama, 1989
; Prabhu
and Salama, 1990a
; Salama et al., 1992
; Boraso and Williams, 1994
;
Tanaka and Tashjian, 1994
). This effect was produced at micromolar
concentrations (e.g., 4 µM Hg2+, 10 to 50 µM Ag+, 2 µM Cu2+,
15 µM Cd+, 20 µM
Zn2+, 5 to 50 µM mersalyl, and 5 to 50 µM p-chloromercuribenzoate), and it was
inhibited by the thiol-reducing agent dithiothreitol (DTT), suggesting
that it was mediated by sulfhydryl oxidation. In accordance with this
hypothesis, classical sulfhydryl reagents also induced Ca2+
release, which was blocked by DTT or glutathione. Such agents include
N-ethylmaleimide (1 to 30 mM), thimerosal (200 to 400 µM), 5-5'-dithiobis-(2-nitrobenzoic acid) (> 300 µM), and the highly specific thiol reagents
2,2'-dithiodipyridine (2,2'-DTDP) (> 2.5 µM), 4,4'-DTDP
(> 2.5 µM) and N-succinimidyl
3-(2-pyridyldithio)propionate (SPDP) (25 to 100 µM)
(Bindoli and Fleischer, 1983
; Palade, 1987b
; Nagura et al., 1988
; Zaidi
et al., 1989a
; Prabhu and Salama, 1990b
; Abramson et al., 1995
).
Ca2+ release induced by sulfhydryl reagents was blocked by
ruthenium red, tetracaine, or procaine, and it was dependent on pH, ionic strength, and Mg2+ concentration. Adenine nucleotides
inhibited the oxidation of SR thiols, but stimulated Ca2+
release once it was induced (Salama and Abramson, 1984
; Nagura et al.,
1988
; Stuart and Abramson, 1988
; Zaidi et al., 1989a
; Prabhu and
Salama, 1990a
,b
). These observations are consistent with the hypothesis
that the target of sulfhydryl reagents is the RyR.In some experiments, sulfhydryl reagent-induced Ca2+
release showed a fast and a slow component, and the latter was not
blocked by ruthenium red. Because sulfhydryl reagents can inhibit the SR Ca2+-ATPase, it has been suggested that the inactivated
pump might act as a pathway for Ca2+ release (Gould et al.,
1987
). However, measurements performed after pump inhibition by
vanadate have shown that the contribution of this mechanism to
Ca2+ release was negligible (Brunder et al., 1988
).
Intriguing findings have been obtained with biotinylated SPDP.
Biotinylation identified a 106-kDa protein (Zaidi et al., 1989b
;
Hilkert et al., 1992
) that contained a Ca2+-activated,
Mg2+-sensitive, and ruthenium red-sensitive channel, which
did not appear to be a proteolytic fragment nor a subunit of the RyR, because polyclonal antibodies obtained against the 106-kDa protein did
not cross-react with the RyR. The nature and functional role of this
protein remain unclear. Although sulfhydryl oxidation was associated usually with stimulation
of Ca2+ release, some authors observed that high
concentrations of heavy metals inhibited Ca2+ release
(Prabhu and Salama, 1990a
). A biphasic effect of thiol oxidation has
been observed also in single-channel and ryanodine binding experiments.
In single-channel recordings, 100 µM thimerosal increased
channel Po, but with 1 mM thimerosal, channel activation was transient and was followed by a persistent inactivation (Abramson et al., 1995
). In binding experiments, a slight increase in ryanodine binding was produced by low concentrations (0.1 to 0.3 µM) of 4,4'-DTDP or 2,2'-DTDP, but higher concentrations
reduced ryanodine binding with IC50 of the order of 1.5 to
7.5 µM. Thimerosal and SPDP had a monophasic inhibitory
action, with IC50 = 50 µM and 15 µM, respectively (Zaidi et al., 1989a
; Abramson et al.,
1995
). In the case of thimerosal, it was observed that the
KD was not modified, whereas the
Bmax was reduced. Other lines of evidence suggest that sulfhydryl oxidation can
inactivate the RyR: prolonged exposure to micromolar ryanodine promoted
channel inactivation and reduced ryanodine binding, which was prevented
by DTT (Zimanyi et al., 1992
); doxorubicin-induced stimulation of
ryanodine binding was further increased by DTT (Pessah et al., 1990
),
and in single-channel experiments, the inactivation caused by prolonged
exposure to doxorubicin was prevented by DTT (Ondrias et al., 1990
).Other oxidizing agents can modulate SR Ca2+ release by
interacting with thiol groups. H2O2 induced SR
Ca2+ release, increased channel Po, and stimulated
ryanodine binding (Boraso and Williams, 1994
; Favero et al., 1995a
). In
single-channel experiments, H2O2 increased the
lifetime of the open channel, decreased the lifetime of the closed
channel, and allowed channel openings to occur even at subactivating
Ca2+ concentration. Binding experiments showed higher
affinity for ryanodine, increased Bmax, and enhanced
Ca2+-sensitivity of the binding reaction. These responses
were inhibited by DTT, suggesting the involvement of sulfhydryl
oxidation. In bilayer and binding experiments,
H2O2 was effective at 0.1 to 0.6 mM concentration, whereas millimolar concentrations were
necessary in release experiments, probably because such experiments
were not performed under equilibrium conditions. As observed with other sulfhydryl reagents, 10-fold to 100-fold higher concentrations of
H2O2 caused an irreversible decrease in
ryanodine binding and in channel Po (Favero et al., 1995a
). Free-radical-generating systems, such as xanthine-xanthine oxidase and
iron-ascorbate, increased channel Po (Okabe et al., 1991
; Stoyanovsky
et al., 1994
), but in these models, the involvement of sulfhyrdyl
groups has not been demonstrated. Stimulation of Ca2+
release, which was inhibited by DTT or glutathione, has been observed
with phthalocyanine dyes and alcian blue (Abramson et al., 1988b
;
Koshita et al., 1993
). The different responses to sulfhydryl reagents suggest that RyRs
contain several classes of reactive sulfhydryls, possibly located
in different domains, whose oxidation produces different functional
consequences. Labeling with a coumarin maleimide identified highly
reactive sulfhydryls on the RyR and on triadin (Liu et al., 1994
). The
accessibility of these groups was enhanced under conditions favoring
channel closure and was decreased under conditions favoring channel
opening. In addition, sulfhydryl oxidation stabilized a high molecular
weight complex between RyR and triadin. On the basis of these findings,
it has been speculated that sulfhydryl oxidation might be involved in
the physiological mechanism of channel activation, possibly by
modulating RyR-triadin interaction (Trimm et al., 1986
; Abramson and
Salama, 1989
; Salama et al., 1992
; Liu and Pessah, 1994
). In contrast
with this hypothesis, in permeabilized voltage-clamped frog skeletal
muscle, excitation-contraction coupling was not affected by DTT nor by
other reducing agents, and Ca2+ release induced by caffeine
and other activators was unaffected also (Brunder et al., 1988
).
b. OTHER COVALENT REAGENTS.
