Skip to main content
Log in

Ethical guidelines for the use of human embryonic or fetal tissue for experimental and clinical neurotransplantation and research

  • Original Communication
  • Published:
Journal of Neurology Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

Recently a Network of European CNS Transplantation And Restoration (NECTAR) has been founded, aimed at a concerted effort to develop efficient, reliable, safe and ethically acceptable transplantation therapies for neurodegenerative diseases, in particular Parkinson's and Huntington's disease. Owing to the use of human fetal brain tissue in such studies, usually obtained from elective abortions, ethical concerns have been focused on the relationship between abortion and transplantation activities. There is no uniform code on the retrieval and use of human embryonal or fetal material for experimental and clinical research or application in Europe. NECTAR has therefore formulated self-restraining ethical guidelines for its European member groups. These guidelines consist of a series of restrictions intended to prevent the use of grafts from encouraging induced abortions and to maintain high standards of respect for life and human dignity. In order to support applications for human embryonal or fetal neurotransplantation studies of NECTAR member groups to local or national medico-ethical committees, and to stimulate the goal of obtaining European legislation on this issue, the guidelines are here presented. They are followed by extensive explanatory notes. Only in this public manner can the lines of thought behind these NECTAR guidelines be addressed critically by those working in the fields of biomedical ethics and legislation as well by politicians and the general public.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  1. Allen GS, Burns RS, Tulipan NB, Parker RA (1989) Adrenal medullary transplantation to the caudate nucleus in Parkinson's disease. Arch Neurol 46:487–491

    Google Scholar 

  2. American Medical Association (1990) Medical applications of fetal tissue transplantation. JAMA 263:565–570

    Google Scholar 

  3. Backlund E-O, Granber P-O, Hamberger B, Sedvall G, Seiger A, Olson L (1985) Transplantation of adrenal medullary tissue to striatum in Parkinsonism. In: Björklund A, Stenevi U (eds) Neural grafting in the mammalian CNS. Fernström Foundation Series. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 551–556

    Google Scholar 

  4. Beauchamp TL, Childress JE (1989) Principles of biomedical ethics. Oxford University Press, New York

    Google Scholar 

  5. Björklund A, Stenevi U, Schmidt RH, Dunnett SB, Gage FH (1983) Intracerebral grafting of neuronal cell suspensions. I. Introduction and general methods of preparation. Acta Physiol Scand [Suppl] 522:1–7

    Google Scholar 

  6. BMA guidelines on the use of fetal tissue (1988) Lancet 1:1119

    Google Scholar 

  7. Boer GJ (1991) Notes for the discussion on the ethical issue of clinical neurotransplantation. Report at Founding meeting Network for European CNS Transplantation and Regeneration (NECTAR), Le Vésinet, May 10–11

  8. Bopp J, Burtchaell JT (1988) Report of the Human Fetal Tissue Research Panel, vol 1. US Government Printing Office, Washington, pp 45–71

    Google Scholar 

  9. Brundin P, Nilsson PG, Strecker RE, Lindvall O, Astedt B, Björklund A (1986) Behavioural effects of human fetal dopamine neurons grafted in a rat model of Parkinson's disease. Exp Brain Res 65:235–240

    Google Scholar 

  10. Burnell GM, Norfleet MA (1987) Women's self-reported responses to aborton. J Psychol 121:71–76

    Google Scholar 

  11. Burtchaell JT (1988) Case study: Unversity policy on experimental use of aborted fetal tissue. IRB: A Review of Human Subject Research 10:7–11

    Google Scholar 

  12. Capron AM, Kass LR (1976) A statutory definition of the standards for determining human death. In: Humber JM, Almeder RF (eds) Biomedical ethics and the law. Plenum Press, New York, pp 489–522

    Google Scholar 

  13. Committee of the Netherlands Health Council (1984) Advice on donation and use of fetuses, fetal tissue and other remains of abortion for scientific purposes (Kuitert report). Health Council of The Netherlands, The Hague, no. 19

    Google Scholar 

  14. Committee on Science and Technology (1988) Report on scientific research relating to the human embryo and foetus (Rapporteur: A. Palacios). Parliamentary Assembly of Council of Europe, Strasbourg, Doc 5943

    Google Scholar 

  15. Department of Health and Social Security (1972) The use of fetuses and fetal material for research, report of the advisory group (Peel report) Her Majesty's Stationary Office, London

