Assessment of pain in animals

doi:10.1016/S0003-3472(05)80127-7

Animal Behaviour

Volume 42, Issue 5, November 1991, Pages 827-839

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0003-3472(05)80127-7 Get rights and content

Abstract

Judgements about pain and suffering in animals are required by the law of many countries and by many professional guidelines. Nevertheless, such assessments raise many problems, even in humans. Furthermore, an appeal to continuities between humans and other animals is clouded when, as is still the case, both the evolution and the function of a subjective sense of pain are obscure. Despite these difficulties, the criteria that lead to the judgement that a human is in pain can be generalized with substantial measure of agreement to other animals. This generalization is done on the basis of uncovering comparable mechanisms and comparable behaviour; then the whole cluster of features found in the animal is used to make the judgement. The less similar the animal to a human and the less complex it is, the more difficult is the assessment. The fuzziness of the boundary between those animals that are judged to feel pain and those that are not does not invalidate the process of assessment. However, the extent to which an animal is given the benefit of the doubt clearly depends on the empathy a person feels for it as well as the type of ethical concerns that motivate the person.

References (59)

ChudlerE.H. et al.
The assessment of pain by cerebral evoked potentials
Pain
(1983)
ColpaertF.C. et al.
Chronic pain
Life Sci.
(1980)
DriscollJ.W. et al.
Animals in behavioural research
Anim. Behav.
(1988)
KavaliersM.
Evolutionary and comparative aspects of nociception
Brain Res. Bull.
(1988)
RowanA.N.
Animal anxiety and animal suffering
Appl. Anim. Behav. Sci.
(1988)
WallP.
On the relation of injury to pain
Pain
(1979)
BatesonP.
When to experiment on animals
New Scient.
(1986)
BatesonP.
Animal communication

BroomD.M.

Indicators of poor welfare

Br. vet. J.

(1986)

BurghardtG.M.

Animal awareness

Am. Psychol.

(1985)

CrookJ.H.

On attributing consciousness to animals

Nature, Lond.

(1983)

DawkinsM.S.

Attitudes to animals

DawkinsM.S.

From an animal's point of view: motivation, fitness and animal welfare

Behav. Brain Sci.

(1990)

DennettD.C.

Intentional systems in cognitive ethology: the ‘Panglossian paradigm’ defended

Behavl Brain Sci.

(1983)

DennettD.C.

DickinsonA.

DudaiY. et al.

dunce, a mutant of Drosophila deficient in learning

Proc. natn. Acad Sci., U.S.A.

(1976)

EisemannC.H. et al.

Do insects feel pain? A biological view

Experientia

(1984)

EwbankR.

Behavioral responses to stress in farm animals

FlecknellP.A.

Recognition and alleviation of pain in animals

GoodallJ.

GriffinD.R.

HaraT.J.

Role of olfaction in fish behaviour

HebbD.O.

Cited by (290)