The porphyrin derivative
mesotetra-(4-N-methylpyridyl)-porphine tetraiodide (TMPyP), which is
structurally similar to phthalocyanine dyes, stimulated
Ca2+ release from skeletal muscle SR vesicles with
EC50 = 18 µM (Abramson et al., 1993
). The
anionic and deiodinated phorphyrin
tetrasodium-mesotetra-(4-sulfonatophenyl)-porphine dodecahydrate was
also effective in inducing SR Ca2+ release. TMPyP-induced
Ca2+ release retained the physiological modulation by
Ca2+, Mg2+, and adenine nucleotide. It was
inhibited by ruthenium red, but not by 1 mM DTT. In binding
experiments, 30 µM TMPyP stimulated high-affinity
ryanodine binding by increasing the Bmax and by slightly
reducing the KD. Single-channel recordings
showed increased Po, which was not affected by DTT. Therefore, it seems
unlikely that sulfhydryl oxidation was involved in the response to
TMPyP. Disulfonic stilbene derivatives are amino-group modifiers and affect
the gating of several ion channels. In bilayer experiments, 100 µM 4,4'-diisothiocyanostilbene-2,2'-disulfonic acid and
4-acetoamido-4'-isothiocyanostilbene-2,2'-disulfonic acid induced the
appearance of an irreversibly open state with unitary conductance. This
action was observed both in skeletal muscle (Kawasaki and Kasai, 1989
)
and in cardiac (Zahradnikova and Zahradnik, 1993
) preparations, and it
was attributed to a covalent modification. However, in some
experiments, the instantaneous appearance of a ruthenium
red-inhibitable open state suggested that channel activation could also
be induced by noncovalent interactions. Dicyclohexylcarbodiimide is a hydrophobic carboxyl-reacting compound.
At concentrations
25 µM (EC50 = 0.3 mM), it decreased ryanodine binding and inhibited
Ca2+ release induced by alkalynization, triphenylboron, and
sulfhydryl reagents (Shoshan et al., 1981
; Yamamoto and Kasai, 1982
;
Chiesi, 1984
; Shoshan-Barmatz, 1987
; Argaman and Shoshan-Barmatz, 1988
; Michalak et al., 1988
). Lower concentrations (10 µM) did
not affect channel activation by Ca2+, but prevented the
inactivation produced by Mg2+, ruthenium red, or high
Ca2+ concentration (Martinez-Azorin et al., 1993
). Labeling
experiments showed minimal dicyclohexylcarbodiimide incorporation in
high molecular weight proteins, suggesting that it might not act
directly on the RyR (Argaman and Shoshan-Barmatz, 1988
). Fluorescin-5'-isothiocyanate, which reacts with lysine
-amino
groups, inhibited ryanodine binding (IC50 = 20 µM) without affecting the affinity for ryanodine, whereas
in single-channel experiments, it increased channel Po and induced the
appearance of subconductance states (Orr et al., 1993
). Acetic or
maleic anhydride, also thought to react with lysine amino groups,
induced rapid Ca2+ release (Shoshan-Barmatz, 1986
). Like fluorescin-5'-isothiocyanate, the histidyl reagent
diethylpyrocarbonate (0.1 to 1 mM) decreased ryanodine
binding (reduced Bmax with unchanged
KD), and yet favored Ca2+
release (Aoki and Oba, 1989
; Shoshan-Barmatz and Weil, 1994
). Ca2+ release was induced also by ethoxyformic anhydride,
another histidine-modifying reagent (Stuart et al., 1992
). It has been
suggested that these amino acid reagents may react with residues
located in the ryanodine binding site, thus preventing ryanodine
binding and, at the same time, reproducing the effect of nanomolar
ryanodine, i.e., channel activation.The photo-oxidation of rose bengal generates singlet oxygen. This
experimental system produced SR Ca2+ release and increased
channel Po (Holmberg et al., 1991
; Stuart et al., 1992
; Xiong et al.,
1992
). The response to rose bengal had some peculiarities, because the
stimulation of Ca2+ release was not inhibited by
Mg2+ and was associated with reduced ryanodine binding
(Stuart et al., 1992
). In another study, prolonged exposure to rose
bengal eventually produced channel inactivation (Holmberg et al.,
1991
). The molecular target of rose bengal photo-oxidation is probably a histidyl residue.
17. Others.
High concentrations of propranolol inhibited
Ca2+ accumulation and yet stimulated
Ca2+-ATPase activity, which was interpreted as evidence of
an activation of Ca2+ efflux (Shoshan-Barmatz, 1988
).
Recently, it has been reported (Zchut et al., 1996
) that 1 to 2 mM propranolol increased the Bmax for ryanodine
in skeletal muscle junctional SR, without any change in the
KD. However, this effect was not observed with
purified RyR1, and at low ionic strength (0.2 M NaCl),
ryanodine binding was inhibited. Under these experimental conditions,
propranolol caused a partial loss of the Ca2+ dependence
and pH dependence of ryanodine binding, and its effect was antagonized
by ATP. Single-channel experiments confirmed that 0.2 mM
propranolol elicited complete channel blockade. The subsequent addition
of ATP reactivated the channel but induced the appearance of a low
conductance state. Therefore, propranolol appears to have complex
actions that have not been completely clarified. In any case, RyR
modulation was observed only at very high concentrations, and it should
not have any clinical relevance.
The observation that calmodulin inhibited Ca2+ release (see
II.A.7.b.) promoted the investigation of calmodulin antagonists. Meissner (1986a)
reported that trifluoperazone, calmidazolium, and
compound 48/80 did not affect SR Ca2+ release when used at
concentrations able to inhibit calmodulin-mediated interactions in
other systems (respectively, 25 µM, 5 to 25 µM, and 5 to 25 µg/ml). However, Ca2+
release was stimulated at higher concentrations, i.e., 40 to 500 µM trifluoperazone, 100 µM calmidazolium,
and 20 to 70 µg/ml compound 48/80 (Chamberlain et al., 1984b
;
Wyskovsky et al., 1988
; Vale, 1990
). Ca2+ release was
inhibited by Mg2+ and ruthenium red, suggesting that it was
not due to a nonspecific increase in membrane permeability. A biphasic
action was observed with N-(6-aminohexyl)-5-chloro-1-naphtalene
sulfonamide (W7): 10 µM W7 reduced Po, but 100 µM W7 reactivated the channel (Smith et al., 1989
).
Chlorpromazine (160 to 200 µM) was also effective, whereas other calmodulin antagonists such as bepridil and felodipine were not (Bindoli and Fleischer, 1983
; Palade, 1987b
; Wyskovsky et al.,
1988
). On the whole, although some calmodulin antagonists may affect SR
Ca2+ release, calmodulin antagonism does not appear to be
involved in such an action.
BisG10 (1,10-bis-guanidino-n-decane) is a blocker of the SR
K+ channel. In skeletal muscle, 70 to 360 µM
bisG10 inhibited Ca2+-induced and caffeine-induced
Ca2+ release (Allard et al., 1992
). This action was not
accounted for by inhibition of K+ counter-transport,
suggesting direct interaction with the RyR, which was confirmed by the
observation that bisG10 inhibited ryanodine binding. The inhibition was
characterized by reduced Bmax with unchanged
KD.
Inhibition of Ca2+ release by the K+-ATP
channel opener pinacidil was suggested by its effect on the
ryanodine-sensitive outward current in vascular smooth muscle (Xiong et
al., 1991
). However, in skeletal muscle, the K+-ATP opener
cromakalim and the K+-ATP blocker glibenclamide had no
effect on caffeine-induced Ca2+ release (Ishida et al.,
1992
). In the same preparation, aspecific K+ blockers such
as 4-aminopyridine and tetraethylammonium chloride induced SR
Ca2+ release, but this was attributed to SR depolarization.
Therefore, there is no clear evidence of any direct action of these
K+ blockers on the RyR.
Micromolar concentrations of the triazine dyes cibacrom blue F3A-G
(reactive blue 3) and reactive red 120 induced Ca2+ release
from skeletal muscle SR vesicles and increased channel Po in bilayer
experiments (Xu et al., 1989
). Benzimidazole dyes such as hoechst 33342 and hoechst 33258 inhibited the SR channel incorporated into lipid
bilayers. However, in Ca2+ release experiments, these two
compounds had opposite effects, because the former inhibited and the
latter stimulated Ca2+ release (Beeler and Gable, 1993b
).