    Google Scholar 

  16. Dutch Committee on Ethical Aspects of Medical Research (1993) Annual Report 1991 and 1992. Health Council of the Netherlands, The Hague, Publication K93/01

    Google Scholar 

  17. Faria G, Barett E, Goodman LA (1985) Women and abortion: attitudes, social networks, decision-making. Soc Work Health Care 11:85–99

    Google Scholar 

  18. Frankowski SJ, Cole GF (eds) (1987) Abortion and protection of the human fetus. Martinus Nijhoff, Dordrecht

    Google Scholar 

  19. Freed CR, Breeze RE, Rosenberg NL, Schneck SA, Kriek E, Qi J, Lone T, Zhang Y, Snyder JA, Wells TH, Ramig LO, Thompson L, Mazziotta JC, Huang SC, Grafton ST, Brooks D, Sawle G, Schroter G, Ansari AA (1992) Survival of implanted fetal dopamine cells and neurologic improvement 12 to 46 months after transplantation for Parkinson's disease. N Engl J Med 327:1549–1555

    Google Scholar 

  20. Gareth Jones D (1991) Fetal neural transplantation: placing the ethical debate within the context of society's use of human material. Bioethics 5:23–43

    Google Scholar 

  21. Garry DJ, Caplan AL, Vawter DE, Kearney W (1992) Are there really alternatives to the use of fetal tissue from elective abortions in transplantation research? N Engl J Med 327:1592–1595

    Google Scholar 

  22. Gash DM, Collier TJ, Sladek Jr JR (1985) Neural transplantation: a review of recent developments and potential applications to the aged brain. Neurobiol Aging 6:131–150

    Google Scholar 

  23. Goetz CG, Olanow CW, Killer WC, Penn RD, Cahill D, Morantz R, Stebbins G, Tanner CM, Klawans HL, Shannon KM, Comella CL, Witt T, Cox C, Waxman M, Gauger L (1989) Multicenter study of autologous adrenal medullary transplantation to the corpus striatum in patients with advanced Parkinson's disease. N Engl J Med 320:337–341

    Google Scholar 

  24. Greely HT, Hamm T, Johnson R, Price CR, Weingarten R, Raffin T, The Stanford University Medical Center Committee on Ethics (1989) The ethical use of human fetal tissue in medicine. N Engl J Med 320:1093–1096

    Google Scholar 

  25. Hansen JT, Sladek Jr JR (1989) Fetal research. Science 246:775–779

    Google Scholar 

  26. Henderson BTH, Clough CG, Hughes RC, Hitchcock ER, Kenny BG (1991) Implantation of human fetal ventral mesencephalon to the right caudate nucleus in advanced Parkinson's disease. Arch Neurol 48:822–827

    Google Scholar 

  27. Her Majesty's Stationary Office (HMSO) (1989) Review of the guidance on the research and use of fetuses and fetal material (Polkinghorne report), London, Cm 762

  28. Hoffer BJ, Olson L (1991) Ethical issues in brain-cell transplantation. TINS 14:384–388

    Google Scholar 

  29. Isacson O, Hantraye P, Riche D, Schumacher JM, Maziere M (1991) The relationship between symptoms and functional anatomy in the chronic neurodegenerative diseases: from pharmacological to biological therapy in Huntington's disease. In: Lindvall O, Björklund A, Widner H (eds) Intracerebral transplantation in movement disorders. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 245–258

    Google Scholar 

  30. Jacobson M (1991) Developmental neurobiology. Plenum Press, New York

    Google Scholar 

  31. Jiang N, Jiang C, Tang Z, Zhang F, Li S, Jiang D (1987) Human foetal brain transplant trials in the treatment of Parkinsonism. Acta Acad Med Shanghai 14:1

    Google Scholar 

  32. King P, Areen J (1988) Legal regulation of fetal tissue transplantation. Clin Res 36:205–208

    Google Scholar 

  33. Kolarik J, Nádvornik P, Tabarka K, Dvorák M (1988) Successful therapeutic transplantation of human embryonic nerve tissue into a schizophrenic brain. Activ Nerv Sup 30:155–157

