The thrombin receptor PAR1 is activated when thrombin cleaves the receptor's amino-terminal exodomain to reveal the new N-terminal sequence SFLLRN which then acts as a tethered peptide ligand. Free SFLLRN activates PAR1 independent of receptor cleavage and has been used to probe PAR1 function in various cells and tissues. PAR1-expressing cells desensitized to thrombin retain responsiveness to SFLLRN. Toward determining the mechanism of such responses, we utilized fibroblasts derived from a PAR1-deficient mouse. These cells were unresponsive to thrombin and SFLLRN and became sensitive to both ligands after transfection with human PAR1 cDNA. Moreover, PAR1-transfected cells responded to SFLLRN after thrombin-desensitization, indicating that signaling of thrombin-desensitized cells to SFLLRN was mediated by PAR1 itself. SFLLRN caused signaling in thrombin-desensitized cells when no uncleaved PAR1 was detectable on the cell surface; however, cleaved PAR1 was present. To determine whether the cleaved receptors could still signal, fibroblasts were transfected with a PAR1 mutant containing a trypsin site/SFLLRN sequence carboxyl terminal to the native thrombin site. These cells retained responsiveness to trypsin after thrombin-desensitization. Conversely, fibroblasts expressing a PAR1 mutant with the trypsin site/SFLLRN sequence amino terminal to the native thrombin site retained responsiveness to thrombin after trypsin-desensitization. This suggests that a population of thrombin-cleaved PAR1 can respond both to exogenous SFLLRN and to a second tethered ligand. In this population, the tethered ligand unmasked by thrombin cleavage must not be functional, suggesting the possibility of a novel mechanism of receptor shutoff involving sequestration or modification of the tethered ligand to prevent or terminate its function.