Several other substances have been used to induce SR Ca2+
release, but their action has not been fully characterized. These include quercetin (Kim et al., 1983
; Antoniu et al., 1985
; Palade, 1987b
), originally used as Ca2+-ATPase inhibitor; the
fungicides miconazole, clotrimazole and ketonazole (Palade, 1987b
); and
the alcohols 1-heptanol and 1-octanol (Ma et al., 1988
). Other
compounds have been suggested to modulate the RyR on the basis of
indirect studies, usually relying on the measurement of tension
development, which still need confirmation by direct methods. These
include the putative activators DPI 201-106 (Kihara et al., 1989
),
KT-362 (Kodama and Shibata, 1991
), and cyclosporin A (Banijamali et
al., 1993
), the putative inhibitors TMB-8 (Himmel and Ravens, 1990
),
2,3-butanedione monoxime (Gwathmey et al., 1991
), and
methylenedioxyndenes (Rahwan, 1985
).
Ca2+ release can be induced in skeletal muscle SR by
replacing permeable cations with impermeable ones, or by replacing
impermeable anions with permeable ones. This phenomenon occurs only
when the connection between the junctional SR and the sarcolemmal
T-tubule is preserved. After T-tubule dissociation, Ca2+
release was still induced by caffeine or other drugs, but not by ion
replacement (Ikemoto et al., 1984
), suggesting that the latter acted
indirectly by depolarization of the T-tubule membrane.
C. Overview of the Mechanisms of Ryanodine Receptor Modulation
The investigations reviewed above (II.A. and II.B.) have shown
that the RyR is the target of multiple agents having complex pharmacological actions. The assessment of a putative modulator requires dose-response studies of its effect on Ca2+
release, single-channel gating, ryanodine binding (by equilibrium and
kinetic experiments), and of its interaction with other modulators. Such a thorough evaluation has not been performed for most modulators. However, some general patterns of RyR modulation can be tentatively identified. The proposed classification, the major features of which
are outlined in table 3, is based on pharmacological
actions, rather than chemical structure of agents, because some agents show multiple actions, possibly mediated by interaction with different molecular sites.
A special position (class I) is reserved to ryanodine-like action, both
for historical reasons and for the peculiar properties of ryanodine,
which affects both channel conductance and channel gating, leading to a
biphasic effect on Ca2+ release, as described in detail
above (B.1.). Agents that modulate channel gating but do not affect
channel conductance are included in classes II-V, whereas agents that
decrease channel conductance without affecting the Po are included in
class VI. An additional group (class VII) is defined by a peculiar
action, namely delayed persistent channel inactivation.
Class II action (typical activation) is characterized by channel
activation due to increased Po (increased lifetime of the open channel
and/or decreased lifetime of the closed channel) with unchanged channel
conductance and increased affinity for [3H]ryanodine.
Several patterns can be distinguished. Ca2+-activation
deserves special emphasis because Ca2+ is the physiological
activator of the RyR. Increased Po is mainly due to decreased lifetime
of the closed channel, and in binding experiments, both the density of
ryanodine binding sites and the affinity for ryanodine are increased,
the latter due to an increased association rate. Another pattern
is characterized by Ca2+-sensitization, i.e.,
substantial stimulation of Ca2+ release at suboptimal
Ca2+ concentration, with minimal stimulation at optimal
Ca2+ concentration. In single-channel experiments, the main
effect is a decreased lifetime of the closed channel, although, at
higher drug concentration, the lifetime of the open channel may be
increased. In binding experiments, the affinity for ryanodine is
increased, while the Bmax is either unchanged or slightly
increased. Such modes of action are shown by caffeine,
9-methyl-7-bromoeudistomin D, sulmazole, doxorubicin, and possibly by
digoxin. The third pattern is characterized by (a)
substantial stimulation of Ca2+ release at high
Ca2+ concentrations; (b) parallel effect on open
and closed states, with increased lifetime of the open channel and
decreased lifetime of the closed channel; and (c) greater
increase in the Bmax for ryanodine. This is the effect of
adenine nucleotides, of suramin, and, possibly, of some oxidizing
agents, e.g., H2O2.
These substances appear to interact at closely related molecular sites.
On the basis of indirect evidence, Pessah et al. (1987)
suggested the
existence of distinct but interacting sites for Ca2+-Mg2+, adenine nucleotides, and caffeine.
Additional sites are likely to exist. For instance, although
doxorubicin and caffeine have a similar action, they do not interact
with the same site (Abramson et al., 1988a
).
Class III action (atypical activation) is defined as stimulation of
Ca2+ release with unchanged channel conductance, which does
not fulfill the criteria set for class II action. Such behavior is
shown, for instance, by halothane, which does not modify the affinity for ryanodine, although it seems to increase the number of ryanodine binding sites, and by heparin, which does not affect ryanodine binding
except possibly at very high concentrations. Class III agents should
also include hexachlorocyclohexane and rose bengal, which inhibit
ryanodine binding, and bastadins, which stabilize both the open and the
closed states of the channel. On a molecular level, different
mechanisms of action may produce an atypical activation, e.g.,
halothane might have a nonspecific membrane action, heparin might
increase local Ca2+ concentration close to the
Ca2+ activation site, and bastadins might interact with FK
binding proteins.
Class IV action (typical inhibition), is the opposite of class II
action, i.e., channel inhibition due to reduced Po with unchanged
conductance and decreased affinity for [3H]ryanodine.
These effects are produced by the "physiological" inhibitor
Mg2+ and by millimolar Ca2+. Other typical
inhibitors include ruthenium red, aminoglycosides, and FLA365.
Ca2+ and Mg2+ act at divalent cations sites
that seem to overlap at least in part with the polyamine binding sites.
It has been suggested that the polyamine binding site and the FLA365
binding site may represent different subregions of the ryanodine
binding site (Mack et al., 1992
). However, these conclusions are
largely speculative, and the concept that all polyamines interact with
the same site has been challenged (Kang et al., 1992
).
Class V action (atypical inhibition) is defined as inhibition of
Ca2+ release with unchanged channel conductance, which does
not fulfill the criteria set for class IV action. For instance, low
concentrations of procaine and tetracaine decrease ryanodine binding
but do not modify the affinity for ryanodine, whereas phenylalkylamines
affect low-affinity rather than high-affinity ryanodine binding.
Dantrolene action should also be considered as atypical, because it
shows peculiar properties, namely preferential inhibition of
doxorubicin-induced versus Ca2+-induced Ca2+
release, and complex, probably biphasic effects on single-channel gating.
Class VI action (channel blockade) is characterized by reduced
conductance of the open channel with unchanged Po, as produced, for
instance, by spermine and quaternary amines. Ryanodine binding is
usually stimulated, and these agents are likely to interact with
site(s) located close to the conduction pathway of the channel pore.
Prolonged incubation with micromolar ryanodine or other modulators
determines a persistent loss of channel function associated with
reduced ryanodine binding. This action has been observed with
substances that show different acute effects, such as doxorubicin, ruthenium red, and neomycin, and it might be mediated by sulfhydryl oxidation, because, in several experimental models, it was prevented by
disulfide-reducing agents. As discussed above (II.B.16.a.), it is
likely that a similar process may account for the reduction in
ryanodine binding observed after prolonged incubation with sulfhydryl-oxidizing compounds. Because the available evidence suggests
that the molecular mechanisms involved in delayed channel inactivation
are different from those that are responsible for acute effects, we
suggest that the former be considered as a separate and independent
(class VII) action.