    Google Scholar 

  34. Koller WC (ed) (1987) Handbook of Parkinson's disease. Dekker, New York

    Google Scholar 

  35. Lawler SD (1981) Conceptation and development of the Fetal Tissue Bank. J Clin Pathol 34:240–248

    Google Scholar 

  36. Legal Affairs Committee (1989) Report on the use of human embryos and foetuses in scientific research (rapporteur: A. Elmquist). Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, Strasbourg, Doc 5996

    Google Scholar 

  37. Lennette EH, Halonen P, Murphy FA (eds) (1988) Laboratory diagnosis of infectious diseases. Principles and practice, vol II. Springer, New York Berlin Heidelberg

    Google Scholar 

  38. Lindvall O, Brundin P, Widner H, Rehncrona S, Gustavii B, Frackowiak R, Leenders KL, Sawle G, Rothwell JC, Marsden CD, Björklund A (1990) Grafts of fetal dopamine neurons survive and improve motor function on Parkinson's disease. Science 247:574–577

    Google Scholar 

  39. Lindvall O, Widner H, Rehncrona S, Brundin P, Odin P, Gustavii B, Frackowiak R, Leenders KL, Sawle G, Rothwell JC, Björklund A, Marsden CD (1992) Transplantation of fetal dopamine neurons in Parkinson's disease: one-year clinical and neurophysiological observations in two patients with putaminal implants. Ann Neurol 31:155–165

    Google Scholar 

  40. López Lozano JJ, Bravo G, Brera B, Uria J, De Argello J, Salmean J, Insausti J, CPH Neural Transplantation Group (1991) Can an analogy be drawn between the clinical evaluation of Parkinson's patients who undergo autoimplantation of adrenal medulla and those of fetal ventral mesencephalon transplant recipients? Restor Neurol 4:87–98

    Google Scholar 

  41. MacDonald AS (1990) Foetal neuroendocrine tissue transplantation for Parkinson's disease: an institutional review board faces the ethical dilemma. Transplant Proc 22:1030–1032

    Google Scholar 

  42. Madrazo I, Drucker-Colin R, Diaz V, Martinez-Mata J, Torres C, Becerril JJ (1987) Open microsurgical autograft of adrenal medulla to the right caudate nucleus in two patients with intractable Parkinson's disease. N Engl J Med 316:831–834

    Google Scholar 

  43. Madrazo I, Franco-Bourland M, Aguilera M, Ostrosky-Solis F, Cuevas C, Castregon H, Velazquez D, Grijalva E, Guizar-Sahagun G, Magallon E, Madrazo M (1991) Fetal ventral mesencephalon brain homotransplantation in Parkinson's disease: the Mexican experience. In: Lindvall O, Björklund A, Widner H (eds) Intracerebral transplantation in movement disorders, restorative neurology 4. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 123–130

    Google Scholar 

  44. Mahowald MB (1988) Placing wedges along a slippery slope: use of fetal neural tissue for transplantation. Clin Res 36:220–222

    Google Scholar 

  45. May WF (1990) Brain death: anencephalics and aborted fetuses. Transplant Proc 22:985–988

    Google Scholar 

  46. McCullagh PM (1987) The foetus as transplant donor. Scientific, social and ethical perspectives. Wiley, Chichester

    Google Scholar 

  47. McLaren A (1989) Report on the use of human foetal embryonic and preembryonic material for diagnostic, therapeutic, scientific, industrial and commercial purposes. Select Committee of Experts on the Use of Human Embryos and Foetuses, Council of Europe, Strasbourg, CAHBI-R-EF: 1

    Google Scholar 

  48. Minister's Deputies of the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe (1989) Use of human embryos and foetuses. Council of Europe, Strasbourg, Doc 7244

    Google Scholar 

  49. Molina H, Quiñones R, Alvarez L, Galarraga J, Piedra J, Suárez C, Rachid M, García JC, Perry TL, Santana A, Carmenate H, Macías R, Torres O, Rojas MJ, Córdova F, Muñoz JL (1991) Transplantation of human fetal mesencephalic tissue in caudate nucleus as treatment for Parkinson's disease: the Cuban experience. In: Lindvall O, Björklund A, Widner H (eds) Intracerebral transplantation in movement disorders, restorative neurology 4. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 99–110

    Google Scholar 

  50. Mollison PL, Engelfriet CP, Contreras M (1987) Blood transfusion in clinical medicine. Blackwell, Oxford, pp 764–806

    Google Scholar 

  51. National Consultative Ethics Committee for Life Sciences and Health (CNESVS) (1984) Recommendation on the use of embryo tissue as well as tissue of dead foetuses for therapeutic, diagnostic and scientific purposes. Le Comité, Paris

