The effects of suggestion on airways of asthmatic subjects breathing room air as a suggested bronchoconstrictor and bronchodilator

https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-3999(92)90135-OGet rights and content

Abstract

Thirty-three asthmatic subjects were told they were receiving, alternately, an inhaled bronchoconstrictor and inhaled bronchodilator, although they actually were only breathing room air. No subjects showed suggestion-produced effects on FEV1, although two (of the 19 on whom FEF50 was measured) showed effects of greater than 20% on measures of maximal midexpiratory flow. The incidence of the effect is smaller than reported previously, possibly because some subjects in previous studies inhaled saline, a mild bronchoconstrictor, and reversal of effect was not required for classification as a reactor. Higher percentages of subjects in this study showed decreased MMEF in response to the ‘bronchoconstrictor’, but this appeared to reflect fatigue rather than suggestion effects. However, the fact that the effect occurred in a relatively non-effort-dependent measure suggests that real changes occurred in bronchial caliber, not just in test effort. Suggestion had a significant effect on perception of bronchial changes, but the correlation between actual and perceived changes was minimal. There was an increase in FVC prior to administration of the ‘bronchoconstrictor’, possibly reflecting a preparatory response to the expected drug. Correlations among self-report variables suggested the existence of three personality dimensions among our population related to suggestion and asthma: cognitive susceptibility to suggestion of bronchial change; feeling of physical vulnerability; and anxiety. However, there was no significant relationship between airway response to suggested changes and hypnotic susceptibility, as measured by the Harvard Group Scale of Hypnotic Susceptibility.

References (23)

  • RL Philipp et al.

    Suggestion and relaxation in asthmatics

    J Psychosom Res

    (1972)
  • H Chai et al.

    Standardization of bronchial inhalation challenge procedures

    J All Clin Immunol

    (1975)
  • A Khan

    The effects of biofeedback and counterconditioning in the control of bronchial asthma

    J Psychosomatics

    (1977)
  • TJ Luparello et al.

    Influences of suggestion on airway reactivity in asthmatic subjects

    Psychosom Med

    (1968)
  • SA Isenberg et al.

    The effects of suggestion and emotional arousal on asthma

    Psychosom Med

    (1992)
  • ER McFadden et al.

    The mechanism of action of suggestion in the induction of acute asthma attacks

    Psychosom Med

    (1969)
  • J Weiss et al.

    Effects of suggestion on respiration in asthmatic children

    Psychosom Med

    (1970)
  • EA Pastorello et al.

    The role of suggestion in asthma. I. Effects of inactive solution on bronchial reactivity under bronchoconstrictor or bronchodilator suggestion

    Ann Allergy

    (1987)
  • DJ Horton et al.

    Bronchoconstriction in asthma: a role for airways hyperreactivity and emotion

    Am Rev Resp Dis

    (1978)
  • JE Neild et al.

    Bronchoconstriction in response to suggestion: its prevention by an inhaled anticholinergic agent

    Br Med J

    (1985)
  • A Khan et al.

    Hypnotic suggestibility compared with other methods of isolating emotionally-prone asthmatic children

    Am J Clin Hypn

    (1974)
  • Cited by (30)

    • Transportation noise exposure, noise annoyance and respiratory health in adults: A repeated-measures study

      2018, Environment International
      Citation Excerpt :

      Our observation of positive associations of noise level with respiratory symptoms in asthmatics may indicate their higher vulnerability to stressors (Ritz et al., 2000). Asthmatics may be more sensitive to chronic stress-induced immune system dysfunction (Schmid-Ott et al., 2001) and smooth-muscle reactivity (Isenberg et al., 1992). More so, associations were stronger in asthmatics on medication given the weakening of associations on their exclusion, showing increased effects with disease severity.

    • Inhaled peppermint, rosemary and eucalyptus essential oils do not change spirometry in healthy individuals

      2018, Physiology and Behavior
      Citation Excerpt :

      An interaction between the suggestions and the effects of bronchodilator and bronchoconstrictor drugs was also demonstrated [31]. These findings were replicated in a number of studies [32–36]. Although null findings and methodological criticisms were also reported [37–39], it was concluded that the placebo effect might play a role in the treatment of chronic obstructive diseases such as asthma [40–43].

    • Do asthma patients with panic disorder really have worse asthma? A comparison of physiological and psychological responses to a methacholine challenge

      2015, Respiratory Medicine
      Citation Excerpt :

      Two potential pathways have been proposed to explain the PD-worse asthma outcomes association: one postulates a direct physiological pathway where panic leads to physiological changes (e.g., increased cardiorespiratory reactivity such as heart rate, carbon dioxide partial pressure, and respiratory rate) [17,18] via increased autonomic nervous activation that may be causally linked to asthma [5–7]. The other proposes that PD patients' tendency to catastrophize bodily sensations is associated with increased symptom reporting, resulting in greater treatment-seeking, independent of worse asthma [16,19–23]. Previous evidence supports both hypotheses, but has suffered from methodological weaknesses: a failure to objectively diagnose asthma [22,24], often relying upon self-reported diagnoses which are subject to bias [25]; a failure to use a validated psychiatric interview to diagnose PD [22,26], over-relying on questionnaire measures of panic-like anxiety which are insufficient to confirm PD diagnoses; and the use of resting spirometry as the sole objective measures of asthma [23,27], which may appear normal when asthma is well controlled [28].

    • Do "placebo responders" exist?

      2008, Contemporary Clinical Trials
    • Psychological triggers and hyperventilation symptoms in asthma

      2008, Annals of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology
      Citation Excerpt :

      Observational and experimental studies1-3 have established a role for psychosocial factors, such as life events, distress, or various mood states or emotions, in asthmatic symptom episodes and lung function decline; reviews are also available.4-7

    View all citing articles on Scopus

    This paper is based on the Masters' thesis of the senior author at Rutgers University. The work was supported by Grant # HL44097, from the Heart, Lung and Blood Institute of the National Institutes of Health. Some of this material was presented previously at the annual meeting of the Society for Psychophysiological Research, Boston 17–20 October 1990.

    View full text