An important issue is the observation that some modulators have a
selective action on a specific RyR isoform. RyR1 selectivity has been
described with palmitoyl carnitine, bastadins, and imperatoxin-a, whereas digoxin and possibly adenosine are selective for RyR2. However,
several modulators have not been tested comparatively in different
tissues, and their selectivity is unknown.
 |
III. The Ryanodine Receptor in Disease |
A. Myocardial Ischemia and Reperfusion
Myocardial ischemia is associated with important modifications of
intracellular Ca2+ homeostasis (Lee et al., 1987
;
Steenbergen et al., 1987
). Whereas Ca2+ transients undergo
complex time-dependent changes, mean cytosolic Ca2+
increases progressively during the first seconds or minutes of ischemia
(Lee and Allen, 1992
). Cytosolic Ca2+ overload contributes
to the development of cellular injury by multiple mechanisms, such as
the activation of Ca2+-dependent proteases and
phospholipases (Opie, 1989
; Silverman and Stern, 1994
). Postischemic
reperfusion may lead to either a progressive normalization of
intracellular Ca2+ homeostasis, which is associated with
functional recovery, or an exacerbation of Ca2+ overload,
which is associated with the development of irreversible cellular
injury. Due to the importance of Ca2+ in the
pathophysiology of ischemic injury, the effects of ischemia and
reperfusion on the systems involved in Ca2+ homeostasis
have raised special interest. The effect of myocardial ischemia on SR
function has been reviewed recently by Mubagwa (1995)
.
The function of RyR2 in experimental models of ischemia and reperfusion
has been evaluated initially on the basis of indirect methods, namely
the effect of channel blockers such as ryanodine or ruthenium red on
oxalate-supported Ca2+ uptake. The results have not been
unequivocal: whereas Ca2+ uptake, as measured in the
absence of inhibitors, was consistently reduced, the extent of the
stimulation produced by ryanodine or ruthenium red was either decreased
(Limbruno et al., 1989
), unchanged (Rehr et al., 1991
; Kaplan et al.,
1992
; Zucchi et al., 1994
), or increased (Feher et al., 1989
;
Abdelmeguid and Feher, 1994
; Wu and Feher, 1995
). Davis et al. (1992)
reported decreased response to ruthenium red and increased response to
ryanodine in homogenates obtained from ischemic rat hearts. In the
isolated rat heart preparation studied by Tani et al. (1996)
, the
stimulation of Ca2+ uptake produced by ryanodine was
increased after prolonged (40 min) ischemia, but it was reduced after
brief (10 min) hypoxia. Reasons for these discrepancies remain to be
defined. It has been claimed that the use of purified SR fractions may
introduce a bias, because the preparative procedures result in the loss
of more than 90% of the Ca2+ uptake activity and might
select vesicles that are not representative of the whole SR (Feher et
al., 1980
; Rapundalo et al., 1986
). However, different results were
obtained, even in unfractionated homogenates. Another potential bias is
related to SR disruption during tissue homogenization. As mentioned
above (I.B.4.), only part of the SR vesicles formed after
homogenization contain RyRs, and channel-containing vesicles cannot
accumulate Ca2+ unless the channel is blocked (Jones and
Cala, 1981
; Feher and Lipford, 1985
). Therefore, a different
distribution of RyRs between SR vesicles, possibly produced by
different homogenization and fractionation procedures, or by altered
physical-chemical properties of the SR membrane, might bias the results
of the Ca2+ uptake studies.
This potential bias can be overcome with the use of intact or skinned
cells. In skinned cardiomyocytes subjected to simulated ischemia, the
stimulation of Ca2+ uptake produced by ruthenium red and
procaine decreased at pCa < 6 (Hohl et al., 1992
). In another
study, tension development after exposure to caffeine, which is another
indirect index of SR Ca2+ release, was decreased in human
myocardium subjected to surgical ischemia (Luciani et al., 1993
).
Ca2+ release experiments performed with quick filtration
techniques showed that the rate constant of Ca2+-induced
Ca2+ release decreased after ischemia or
ischemia-reperfusion (Zucchi et al., 1995b
), whereas the
Ca2+-dependence of Ca2+ release and its
modulation by Mg2+, H+, and ruthenium red were
preserved (Darling et al., 1992
; Zucchi et al., 1995b
). These changes
appeared after a few minutes of ischemia. In particular, in the
isolated working rat heart, the rate of Ca2+ release
decreased after three cycles of 3-min ischemia and 3-min reperfusion,
whereas three cycles of 1-min ischemia and 3-min reperfusion were
ineffective. RyR dysfunction disappeared after 3 to 4 h of
reperfusion.
Darling et al. (1992)
reported that ryanodine binding decreased in
heavy SR vesicles obtained from dog ventricular myocardium subjected to
prolonged (60 min) ischemia, but the implications of this finding were
not clear, because of potential contamination of ischemic SR vesicles
by myofibrillar proteins. Reduced ryanodine binding has been observed
also in microsomes and crude homogenates obtained from isolated rat
hearts subjected to ischemia or ischemia-reperfusion (Zucchi et al.,
1994
, 1995b
). Significant reduction occurred after 10 min of ischemia,
i.e., in the absence of irreversible tissue injury, and no further
decrease was observed after prolonged (up to 30 min) ischemia. Maximal
binding was reduced by 15 to 25%, while the KD
and KDCa were unchanged. Valdivia et
al. (1995a)
have obtained recently similar results with SR vesicles
obtained from pig myocardium subjected to 10 min of ischemia and 120 min of reperfusion, whereas no change in ryanodine binding has been observed by Wu and Feher (1995)
, who used Langendorff-perfused rat
hearts subjected to 15 min of ischemia. Because the latter was a
nonworking model, the extent of ischemic injury may have been lower
than in the other studies.
In single-channel experiments, Holmberg and Williams (1992)
did not
observe significant differences between channels obtained from ischemic
versus control sheep myocardium. In a similar study, Valdivia et al.
(1995a)
used RyRs obtained from pig ventricular myocardium subjected to
10 min of ischemia and 120 min of reperfusion, and observed that
ischemia-reperfusion reduced channel Po.
On the whole, the bulk of evidence suggests that myocardial ischemia is
associated with a moderate and persistent reduction in the number of
active SR channels. The molecular mechanism of this action remains to
be determined. In a preliminary report, it has been shown that the
decrease of Ca2+ release observed after
ischemia-reperfusion can be prevented or reversed by DTT, suggesting
that sulfhydryl oxidation might play a role (Ronca-Testoni et al.,
1996
).
It is not easy to predict the pathophysiological consequences of these
findings. The cytosolic Ca2+ overload produced during
ischemia largely represents a redistribution of intracellular
Ca2+ (Kleber and Oetliker, 1992
), which is due to
inhibition of the SR and sarcolemmal Ca2+-ATPases because
of reduced ATP phosphorylation potential, in the face of persisting SR
Ca2+ release. A moderate reduction in RyR density cannot
prevent Ca2+ overload, although it might possibly affect
its time course. During reperfusion, persistent abnormalities in SR
function might affect the capability of the cell to cope with increased
cytosolic Ca2+, although other processes, such as recovery
of Ca2+-ATPase function and reversal of
Na+/Ca2+ exchange, are likely to have equal or
greater importance (Tani, 1990
; Silverman and Stern, 1994
).
RyR dysfunction might be involved in the pathogenesis of some peculiar
postischemic syndromes, namely myocardial stunning and ischemic
preconditioning. Stunning refers to persistent contractile dysfunction
occurring after ischemia and reperfusion, in the absence of any
necrosis (Braunwald and Kloner, 1982
; Bolli, 1990
; Hearse, 1991
;
Kusuoka and Marban, 1992
). The contractile impairment lasts hours or
days and is eventually reversible. Although the molecular mechanisms
responsible for myocardial stunning are not completely clear, reduced
Ca2+ sensitivity of the contractile proteins (Kusuoka and
Marban, 1992
; Atar et al., 1995
; Gao et al., 1995
) and reduced SR
Ca2+ release represent the most likely causes. The latter
phenomenon has been attributed to depletion of the SR Ca2+
pool, owing to reduced activity of the SR Ca2+-ATPase
(Krause et al., 1989
; Limbruno et al., 1989
; Krause, 1991
; Krause and
Rozanski, 1991
; Zucchi et al., 1996
), but RyR alteration might also
play an important role.