    Google Scholar 

  52. National Consultative Ethics Committee for Life Sciences and Health (CNESVS) (1990) Statement on intracerebral graft of mesencephalic tissue of human embryo origin in patients with Parkinsonism for therapeutic experimentation. Le Comité, Paris

    Google Scholar 

  53. NECTAR (1993) A new program for NECTAR: neural transplants in patients with Huntington's disease. NECTAR Newsl 5

  54. Nolan K (1990) The use of embryo or fetus in transplantation: what there is to lose. Transplant Proc 22:1028–1029

    Google Scholar 

  55. Olson L (1988) Grafting in the mammalian central nervous system: Basic science with clinical promise. Discussion in Neuroscience, vol 5, no. 4, FESN, Geneva

    Google Scholar 

  56. O'Rahilly R, Müller F (1987) Developmental stages in human embryos. Carnegie Institution of Washington, Washington

    Google Scholar 

  57. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (1986) On the use of human embryos and foetuses for diagnostic, therapeutic, scientific, industrial and commercial purposes. Council of Europe, Strasbourg, Recommendation 1046

    Google Scholar 

  58. Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (1989) On the use of human embryos and foetuses for scientific research Council of Europe, Strasbourg, Recommendation 1100

    Google Scholar 

  59. Ralph MR, Foster RG, Davis FC, Menaker M (1990) Transplanted suprachiasmatic nucleus determines circadian period. Science 247:975–978

    Google Scholar 

  60. Robertson JA (1988) Rights, symbolism and public policy in fetal tissue transplants. Hastings Center Report 6

  61. Robertson JA (1990) The ethical acceptability of fetal tissue transplants. Transplant Proc 22:1025–1027

    Google Scholar 

  62. Sladek JR Jr, Shoulson I (1988) Neural transplantation: a call for patience rather than patients. Science 240:1386–1388

    Google Scholar 

  63. Spanish law 42, governing the donation and utilization of human embryos and fetuses, or their cells, tissues or organs, December 1988

  64. Spencer DD, Robbins RJ, Naftolin F, Phil D, Marek KL, Vollmer T, Leranth C, Roth RH, Price LH, Gjedde A, Bunney BS, Sass KJ, Elsworth JD, Kier EL, Makuch R, Hoffer PB, Redmond DE Jr (1992) Unilateral transplantation of human fetal mesencephalic tissue into the caudate nucleus of patients with Parkinson's disease. N Engl J Med 327:1541–1548

    Google Scholar 

  65. US Department of Health and Human Services. Public Health Services and National Institutes of Health (1988) Report of the Human Fetal Tissue Transplantation Research Panel. US Government Printing Office, Washington

    Google Scholar 

  66. Walters L (1988) Ethical issues in fetal research: a look back and a look forward. Clin Res 36:209–214

    Google Scholar 

  67. Warren MA (1975) On the moral and legal status of abortion. In: Wasserstrom R (ed) Today's moral problems. McMillan, New York, pp 120–136

    Google Scholar 

  68. Widner H, Tetrud J, Rehncrona S, Snow B, Brundin P, Gustavii B, Björklund A, Lindvall O, Langston JW (1992) Bilateral fetal mesencephalic grafting in two patients with Parkinsonism induced by 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP). N Engl J Med 327:1556–1563

    Google Scholar 

  69. Woods L, Gutierrez Y (1993) Diagnostic pathology of infectious diseases. Lea & Febiger, Philadelphia, pp 573–584

    Google Scholar 

  70. Working Group on Human Embryos and Research (HER) (1992) First report, EC, Directorate General XII Science Research 2nd Development, Brussels

  71. World Medical Association (1990) Statement on fetal tissue transplantation. Bulletin February, pp 8–10

  72. Yezzi R (1980) Medical ethics, thinking about unavoidable questions. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Additional information

NECTAR: M. Peschanski, Secretariat NECTAR, INSERM CJF 91-02 Faculté de Médecine 8 rue du Général Sarrail 94010 Créteil Cedex France

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Boer, G.J. Ethical guidelines for the use of human embryonic or fetal tissue for experimental and clinical neurotransplantation and research. J Neurol 242, 1–13 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00920568

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Revised:

  • Accepted:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00920568

Key words

Navigation