Study on the quality of Corydalis Rhizoma in Zhejiang based on multidimensional evaluation method
2024, Journal of Ethnopharmacology
The quality requirements of Corydalis Rhizoma (CR) in different producing areas are uniform, resulting in uneven efficacy. As a genuine producing area, the effective quality control of CR in Zhejiang Province (ZJ) could provide a theoretical basis for the rational application of medicinal materials.
The purpose of this study was to effectively distinguish the CR inside and outside ZJ, and provided a theoretical basis for the quality control and material basis research of ZJ CR.
The core components of ZJ CR could be identified by HPLC combined with chemometrics screening, and the quality of CR from different producing areas was evaluated by a genetic algorithm-back propagation (GA-BP) neural network. Chromaticity and near-infrared (NIR) spectroscopy were used to identify CR inside and outside ZJ, and rapid content prediction was realized. The analgesic effect of CR in different regions was compared by a zebrafish analgesic experiment. Analgesic experiments in rats and analysis of the research status of quality components were used to screen the quality control components of ZJ CR.
The contents of palmatine hydrochloride (YSBMT), dehydrocorydaline (TQZJJ), tetrahydropalmatine (YHSYS), tetrahydroberberine (SQXBJ), corydaline (YHSJS), stylopine (SQHLJ), and isoimperatorin (YOQHS) in ZJ CR were higher than those in CR from outside ZJ, but the content of protopine (YAPJ) and berberine hydrochloride (YSXBJ) was lower than that in CR from outside ZJ. YHSJS and SQHLJ could be used as the core components to identify ZJ CR. The GA-BP neural network showed that the relative importance of ZJ CR was the strongest. Chroma-content correlation analysis and the NIR qualitative model could effectively distinguish CR from inside and outside of ZJ, and the NIR quantitative model could quickly predict the content of CR from inside and outside of ZJ. Zebrafish experiments showed that ZJ, Shaanxi (SX), Henan (HN), and Sichuan (SC) CR had significant analgesic effects, while Hebei (HB) CR had no significant analgesic effect. Overall comparison, the analgesic effect of ZJ CR was better than that of CR outside ZJ. The comprehensive score of the grey correlation degree between YAPJ, YSBMT, YSXBJ, TQZJJ, YHSYS, YHSJS, SQXBJ, and SQHLJ were higher than 0.9, and the research frequency were extremely high.
The relative importance of the content and origin of most components of ZJ CR was higher than that of CR outside ZJ. The holistic analgesic effect of ZJ CR was better than that of CR outside ZJ, but slightly lower than that of SX CR. YHSJS and SQHLJ could be used as the core components to identify ZJ CR. YAPJ, YSBMT, YSXBJ, TQZJJ, YHSYS, SQXBJ, YHSJS, and SQHLJ could be used as the quality control components of ZJ CR. The multidimensional evaluation method used in this study provided a reference for the quality control and material basis research of ZJ CR.
Guidelines for the ethical treatment of nonhuman animals in behavioural research and teaching
2024, Animal Behaviour
Sheep health behavior analysis in machine learning: A short comprehensive survey
2023, Smart Agricultural Technology
Sheep management and production enhancement are difficult for farmers due to the lack of dynamic response and poor welfare of the sheep. Poor welfare needs to be mitigated, and each farm must receive an expert-level assessment of critical importance. To mitigate poor welfare, researchers have conducted machine learning-based studies to automate the sheep health behavior monitoring process instead of using manual assessment. However, failure to recognize some sheep health behaviors degrades the performance of the model. In addition, behavior challenges, parameters, and analysis must be considered when conducting a study based on machine learning. In this paper, we discuss the different challenges: what are the parameters of the sheep health behaviors, and how to analyze the sheep health behaviors for automated machine learning systems to be helpful in the long term? The hypothesis is based on a different review of the literature of precision-based animal welfare monitoring systems with the potential to improve management and production.
Relationship among indicators of pain and stress in response to piglet surgical castration: an exploratory analysis
2023, Journal of Veterinary Behavior
Multi-dimensional approaches are suggested as advantageous for evaluation of pain and/or stress at piglet castration, but the interpretation of data from such approaches is limited by a lack of understanding of relationships among different types of indicators and associated parameters. This paper used an exploratory approach to evaluate the interrelationships between different physiological, vocal, and behavioral indicators obtained during and after surgical castration of 580 piglets aged 3-4 days. The data, obtained from two experimental studies, were examined by analyses of correlations and by principal component analyses (PCA). Principal components were analyzed in mixed effects models. Each type of indicator (vocalization, resistance movement, saliva cortisol concentration, behavioral response in a social motivation test, behavior in the home pen, reaction to human) mainly contributed to separate principal components in the PCA and showed relatively low correlation coefficients between each other, indicating a variation in the response explained by the indicator types. Even within a type of indicator, specific parameters were, in several cases, found to explain different aspects of the piglet response. Overall, the results point to the importance of careful consideration of the differences existing among indicator types and highlight the need for further methodological development in that domain.
Pain assessment in laboratory species
2023, Anesthesia and Analgesia in Laboratory Animals
Pain recognition, prevention, and alleviation in research animals are important from an animal welfare, ethical, and legal standpoint. The ideal pain assessment tool would be reliable, sensitive, valid, practical, easily applicable, and generalizable. Whilst there are a number of physiological and behavioral markers available, the latter is more likely to be applicable in clinical decision making. Therefore, the use of animal-based indices and pain-specific behaviors is widespread as a method of pain assessment. There are many challenges in the selection of an appropriate pain assessment strategy, including, for example, species and strain differences in pain-related behaviors. Tools may also be complex, require prior training and experience, or be nongeneralizable. Good record maintenance and referral to records aid in the achievement of objectivity in assessment, as well as transparency in decision-making.
Pain Recognition in Rodents
2023, Veterinary Clinics of North America - Exotic Animal Practice

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text