Ischemic preconditioning is a term used to describe the increased
resistance to ischemic injury caused by previous exposure to one or
more brief periods of ischemia-reperfusion (Murry et al., 1986
).
Several effectors have been implicated in the pathophysiology of
ischemic preconditioning (Marber and Yellon, 1996
), and myocardial protection appears to be related to changes in Ca2+
homeostasis, because the development of cystosolic Ca2+
overload is delayed in the preconditioned myocardium (Steenbergen et
al., 1993a
,b
). A reduction in the number of active SR channels might
contribute to such a delay. The observation that the time course of RyR
changes parallels the time course of myocardial protection (Zucchi et
al., 1995b
) supports this hypothesis, which deserves further
investigation.
B. Cardiac Hypertrophy and Failure
In pressure overload-induced cardiac hypertrophy of rat, guinea
pig, and ferret, RyR density was reduced, if expressed per mg of
protein, whereas the affinity for ryanodine was unchanged (Naudin et
al., 1991
; Sainte Beuve et al., 1992
; Kim et al., 1994a
; Rannou et al.,
1995
). It has been calculated that RyR density per unit of SR surface
was reduced by about 50%, whereas the density of dihydropyridine
receptors was unchanged. Consistently, the expression of RyR2 messenger
ribonucleic acid (mRNA) decreased in rat and in rabbit
pressure-overload hypertrophy (Matsui et al., 1995
; Rannou et al.,
1996
). Arai et al. (1996)
described a biphasic response, because RyR2
mRNA increased in mild hypertrophy and decreased to subnormal levels as
the severity of hypertrophy increased. Although the functional
consequences of these observations remain to be determined, it has been
speculated that RyR2 down-regulation may be involved in the decrease of
Ca2+ transients observed in the hypertrophic myocardium
(Sainte Beuve et al., 1992
; Carré et al., 1993
). Qualitative
abnormalities in channel function have been described. In particular,
Kim et al. (1994a)
reported that the stimulation of ryanodine binding and of Ca2+ release produced by caffeine and doxorubicin
was greater in hypertrophied than in control hearts.
The cardiomyopathic Syrian hamster is a well-known model of hereditary
cardiomyopathy, with a phenotype that is transmitted in
autosomal-recessive fashion. The disease is characterized by progressive myocytolytic necrosis, which begins at 30 to 40 days of age
and leads to fatal congestive heart failure at 10 to 12 months of age.
In SR preparations obtained from 1-month-old to 2-month-old
cardiomyopathic hamsters, the density of ryanodine binding sites was
increased, and the affinity for ryanodine was unchanged (Finkel et al.,
1992
; Sapp and Howlett, 1995
). This finding has been attributed to
increased efficiency of junctional SR isolation (Tawada-Iwada et al.,
1993
), possibly due to decreased resistance of cell membranes to
osmotic stress, owing to structural protein deficiency (Iwata et al.,
1993
; Roberds et al., 1993
). In fact, in unfractionated homogenates and
in crude membrane preparations, ryanodine binding was either unchanged
(Tawada-Iwada et al., 1993
) or decreased (Lachnit et al., 1994
), and
RyR2 mRNA was decreased also (Lachnit et al., 1994
). RyR2 had abnormal
functional properties in the cardiomyopathic hamster, because ryanodine
binding showed an increased sensitivity to Ca2+ activation
and doxorubicin activation (Lachnit et al., 1994
). The implications of
these findings are not clear. It has been speculated that myocyte
necrosis be mediated by cytosolic Ca2+ overload, which
might be favored by abnormal SR channel gating. However, in 110-day-old
cardiomyopathic hamsters, total cellular Ca2+ was not
increased, and junctional SR Ca2+ was decreased (Keller et
al., 1995
): the decrease was attributed to Ca2+-ATPase
dysfunction.
Similar findings have been obtained in other experimental models of
heart failure. As mentioned above (II.B.3.), ryanodine binding was
reduced in the cardiomyopathy produced by chronic doxorubicin
administration (Pessah et al., 1992b
; Dodd et al., 1993
). In SR
preparations obtained from dogs with heart failure that was induced by
rapid pacing, the Bmax for ryanodine was reduced, whereas
the KD was unchanged (Cory et al., 1993
; Vatner
et al., 1994
). Reduced Bmax for ryanodine was also observed
in dogs with spontaneous dilated cardiomyopathy (Cory et al., 1993
) and
also after endotoxin administration, which is known to produce
myocardial depression (Liu and Wu, 1991
). These results should be
interpreted with a note of caution, because SR fractions obtained from
failing myocardium might not be comparable to control SR fractions.
Indirect studies have supported the concept of defective RyR2 function
in experimental heart failure. After rapid pacing, the mechanical
restitution response, postextrasystolic potentiation, and
ryanodine-induced stimulation of Ca2+ uptake were decreased
(Cory et al., 1993
, 1994
; Vatner et al., 1994
). In furazolidone-induced
turkey cardiomyopathy, indirect studies produced complex results, which
were interpreted as evidence of defective SR channel function,
associated with a nonspecific (i.e., not related to the RyR) increase
in SR permeability (O'Brien et al., 1991
).
Rats with streptozocin-induced diabetes mellitus develop a form of
cardiomyopathy. In the crude homogenate obtained from diabetic hearts,
ryanodine binding was reduced, due to reduced Bmax with unchanged KD (Yu et al., 1994
). The functional
relevance of this finding was confirmed in myocyte experiments, because
the amplitude of caffeine-induced or rapid cooling-induced contracture
was decreased.
Human studies have relied on samples obtained from the hearts of
patients undergoing cardiac transplantation, with donor heart samples
as controls. According to Brillantes et al. (1992)
, RyR2 mRNA was
reduced in patients with end-stage heart failure due to ischemic
cardiomyopathy, whereas no change was observed in patients with
end-stage dilated cardiomyopathy. In other series, RyR2 mRNA was
reduced in end-stage heart disease, irrespective of etiology (Arai et
al., 1993
; Go et al., 1995
).
However, changes in gene transcription do not necessarily correspond to
changes in protein expression. Although Go et al. (1995)
have reported
a reduction of ryanodine binding in a small series of four patients, in
two larger series, no change in cardiac RyRs has been observed, on the
basis of either immunological techniques (Meyer et al., 1995
) or
[3H]ryanodine binding (Nimer et al., 1995
; Schumacher et
al., 1995
).
Indirect studies have provided conflicting results. The stimulation of
Ca2+ uptake produced by ryanodine was reduced in SR
vesicles associated with end-stage ischemic or dilated cardiomyopathy
(Nimer et al., 1995
; O'Brien and Gwathmey, 1995
). However, in skinned
fibers obtained from dilated cardiomyopathy patients, the analysis of caffeine-induced tension development suggested that the rate and extent
of Ca2+ release were normal, although the caffeine
threshold was increased (D'Agnolo et al., 1992
). The latter finding
might imply abnormal channel gating, yet no gating abnormality has been
reported in bilayer experiments using channels obtained from explanted
hearts (Holmberg and Williams, 1989
, 1992
).
A serious limitation of the human studies is the use of severely
diseased tissue. Although all investigators took care in avoiding scars
and grossly abnormal tissue, the presence of fibrosis and/or myocyte
degeneration was a potential bias that could be neither excluded nor
quantified. Besides, most patients were receiving an intensive
pharmacological treatment (e.g., digoxin, adrenergic agents,
nonadrenergic inotropes), which may have affected RyR function of RyR
gene expression.
In summary, the study of RyR changes in heart failure is at an early
stage, and controversial findings have been reported. Reduced RyR2
density has been observed in different models of heart failure. In some
cases, RyR2 mRNA was also reduced, suggesting that the down-regulation
was due to reduced synthesis of the channel protein. Abnormal channel
gating has been occasionally described, but this issue requires
confirmation. The functional implications of these findings have not
been established. Abnormal Ca2+ handling appears to be a
key feature of heart failure, leading to prolongation of
Ca2+ transients, reduced Ca2+ availability for
the contractile process, and increased susceptibility to stimuli
inducing Ca2+ overload (Gwathmey et al., 1987
; Katz, 1990
;
Hano and Lakatta, 1991
; Morgan, 1991
). These phenomena are usually
attributed to decreased Ca2+-ATPase activity, but RyR2
down-regulation might contribute to reduce SR Ca2+ release.
On the other hand, modulation of Ca2+ uptake and release
might be regarded as a compensatory mechanism leading to lower energy
expenditure.
C. Malignant Hyperthermia
Alterations in RyR1 have been implicated in the pathogenesis of
malignant hyperthermia (MH), and this issue has been addressed in
several recent reviews (Joffe et al., 1992
; MacLennan and Phillips, 1992
, 1995
; Ohnishi and Ohnishi, 1993
; Gronert and Antognini, 1994
;
Mickelson and Louis, 1996
).
MH in an autosomal-inherited myopathy, characterized by sustained
uncontrolled skeletal muscle contracture, hypermetabolism, hyperkalemia, hyperthermia, and cardiac arrhythmias. The syndrome is
most often triggered by the administration of halogenated anesthetics such as halothane and/or of the depolarizing neuromuscular blocker succinylcholine, and it can be fatal unless immediately treated with
dantrolene. It is one of the main causes of anesthesia-induced death,
occurring in about 1/40,000 adult and 1/150,000 pediatric surgical
cases. In pigs, physical stress due to sudden changes in ambient
temperature, excitement, transport, or fighting is the major inducing
factor for a MH-like syndrome, usually referred to as porcine stress
syndrome.
The characteristic feature of MH is muscle contracture. Sustained
contracture is due to abnormal myoplasmic Ca2+ elevation,
which determines a massive activation of both aerobic and glycolytic
metabolism, accounting for metabolic and respiratory acidosis and
hyperkalemia. Higher resting Ca2+ levels have been observed
in MH muscle fibers by using Ca2+ microelectrodes, but this
result has not been confirmed with fluorescent
Ca2+-specific dyes (reviewed by Mickelson and Louis, 1996
).
In any case, the peculiar property of MH muscle is an abnormal
sensitivity to stimuli that induce SR Ca2+ release. In
particular, lower concentrations of halothane and caffeine are required
in MH than in normal fibers to increase intracellular Ca2+
concentration and tension development. This is the basis of the clinical test used to assess MH susceptibility, which consists of
determining the contracture threshold of muscle bundle biopsy specimens
exposed to incremental doses of either caffeine, or halothane, or a
combination of these agents. However, standardization of the test and
precise definition of positive versus negative responses are still
controversial issues. It has been observed recently that micromolar
concentrations of 4-chloro-m-cresol induce contracture in
MH-susceptible muscle and potentiate the caffeine contracture response
(Tegazzin et al., 1996
). Because chlorocresol is a preservative added
to commercial succinylcholine preparations, it might be responsible for
the cases of "succinylcholine-induced" MH.
SR function has been extensively studied in MH-susceptible patients and
in MH-susceptible animals (pigs). We will first deal with the animal
model, and then with the human disease.
Many studies have demonstrated that active SR Ca2+
transport is normal in MH-susceptible pigs (reviewed by Mickelson and
Louis, 1996
). On the other hand, significant abnormalities in
Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release have been observed.
In skinned fibers and in SR preparations, the rate and extent of
Ca2+ release were higher than normal (Ohnishi, 1987
;
Ohnishi et al., 1983
; Kim et al., 1984
; Mickelson et al., 1987
,
1988
; Donaldson et al., 1989
; Otha et al., 1989
; Fill et al.,
1990
; Carrier et al., 1991
; El-Hayek et al., 1995b
). Although early
studies suggested that the Ca2+ threshold for the
activation of Ca2+ release was significantly lower in MH
muscle (Nelson, 1983
; Ohnishi et al., 1983
; Fletcher et al., 1991b
),
quick release experiments showed a normal Ca2+-dependence
of SR Ca2+ release (Kim et al., 1984
; Fill et al., 1990
;
Carrier et al., 1991
). The sensitivity to H+ inhibition of
Ca2+ release was reduced in MH: at a pH of 6.5, MH-susceptible SR was still able to release Ca2+, whereas
Ca2+ release from normal SR was completely inhibited (Louis
et al., 1992
). No difference was observed with regard to the modulation by Mg2+, adenine nucleotides, and fatty acids, (Carrier et
al., 1991
; Fletcher et al., 1991b
), whereas some observations suggested
an increased sensitivity to caffeine (Nelson, 1983
; Ohnishi, 1987
).
Single-channel studies (Fill et al., 1990
; Shomer et al., 1993
, 1994a
;
Nelson and Lin, 1995
; Nelson et al., 1996
) showed that the
Ca2+ dependence of channel gating was abnormal. At optimal
Ca2+ concentration, channel Po was either normal or
slightly increased, but Ca2+-inactivation was not observed,
so that at pCa < 4 the Po was higher in MH than in control
preparations. At low pH (6.8), the Po of MH channels was significantly
higher at all Ca2+ concentrations in the range of 7 µM to 10 mM (Shomer et al., 1994b
, 1995
). In
contrast with the release experiments, the sensitivity to caffeine was
unchanged (Shomer et al., 1994b
), whereas the sensitivity to activation
by nanomolar dantrolene was reduced (Nelson et al., 1996
).
Binding experiments, performed on native membranes or purified
receptors, showed that the affinity for ryanodine was normal under
optimal binding conditions, but it was higher than normal under
suboptimal conditions, i.e., at low ionic strength or in the absence of
adenine nucleotides (Mickelson et al., 1988
, 1990
; Carrier et al.,
1991
; Vita et al., 1991
; Hawkes et al., 1992
). Ca2+
stimulation of ryanodine binding was normal (Mickelson et al., 1988
;
Hawkes et al., 1992
), whereas conflicting results were reported with
regard to Ca2+ inhibition, because increased
IC50 was observed by Mickelson et al. (1988)
, but not by
Hawkes et al. (1992)
.
The relationship between these defects in RyR1 function and the
occurrence of MH episodes has not been entirely understood. It has been
suggested that a MH episode may represent the "final common
pathway" resulting from the convergence of a number of small
abnormalities in the presence of a triggering stimulus, such as the
exposure to volatile anesthetics (Pessah et al., 1996
).
Porcine MH syndrome is associated with a mutation in a gene originally
designed as halothane gene (hal) or PSS gene, which is
inherited in an autosomal-recessive manner, so that only homozygotes manifest the disease and respond positively to the halothane/caffeine challenge test (Mabry et al., 1981
; Reik et al., 1983
). Pigs
hetorozygous for the MH allele are not susceptible to MH episodes, but
their muscles show abnormal in vitro responses. RyRs from heterozygous pigs are heterotetramers comprising normal and abnormal subunits, with
different gating kinetics, and more than one MH subunit per channel is
required to determine an abnormal function (Shomer et al., 1995
).
In pigs, the hal gene has been mapped to chromosome 6, through haplotype analysis of linked marker loci (Archibald and Imlah, 1985
; Davies et al., 1988
). The RyR1 gene has been mapped to the same
region of chromosome 6, namely band 6q12 (Harbitz et al., 1990
;
Chowdhary et al., 1994
). The comparison of RyR1 cDNA obtained from MH
and normal pigs (Fujii et al., 1991
) showed that only one of the
observed polymorphisms, namely replacement of cytidine with thymidine
at nucleotide 1843, affected the amino acid sequence, causing
replacement of arginine with cysteine at residue 615 (Arg615Cys). Linkage between the inheritance of this mutation and MH susceptibility has been clearly demonstrated in all the breeds of pigs examined (Otsu
et al., 1991
; MacLennan and Phillips, 1992
, 1995
). Pig MH appears to
have originated from a mutation occurring in a single animal, which was
probably selected because it is associated with positive consequences
with regard to pork production, namely increased lean meat content and
decreased back fat.
Cell lines have been transfected with normal and mutant (Arg615Cys)
RyR1 genes (Otsu et al., 1994
; Treves et al., 1994
). In the cells
expressing the mutant gene, resting Ca2+ concentration was
normal, but caffeine, halothane, and 4-chloro-m-cresol produced a larger increase in intracellular Ca2+ than in
the controls. The molecular mechanism by which the Arg615Cys mutation
alters channel function has not been clarified. Residue 615 is located
in the large cytoplasmic foot structure, but its function is unknown.
It is unlikely that this region may be involved in the ion conductance
pathway, and sequence analysis does not suggest the presence of binding
sites for any known RyR modulator.
Biochemical and physiological studies concerning human MH have not been
so informative and conclusive as those performed in the pig, due to the
limited amount of tissue obtained from muscle biopsies, to the quality
of the tissue and to the heterogeneity of the human disease. No defect
in SR Ca2+ uptake and storage has been demonstrated
convincingly (Mickelson and Louis, 1996
). On the other hand, an
increased rate of SR Ca2+ release was observed in skinned
fibers obtained from suspected patients suspected to have MH (Endo et
al., 1983
; Kawana et al., 1992
), whereas the threshold for
Ca2+-induced Ca2+ release was unchanged
(Fletcher et al., 1991b
, 1993
).
In single-channel recordings, Fill et al. (1991b)
did not detect
significant differences in conductance, Po, and
Ca2+-activation between normal and MH muscle, although
caffeine sensitivity was higher in the latter. Nelson (1992)
observed
increased halothane sensitivity of MH channels: whereas 2.2 to 17.6 µM halothane did not affect channel Po in normal muscle,
it increased channel Po in about 50% of MH patients. This author also
reported that halothane-sensitive channels had a higher basal Po.
In binding experiments (Valdivia et al., 1991b
), purified RyRs obtained
from human MH muscle showed an increased affinity for ryanodine and an
increased sensitivity to caffeine. The Ca2+ dependence of
ryanodine binding was abnormal. The Ca2+ concentration
required for half-maximal activation of binding was reduced, but no
abnormality was observed with regard to inhibition by high
Ca2+ concentration.
On the whole, the human studies confirmed the presence of RyR1
abnormalities, although the specific abnormalities were not identical
with those observed in MH-susceptible pigs.
In humans, MH-susceptibility is inherited as an autosomal dominant
trait. Association of the disease with a point mutation in the RyR1
gene in pigs stimulated similar investigations in humans (MacLennan et
al., 1990
). Human RyR1 gene has been mapped to region 19q13.1 in the
proximal long arm of chromosome 19 (MacKenzie et al., 1990). After the
identification of the Arg615Cys mutation in porcine MH, a homologous
mutation (ArgG14Cys) was identified in humans (Gillard et al., 1991
;
Hogan et al., 1992
), but cosegregation of this mutation with MH
susceptibility was observed in only a small fraction (about 5%) of
families with MH (Levitt et al., 1991
; Iles et al., 1992
; Ball et al.,
1993
; Fagerlund et al., 1994
, 1995
; Deufel et al., 1995
; Moroni et al.,
1995
; Steinfath et al., 1995
; Serfas et al., 1996
; Wallace et al.,
1996
). Other RyR1 point mutations have been reported, and these
probably account for additional forms of MH. Such mutations include
Arg163Cys, Gly248Arg, Gly341Arg, Tyr522Ser, Gly2433Arg (Gillard et al.,
1991
, 1992
; Keating et al., 1994
; Phillips et al., 1994
; Quane et al., 1993
, 1994a
,b
). Interestingly, all the mutations associated with MH or
with central core disease (see III.D.) produce amino acid changes
clustered around two regions of the large foot domain of the RyR1
molcule. On the whole, association of chromosome 19-linked mutations
with MH-susceptibility has been demonstrated in less than 50% of the
families examined (Ball and Johnson, 1993
; Pessah et al., 1996
),
although it should be noted that, in most studies, MH susceptibility
was identified on the basis of the in vitro contracture test, and the
threshold chosen to define the positive result influences the extent of
the genetic linkage. For instance, if the threshold used to indicate a
positive response is lowered, i.e., if weak positive responses are
taken into consideration, then the percentage of families with MH
showing RyR1 gene mutations increases substantially (MacKenzie et al.,
1991). In addition, it cannot be excluded that subtle RyR1
abnormalities, insufficient to produce a clear in vitro contracture,
may determine an abnormal reaction to anesthetics in vivo.
It has been speculated that the cases of MH susceptibility for which no
linkage to the RyR1 gene has been demonstrated may be caused by
mutations in other proteins involved in Ca2+ homeostasis,
but no conclusive results have been obtained so far. Loci that have
been tentatively associated with MH-susceptibility include
(a) region 17q11.2-24 on chromosome 17, coding for the
subunit of the Na+ channel and for the
and
subunits
of the dihydropyridine receptor; (b) a microsatellite close
to the
2/
dihydropyridine receptor subunit genes on
chromosome 7q; (c) region 1q31-q32 on chromosome 1, coding
for dihydropyridine receptor
1 subunit; and
(d) locus 3q13.1 on chromosome 3 (for further review, see
MacLennan and Sorrentino, 1995; Mickelson and Louis, 1996
).
D. Other Skeletal Muscle Diseases
Central core disease is a skeletal muscle disease transmitted as
an autosomal dominant trait and characterized by muscle hypotonia and
weakness, in which muscle biopsy shows fibers with single or multiple
discrete zones (cores) devoid of oxidative enzymes. The disease is
usually nonprogressive and, in many cases, it is associated with
predisposition to MH during general anesthesia. Genetic analysis has
mapped central core disease to chromosome 19q13.1 (Kausch et al., 1991
;
Mulley et al., 1993
; Schwemmle et al., 1993
), i.e., to the same locus
as MH susceptibility, suggesting that both diseases originate from
mutations in the RyR1 gene and therefore may be allelic. This
hypothesis has been confirmed by the identification of RyR1 gene
mutations in families with central core disease, e.g., Arg163Cys,
Ile403Met, Tyr522Ser, and Arg2433His (Quane et al., 1993
, 1994a
; Zhang
et al., 1993b
).
Myasthenia gravis is an acquired disease characterized by weakness and
fatigability of skeletal muscles. The basic defect is a decrease in the
number of available acetylcholine receptors at neuromuscular junctions,
due to the presence of anti-acetylcholine receptor autoantibodies.
Thymus abnormalities are frequent in myasthenia gravis patients, with
about 10% having thymic tumors (thymoma). Antibodies against RyR1 have
been detected in about 50% of the patients with myasthenia gravis and
thymoma, whereas they were absent in the cases not associated with
thymoma. The presence of RyR1 antibodies was correlated with the
severity of the disease, suggesting a pathogenetic role, but the
effects of the antibodies on SR Ca2+ release have not been
determined (Mygland et al., 1992a
,b
, 1993
, 1994
).
RyR1 alterations have been described in chicken dystrophy, an
autosomal-recessive myogenic disease that primarily affects fast-twitch
fibers. Whereas in normal muscle SR preparations the density of RyRs
decreased in the first days after birth, in dystrophic muscle, such
decrease did not occur, and the density of low-affinity binding sites
(KD in the range of 0.7 to 4.5 µM)
increased progressively (Pessah and Schiedt, 1990
). Qualitative
abnormalities were also observed, because in dystrophic muscle,
high-affinity ryanodine binding showed an increased sensitivity to
stimulation by caffeine and to inhibition by high Ca2+
concentrations.
The so-called crooked neck dwarf mutation of embryonic chicken has also
been associated with a RyR gene mutation. The normal
isoform of the
RyR could not be detected in skeletal muscle, and extremely low levels
of
-RyR immunoreactivity were observed with atypical distribution,
suggesting the presence of an abnormal
-RyR protein (Airey et al.,
1993a
).
RyR1 knockout mice (known as skrrm1) have been produced
recently (Takeshima et al., 1994
). No immunological evidence of RyR1 expression was obtained in homozygous mice carrying the mutation, and
skeletal muscle from these mice did not show any contractile response
to electrical stimulation. Mutant myocytes still released Ca2+ in response to caffeine, ryanodine, and adenine
nucleotides, which was attributed to the residual expression of RyR3
(Takeshima et al., 1995
). Mice homozygous for the mutation showed gross
developmental defects in the musculoskeletal system and were not viable
after birth, due to respiratory failure. At the subcellular level, the cytoplasmic "foot" domain of the RyR was missing, although
junctions between SR cisternae and T-tubules were still formed,
probably mediated by RyR-associated proteins (Takekura et al., 1995
).
Muscle fatigue is a term used to describe the decline in force
development during periods of repetitive contraction. Fatigue has been
associated with reduced Ca2+ transients, determined at
least in part by decreased SR Ca2+ release (Westerblad et
al., 1991
; Györke, 1993
). Accumulation of lactate,
H+, and Mg2+ might contribute to the process
(Favero et al., 1995b
), but primary RyR1 changes are also involved,
because SR vesicles isolated from fatigued muscle showed a depressed
ryanodine binding and a reduced rate of Ca2+ release
(Favero et al., 1993
).
Changes in the neural control of muscle function affect RyR1 expression
and function. In rat skeletal muscle, denervation caused a decrease in
RyR1 mRNA, whereas muscle paralysis, obtained by chronic superfusion of
the sciatic nerve with tetrodotoxin, produced the opposite effect (Ray
et al., 1995
). In the latter case, RyR1 up-regulation was confirmed by
Western blot analysis. In rabbit skeletal muscle, the rate of
doxorubicin-induced and caffeine-induced Ca2+ release
decreased after denervation, which was paradoxically associated with an
increased Bmax for [3H]ryanodine, suggesting
the presence of abnormal channels, and/or the occurrence of an isoform
shift (Zorzato et al., 1989
). The mechanism of these effects is
unknown, although it has been speculated that the cAMP cascade, PKC,
and nerve-derived factors may be involved.
E. Smooth Muscle and Nonmuscle Diseases
Very little is known about the role of RyRs in pathological
conditions not affecting striated muscle. Increased ryanodine binding
due to increased Bmax with unchanged
KD was observed in microsomal membranes obtained
from the rabbit bladder in a model of partial outlet obstruction (Levin
et al., 1994
). Indirect evidence of reduced caffeine-sensitive or
ryanodine-sensitive Ca2+ release was obtained in aortic
smooth muscle derived from spontaneous hypertensive rats (Aiello and
Grassi de Gende, 1995
). Finally, protection from ischemic neural injury
was described with dantrolene and trimethoxybenzoate derivatives, which
was attributed to modulation of SR Ca2+ release (Zhang et
al., 1993a
; Chiou and Hong, 1995
). As far as the role of RyR in disease
is concerned, these findings should be regarded as preliminary and
still need confirmation.
 |
IV. Conclusions |
The RyR was identified as the SR Ca2+ release channel
about 10 years ago; since that time, its regulation has been
intensively studied. The RyR is the largest of all the known ion
channels, and its structural complexity is matched by the myriad of
effects produced by endogenous and exogenous modulators. Different
patterns of modulation have been described, although these have not
been thoroughly categorized, and some modulators may produce multiple actions. In the present review, we propose a pharmacological
classification of these modulatory agents, based on their effects on
Ca2+ release, channel gating, and
[3H]ryanodine binding. This classification will need
revision as further knowledge is acquired. The number of RyR modulators
identified will certainly increase in the future. In fact, most drugs
analyzed in this review have other target sites of action, and
discovery of their actions at RyRs has been occasionally serendipitous. Efforts to develop specific RyR modulators have just begun.
The potential clinical implications of RyR modulation should not be
overlooked. Because the RyR has a central role in
excitation-contraction coupling, selective RyR modulators have the
potential to be highly effective tools for regulation of cardiac and
muscular function. In addition, the role of the RyR in disease is
becoming more and more clear. MH provides a unique example in which
mutations in the RyR1 gene have been related to a specific clinical
syndrome, in which RyR modulators, such as dantrolene, have proved to
be effective and already are used in patient management. Recent
investigations suggest that SR Ca2+ efflux may be of major
importance in the pathogenesis of myocardial ischemic injury and that
RyR modulation may be a new effective strategy in myocardial
protection. There is preliminary evidence that RyR alterations are
involved in the pathogenesis of heart failure, cardiomyopathies, and
degenerative skeletal muscle diseases. The role of the RyR in the
physiology and pathophysiology of nonmuscle tissues is a new research
field that is likely to produce substantial results in the near future.
The pharmacological modulators that are available at present show
serious limitations with regard to their clinical use. Many lack
selectivity, which may mask or limit effects at RyRs; others show an
irreversible action that is associated with serious toxic effects.
However, it is reasonable to hope that these limitations can be
overcome by future developments, and we believe that RyR modulation is
going to become at least as important as sarcolemmal Ca2+
channel modulation.
RyR, ryanodine receptor;
SR, sarcoplasmic reticulum;
Po, channel open probability;
KD, dissociation constant;
Bmax, binding site density;
ATPase, adenosine 5'-triphosphatase;
EC50, concentration giving half-maximal response;
IC50, concentration giving half-maximal inhibition;
AMP-PCP, adenosine 5'-(
,
-methylene)triphosphate;
AMP, adenosine
5'-monophosphate;
cAMP, cyclic AMP;
ADP, adenosine 5'-diphosphate;
CTP, cytosine 5'-triphosphate;
GTP, guanosine 5'-triphosphate;
ITP, inosine
5'-triphosphate;
UTP, uridine 5'-triphosphate;
cADPR, cyclic
ADP-ribose;
NAD, nicotinamide-adenine dinucleotide;
PKA, cAMP-dependent
protein kinase;
PKG, cGMP-dependent protein kinase;
PKC, protein kinase
C;
CaMK, calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II;
IP3, inositol 1,4,5 trisphosphate;
MBED, 9-methyl-7-bromoeudistomin D;
DTT, dithiothreitol;
DTDP, dithiodipyridine;
SPDP, N-succinimidyl
3-(2-pyridyldithio)propionate;
TMPyP, mesotetra-(4-N-methylpyridyl)-porphine tetraiodide;
W7, N-(6-aminohexyl)-5-chloro-1-naphtalene sulfonamide;
bisG10, 1,10-bis-guanidino-n-decane;
mRNA, messenger ribonucleic
acid;
MH, malignant hyperthermia.